Yuku free message boards

Well shit. Forgot to vote. Finally did a rewatch today so here would be my guesses on the close calls:

Rating:
Ashley: OTT - Her entire persona now is "the cute lazy chick on Ometepe" based on that episode. Not enough insight to be MOR.
Grant: UTR - The content of his edit is the same as any other UTR - fluffy, useless, vapid footage. He just has more of it. Again, why is he potentially getting the same rating as "almost CP but not quite?" It will just add confusion to the chart.
Rob: CP/MOR - I could see it either way. I think the opening is classic CP, but beyond that it was CP-lite. My gut says CP, but I could see MOR making sense.

Tone:
Krista: NEGATIVE! Look at the numbers with M broken down:
People who saw positive manipulation: 6 + 2 = 8
People who saw negative manipulation: 6 + 7 = 13 (majority)
People who saw no manipulation: 7
People who saw both positive and negative manipulation: 6

This one's closer than usual but I still think that when you pull the numbers apart, N comes up the victor.

Stephanie: Neutral. Weird close call. I wasn't paying much attention to this. Honestly I didn't note a ton of actual MANIPULATION in her edit either way. She's an N character in a P position. She got lots of negative SPV from negative/neutral-negative characters and was the classic "underdog." If it went M, though, I wouldn't think of it as a crime.

Visibility:
David: 3. Going super-strictly by the numbers he's a 3. I'd include an argument about the benefits of objectivity over subjectivity here, but there's no point in repeating it, right?

Winners:
Stephanie
Andrea
Matt
Natalie

Eliminated:
Everyone else..... except for....... GAHH fine. Rob! He's still got an outside shot, even as an Edgic contender. I have serious doubts but I'll hold off thanks to Phoenix's argument.