More what if moments... in Lions, Tigers, Survivors

0 Points

More what if moments...

Started By	Comment
karl100589		#1041	[-]
Posts: 882 (04/23/11 03:16 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Ads no more Remove this ad What if Fran had beaten Godboy in the first round of Redemption Island? and What if Allstars 1 had a Heroes Vs Villains format?
ROFLROOSTER		#1042	[-]
Posts: 629 (04/23/11 03:24 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I don't think this has been done yet, what if Rob was on Zapatello and Rus on Ometepe
SirCrocodilep		#1043	[-]
Posts: 15541 (04/23/11 04:13 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	what if JFP ran for the tribe?
Noctivagant		#1044	[-]
Posts: 1338 (04/23/11 04:29 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	et91 wrote: Hmm, JT would still have his HII as would Parvati 12th: Amanda(Courtney and Sandra flip but JT idiotically assumes that Parvati is the biggest threat and has no chance of having an idol, however he plays his idol right after Parv plays hers, leading to a new revote, where the Heroes are a mess as they didn't have a plan B, while the Villains had their plan B in Amanda) 11th: Parvati(JT's plan works out now, but he becomes more of a paranoid bitch as the game goes on) 10th: Russell(get him out before he finds ANOTHER immunity idol) 9th: JT(Candice is tired of JT as are Courtney and Sandra, and they vote him out before he goes on an immunity run) 8th: Candice(Heroes pissed off at the trio, but most hate at Candice, Coach and Jerri flip to vote off Candice) 7th: Danielle(last remnants of R-P-D alliance) 6th: Rupert(The 4 villains come back together) 5th: Colby(last Hero standing falls) 4th: Sandra(tie between Coach and Sandra, Coach wins fire making competition) Final 3: Jerri, Coach, Courtney Amanda: Courtney Parvati: Jerri Russell: Jerri JT: Coach Candice: Jerri Danielle: Jerri Rupert: Coach Colby: Coach Sandra: Courtney Jerri wins HvV 4-3-2 If all votes remained the same except Parv's who I think would have voted Courtney rather than Jerri then we would have had our first tie in the F3.
TheThrillseeker		#1045	[-]
Posts: 21 (04/23/11 04:47 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	et91 wrote: Hmm, JT would still have his HII as would Parvati 12th: Amanda(Courtney and Sandra flip but JT idiotically assumes that Parvati is the biggest threat and has no chance of having an idol, however he plays his idol right after Parv plays hers, leading to a new revote, where the Heroes are a mess as they didn't have a plan B, while the Villains had their plan B in Amanda) 11th: Parvati(JT's plan works out now, but he becomes more of a paranoid bitch as the game goes on) 10th: Russell(get him out before he finds ANOTHER immunity idol) 9th: JT(Candice is tired of JT as are Courtney and Sandra, and they vote him out before he goes on an immunity run) 8th: Candice(Heroes pissed off at the trio, but most hate at Candice, Coach and Jerri flip to vote off Candice) 7th: Danielle(last remnants of R-P-D alliance) 6th: Rupert(The 4 villains come back together) 5th: Colby(last Hero standing falls) 4th: Sandra(tie between Coach and Sandra, Coach wins fire making competition) Final 3: Jerri, Coach, Courtney Amanda: Courtney Parvati: Jerri Russell: Jerri JT: Coach Candice: Jerri Danielle: Jerri Rupert: Coach Colby: Coach Sandra: Courtney Jerri wins HvV 4-3-2 That would have been a great way to end the season! I was rooting for Jerri to win near the end of the real HvV but to no avail.
mennonite		#1046	[-]
Posts: 403 (04/23/11 06:41 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	karl100589 wrote: What if Fran had beaten Godboy in the first round of Redemption Island? and What if Allstars 1 had a Heroes Vs Villains format? Heroes Rudy Jenna L. Tina Colby Amber Ethan Big Tom Kathy Rupert Kimmi Villains Richard Sue Alicia Jerri Lex Rob M. Shii Ann Rob C. Jenna M. Brian Kimmi and Brian are added so it justifies Alicia on the Villains tribe and to balance the tribes, respectively. Amber is the Candice of this version's HvV So, begin: Both tribes must cast a vote on Day 3. An individual immunity challenge is held, which Colby and Lex win. 20th- Brian (Everyone knows what a scoundrel he was the first time, the only person to vote with him is Shii Ann, who was excited to play the game with him. 8-2) 19th- Jenna L. (Goes on a winner's massacre, however can't garner up enough support. Tina, Colby and Ethan band together with Kimmi, Rudy and Rupert to vote off Jenna L. 6-4) 18th- Sue (Violated, humiliated, dehumanized and totally spent. Just kidding. She proves to be too abrasive for the tribe to handle. 6-3) 17th- Jenna M. (Has a vibe that her mom needs her. Quit) 16th- Amber (Tina is worried in a merge situation that she would team up with Jerri again. Also, not a huge physical asset 6-3) 15th- Rudy (The majority decides he's too old and weak to keep up in the challenges. 6-2, only Rupert votes with him) 14th- Alicia (Her big fat mouth gets her into the wrong side of an argument with Richard. Since Richard is more important to the tribe, Alicia is booted 6-1) 13th- Big Tom (Another of Jenna L.'s original alliance, anti-winner/people who made it far. 5-2) The tribes are told again to both boot somebody, with individual immunity on the line. Tina and Shii Ann win this. 12th- Rob M. (Worried about the upcoming merge, the Villains boot him because of this) 11th- Rupert (Blindsided after Kathy forms a secret alliance with Tina, Colby and Kimmi. 4-2) Yin Yang - The Merged Tribe Tina Colby Ethan Kathy Kimmi Richard Jerri Lex Shii Ann Rob C. 10th- Richard (Ethan immune. The Heroes vote Richard, and they convince Shii Ann to flip to vote off Richard 6-4. Villains vote Colby) Jury Begins! 9th- Rob C. (Tina immune. Too smart. 6-3) 8th- Shii Ann (Colby immune. The Heroes decide that Shii Ann is not to be trusted. Blindsided 5-3) 7th- Ethan (Colby immune. Ethan starts to rumble about flipping to the Villains because he's the bottom of a 5 way alliance, voted off 4-2-1) 6th- Tina (Kimmi immune. Kathy: "It's time to dethrone the queen." Kathy makes the case that there will only be a finite number of times to vote off Tina and Colby. Voted off 4-2) 5th- Colby (Kathy immune. Jerri's Survivor closet is now clean. 4-1) 4th- Jerri (Kimmi immune. Lex throws Jerri under the bus, 3-1) 3rd- Kimmi (Lex immune. Thinks Kimmi may be easier to beat, but she could play the "I've never lasted more than 15 days." card) Jury Vote! Lex vs. Kathy Rob C.- Kathy (played a better strategic game, Lex has "no business" being in the Final 2) Shii Ann- Kathy (bonded better in early merge) Ethan- Kathy (fellow Hero) Tina- Kathy (respect vote for blindsiding her) Colby- Kathy (gave better jury speech) Jerri- Kathy (upset that Lex betrayed her) Kimmi- Kathy (allies) Congratulations, Kathy Vavrick-O'Brian for becoming the first unanimous winner in Survivor 8: Heroes vs. Villains!!!!!!! Last Edited By: mennonite 04/29/11 04:16 PM. Edited 1 times.
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#1047	[-]
Posts: 12449 (05/07/11 10:53 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	What if John Carroll had been on Chapera during All Stars instead of Boston Rob?
povertyy		#1048	[-]
Posts: 313 (05/07/11 11:33 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	karl100589 wrote: What if Fran had beaten Godboy in the first round of Redemption Island? This season would've been saved.
et91		#1049	[-]
Posts: 892 (05/07/11 01:35 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	ROFLROOSTER wrote: I don't think this has been done yet, what if Rob was on Zapatello and Rus on Ometepe Hmm 1st voted out(Z wins immunity): Phillip(Russell tries his dumbass girls alliance again and gets Natalie and Ashley, and actually gets Kristina onboard as she knows he's a goat and isn't a threat like Rob would be(she still finds idol). Andrea and Matt get close, Matt refuses to go with Russell so Andrea doesn't, same with Grant and Francesca. Phillip originally is with Russell, but has a blowup at tribal council, leading everyone to vote for him) 2nd voted out(Z immunity): Grant(4-4 vote Russell-Grant, Kristina plays idol on Russell not wanting to risk purple rock, and Grant goes home) RI-Grant beats Phillip 3rd voted out(Z immunity, no great puzzle guys on O and Z doesn't throw challenge): Francesca(Russell hates outspoken women unless they are with him) RI-Grant beats Francesca 4th voted out(Z immunity): Kristina(Russell has numbers to pull this off, and wants to get rid of his biggest "competition" on the tribe) RI-Grant beats Kristina 5th voted out(O immunity): Rob(Rob gets David, Krista, and Stephanie, while Julie/Steve/Mike/Ralph still team up. Sarita is the swing vote and decides to get rid of Rob) RI-Rob beats Grant 6th voted out(O immunity): Krista(getting rid of that alliance) RI-Rob beats Krista 7th voted out(O immunity): David(Sarita's preference goes home) RI-Rob beats David, re-enters game Murlonio: Andrea Ashley Julie Matt Mike Natalie Ralph Rob Russell Sarita Stephanie Steve 8th voted out: Steve(Rob and Steph jump to Ometepe, and use Steve to flush the idol, as Russell's gets played as a "just in case" measure because he doesn't trust Rob as well. Ralph wastes his on Mike. No more HIIs!) 9th voted out: Mike(biggest physical threat) 10th voted out: Julie(continue Pagonging) RI: Steve first member of jury 11th voted out: Sarita(Rob wants her gone) RI: Sarita second member of jury 12th voted out: Russell(Rob and Steph pull over Matt and Andrea, Ralph has no clue whats going on, and Russell is blindsided) 13th voted out: Ralph(the girls aren't threats at this point) RI: Julie third member of jury 14th voted out: Ashley(bigger physical threat) RI: Ashley fourth member of jury 15th voted out: Matt(Rob pulls Natalie, who is helpless and a follower, knowing Matt is a huge physical and jury threat and gets rid of him) RI: Mike comes back into game Final 5: Andrea Mike Natalie Rob Stephanie 16th voted out: Mike(jury threat) 17th voted out: Rob(Stephanie wins immunity and pulls a fast one on Rob) Final 3: Stephanie, Andrea, Natalie Steve: Andrea Sarita: Stephanie Julie: Andrea Ashley: Natalie Russell: Natalie Matt: Andrea Ralph: Stephanie Mike: Stephanie Rob: Stephanie Stephanie Valencia wins RI 4-3-2!
Alex Shallow		#1050	[-]
Posts: 1564 (05/07/11 01:42 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Ads no more Remove this ad et91 wrote: ROFLROOSTER wrote: I don't think this has been done yet, what if Rob was on Zapatello and Rus on Ometepe Hmm 1st voted out(Z wins immunity): Phillip(Russell tries his dumbass girls alliance again and gets Natalie and Ashley, and actually gets Kristina onboard as she knows he's a goat and isn't a threat like Rob would be(she still finds idol). Andrea and Matt get close, Matt refuses to go with Russell so Andrea doesn't, same with Grant and Francesca. Phillip originally is with Russell, but has a blowup at tribal council, leading everyone to vote for him) 2nd voted out(Z immunity): Grant(4-4 vote Russell-Grant, Kristina plays idol on Russell not wanting to risk purple rock, and Grant goes home) RI-Grant beats Phillip 3rd voted out(Z immunity, no great puzzle guys on O and Z doesn't throw challenge): Francesca(Russell hates outspoken women unless they are with him) RI-Grant beats Francesca 4th voted out(Z immunity): Kristina(Russell has numbers to pull this off, and wants to get rid of his biggest "competition" on the tribe) RI-Grant beats Kristina 5th voted out(O immunity): Rob(Rob gets David, Krista, and Stephanie, while Julie/Steve/Mike/Ralph still team up. Sarita is the swing vote and decides to get rid of Rob) RI-Rob beats Grant 6th voted out(O immunity): Krista(getting rid of that alliance) RI-Rob beats Krista 7th voted out(O immunity): David(Sarita's preference goes home) RI-Rob beats David, re-enters game Murlonio: Andrea Ashley Julie Matt Mike Natalie Ralph Rob Russell Sarita Stephanie Steve 8th voted out: Steve(Rob and Steph jump to Ometepe, and use Steve to flush the idol, as Russell's gets played as a "just in case" measure because he doesn't trust Rob as well. Ralph wastes his on Mike. No more HIIs!) 9th voted out: Mike(biggest physical threat) 10th voted out: Julie(continue Pagonging) RI: Steve first member of jury 11th voted out: Sarita(Rob wants her gone) RI: Sarita second member of jury 12th voted out: Russell(Rob and Steph pull over Matt and Andrea, Ralph has no clue whats going on, and Russell is blindsided) 13th voted out: Ralph(the girls aren't threats at this point) RI: Julie third member of jury 14th voted out: Ashley(bigger physical threat) RI: Ashley fourth member of jury 15th voted out: Matt(Rob pulls Natalie, who is helpless and a follower, knowing Matt is a huge physical and jury threat and gets rid of him) RI: Mike comes back into game Final 5: Andrea Mike Natalie Rob Stephanie 16th voted out: Mike(jury threat) 17th voted out: Rob(Stephanie wins immunity and pulls a fast one on Rob) Final 3: Stephanie, Andrea, Natalie Steve: Andrea Sarita: Stephanie Julie: Andrea Ashley: Natalie Russell: Natalie Matt: Andrea Ralph: Stephanie Mike: Stephanie Rob: Stephanie Stephanie Valencia wins RI 4-3-2! This would've made an amazing season!!! Stephandrea being in the F3 <333
RyAn MaGnEr 87		#1051	[-]
Posts: 401 (05/07/11 02:02 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	mike would have won the remaining Immunity challenges and won.
et91		#1052	[-]
Posts: 894 (05/07/11 03:14 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	because we totally know what the final immunity challenges are. eyeroll
RyAn MaGnEr 87		#1053	[-]
Posts: 402 (05/07/11 03:16 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	no this is an eyeroll
karl100589		#1054	[-]
Posts: 922 (05/07/11 03:39 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	What if the Outcasts had only finished second in the 3 way immunity challenge (with Drake winning)?
et91		#1055	[-]
Posts: 898 (05/07/11 05:10 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Burton/Lil/Jon becomes Burton/Jon/Shawn, except that has the potential for it to blowup because Jon and Shawn don't like each other
swimboy818		#1056	[-]
Posts: 485 (05/07/11 05:35 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	What if Matt jumped ship to Zap when the merge started?
et91		#1057	[-]
Posts: 900 (05/07/11 08:45 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	6-6 tie vote? Purple rawk?
EvilDoctorWill		#1058	[-]
Posts: 760 (05/09/11 05:32 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	What if Rob and Russell were not cast on Redemption Island, 16 person cast with the merge and jury being at 10 (I know there is a gender unbalance now, but just go with it!)
tomersde		#1059	[-]
Posts: 963 (05/09/11 09:01 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Dr Will Hatch two point oh wrote: What if John Carroll had been on Chapera during All Stars instead of Boston Rob? That's the most interesting 'what if' in the last 20 pages or so. The Chapera dynamics would've been completely different without Boston Rob. I can't see any 3 member alliance like BRob/Amber/Tom. John probably takes some of the target on Rob C's back. Allthough John was Varner-esqe, I don't think Allicia will align with him. With no BRob to bring Amber in, I think Tom will revert to his standard boys club strategy and aligns with John and Rob C. Amber will most likely be their fouth.
dulcify is awesome		#1060	[-]
Posts: 73 (05/10/11 08:01 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Ads no more Remove this ad What if Rob and Russell were not cast on Redemption Island, 16 person cast with the merge and jury being at 10 (I know there is a gender unbalance now, but just go with it!) ep 1 Zap win immunity on ometepe the same alliance of grant, matt and the three girls form. kristina finds the idol. phillip grates on everybody enough to go out first this time ep 2 ome win immunity on zapatera alliances begin to form sarita, julie, ralph vs mike dave steve. steph and Krista are the swing they go with mike side. sarita out 5-3 ep 3 Zap win immunity alliances hold strong. they try to vote out kristina but she idols out ashley 2-0 ep 4 ome win immunity steph and krista jump to vote out steve in a blindside 4-3 ep5 ome win immunity steph and krista jump back to the boys to try and get Julie out. they succeed but ralph who has found the idol saves his closest ally and idols out the weak and annoying krista 2-0 ep6 zap win immunity ome alliance stay strong and kristina is out 4-2 Merge ep7 immune (natalie) fran saves herself and jumps to the zaps. she julie and ralph form a final 3 alliance. grant out 6-4 ep8 immune (matt) pangoning continues. natalie out 6-3 ep9 immune (andrea) same as above. Matt out 6-2 ep10 immune (andrea) with andrea immune the zaps plan the vote out francesca. however ralph and julie hold true to there final three alliance to fran and bring in andrea. Mike out 4-3 ep11 immune (andrea) with andrea immune again the alliance of four stay together and david is out. 4-2 ep12 Immune (Andrea) steph tries to scramble with ralph and julie to get rid of fran. and works with andrea to try and get rid of julie. she finally plays on frans paranoia and gets her to vote for ralph. at tribal the vote ends up 2-2-1 with a tie between Francesca and steph. on the revote ralph and julie follow through and take out their ally francesca Immune (Steph) fire making contest between julie and andrea. andrea wins Grant: Andrea: Original alliance Natalie: Andrea: original alliance Matt: Andrea: Original alliance Mike: Steph: respect for her game David: Steph: respect for her game Francesca: Steph: Voted to save her at final 5. didn't like Andrea Julie: Ralph Clostest ally Ralph votes for Andrea to win.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

More what if moments...