Rank the winners in Big Brother Forum

0 Points

Rank the winners

Started By	Comment
solesurvivor123		#21	[-]
Posts: 206 (09/15/11 05:24 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Ads no more Remove this ad Best player-worst player 1. Adam (I don't like him but he played the best) 2. Hayden 3. Boogie 4. Maggie 5. Drew 6. Jun 7. Rachel 8. Jordan 9. Lisa 10. Dan 11. Dick 12. Will
Renegades		#22	[-]
Posts: 1178 (09/15/11 06:02 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Rachels win was worse than Jordans
6luttony		#23	[-]
Posts: 238 (09/15/11 06:09 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	1. Rachel 2. Jordan 3. Lisa 4. Will 5. Hayden 6. Drew 7. Jun 8. Adam 9. Boogie 10. Maggie 11. Dan 12. Dick
JasonSiskaLulz		#24	[-]
Posts: 9174 (09/15/11 06:12 AM) What is a muffin top? Reply Quote More Recent Posts	jun > will > rachel > lol who cares
Yasothon		#25	[-]
Posts: 325 (09/15/11 06:15 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Best-Worst Player 1. Hayden gap 2. Rachel 3. Boogie 4. Will 5. Drew 6. Adam gap 7. Lisa 8. Maggie 9. Jun 10. Dan gap 11. Dick 12. Jordan
sGabe4		#26	[-]
Posts: 2406 (09/15/11 07:05 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Best gameplay: 1. Hayden 2. Dr. Will 3. Dan 4. Rachel 5. Jordan 6. Dick I don't care about anyone else because they all sucked (especially Maggie that fucking bitch) likability: #1 RACHEL obvi
solesurvivor01		#27	[-]
Posts: 9599 (09/15/11 07:33 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Game Play: 1. Will 2. Dan 3. Maggiec.unt 4. Jun 5. Hayden 6. Adam 7. Lisa 8. Boogie 9. Rachel 10. Drew 11. Jordan 12. Dick For the record, I think 1-10 were all fairly good players and deserved to win. Based on likability... Love <333 1. Dan 2. Will 3. Lisa 4. Jun 5. Rachel Meh 6. Drew 7. Adam 8. Hayden DIAF 9. Jordan 10. Boogie 11. Maggiec.unt 12. Dick
needsmorecowbell		#28	[-]
Posts: 2190 (09/15/11 07:35 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Jun>Rachel>Dan>Will>Dick>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>everyone else
Gojoseon		#29	[-]
Posts: 163 (09/15/11 07:41 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Gameplay 1. Jun 2. Will 3. Dan 4. Maggie 5. Hayden 6. Drew 7. Lisa 8. Rachel 9. Boogie 10. Adam 11. Jordan 12. Dick
annagreen		#30	[-]
Posts: 562 (09/15/11 11:20 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Ads no more Remove this ad Based on gameplay (strategy, social, comps), but I didn't have the feeds for Seasons 1 through 6 so didn't see the full story on all the winners. 1. Will 2. Dan 3. Hayden 4. Maggie 5. Adam 6. Boogie 7. Drew 8. Jun 9 . Lisa 10. Rachel 11. Dick 12. Jordan
Mai4		#31	[-]
Posts: 4569 (09/15/11 12:52 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	It's hard to rank but based on how they played the game overall: (Not including Eddie) BEST 1. Dr. Will - There will never be another. 2. Dan 3. Maggie 4. Jun AVERAGE 5. Hayden 6. Boogie 7. Adam 8. Drew LUCKY/RIGGED 9. Lisa - Evicting Jason was her only great move. 10. Rachel -She won the ~~rigged~~ comps she needed to ultimately win the game. 11. Jordan -Never a target because of the way she is. Won F3 HoH and picked a goat. 12. Dick -America's Player will forever taint this season for me. Too much rigging.
Nods		#32	[-]
Posts: 10869 (09/15/11 01:07 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Okay my real rankings 01. Dan - Best game, best person, enjoyable season 02. Will - His game has become a bit more mythological than it was good but still the second best winner 03. Drew - boring person but he played the greatest game ever, and his actions brought drama to the house 04. Jordan - pretty much played the cult of personality game to perfection 05. Rachel - Was like a bi-polar Boston Rob 06. Jun - Got very lucky with twists 07. Hayden - played a decent game but was boring 08. Lisa - didn't play the game till day 60 09. Adam - if you end up in Jail you aren't that great a winner. 10. Maggie - didn't win Ivette LOST 11. Dick - AP rigged, also Scott was kicked out from throwing a stool outside, Dick threatened to RAPE people and he got to stay 12. Boogie - not an allstar, won by bribing contestants
Belligerent Ghoul		#33	[-]
Posts: 6533 (09/15/11 01:47 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Taking game & personality into consideration: 1. Jun 2. Lisa 3. Rachel 4. Will 5. Hayden 6. Dan 7. Maggie 8. Boogie 9. Drew other 3 tie in last place.
Renegades		#34	[-]
Posts: 1181 (09/15/11 01:56 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Nods wrote: Okay my real rankings 01. Dan - Best game, best person, enjoyable season 02. Will - His game has become a bit more mythological than it was good but still the second best winner 03. Drew - boring person but he played the greatest game ever, and his actions brought drama to the house 04. Jordan - pretty much played the cult of personality game to perfection 05. Rachel - Was like a bi-polar Boston Rob 06. Jun - Got very lucky with twists 07. Hayden - played a decent game but was boring 08. Lisa - didn't play the game till day 60 09. Adam - if you end up in Jail you aren't that great a winner. 10. Maggie - didn't win Ivette LOST 11. Dick - AP rigged, also Scott was kicked out from throwing a stool outside, Dick threatened to RAPE people and he got to stay 12. Boogie - not an allstar, won by bribing contestants
JonathanPDisciple		#35	[-]
Posts: 164 (09/15/11 02:16 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Strongest Players 1. Hayden - Triple threat who was part of the strongest alliance in BB history and 1 of the strongest BB competitors ever 2. Drew - Triple threat and 1 of the strongest BB competitors ever Strong Players 3. Adam - He's ugly, a criminal, and unpopular but he was a triple threat and good at Big Brother 4. Maggie - Led her stupid sheep well 5. Jun - Made BB4 a clinic on how to float 6. Lisa - The 1st winner to win the game after being the 1st HOH Lucky Players 7. Dan - Got to work over the most influential jury member with no downside 8. Boogie - The dimmest star of the all stars stayed out of the spotlight 9. Rachel - Strong in competitions but social game could use improvement; helped by favorable vet twists 10. Will - Bad in competitions but superb social game; never have to ever deal with veto replacement strategy when he won 11. Dick - The male Rachel 12. Jordan - Did little to nothing but won the critical competitions at the end
Luk.rsfd		#36	[-]
Posts: 182 (09/15/11 02:23 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	1. Rachel 2. Jordan 3. Jun 4. Dan 5. Dick 6. Lisa 7. Will 8. Drew 9. Hayden 10. Maggie 11. Adam 12. Boogie
racedude122003		#37	[-]
Posts: 520 (09/15/11 02:44 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I haven't watched all the seasons, so it's a little hard for me to judge, but from what I've seen I would say that the BEST winners were: Will, Jun, and Dan. They are the best because they played the best game not only in their season, but in any season...and were simply the most deserving. Players who were deserving in their seasons, but can't be classified in the "best" category simply because another player was either equally deserving, or because there were some flaws: Maggie, Hayden, Boogie, Rachel Players who were undeserving of the win - Dick, Jordan, Lisa I think everyone in the first two categories is very deserving, and pretty close. I would consider putting Maggie and Boogie in that top category. I know Boogie didn't do shit in BB2, and that's why some people have trouble accepting his win in All-Stars (simply because he wasn't an allstar), but I felt like he played a strong game. Maggie as well. She was the head of the winning alliance of the season that ended with two of its members in the F2. She had everyone in her alliance playing HER game. Would it be safe to say though that Hayden played a similiar game to Maggie in the sense that they got to where they were because of a strong alliance that had their backs from the beginning?? The main difference between the two being that Maggie had her alliance brainwashed to support HER game. I don't know enough about BB5 or BB9 to make an assumption.
mennonite		#38	[-]
Posts: 575 (09/15/11 02:48 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I feel like the difference between what makes a good winner or a bad one is how they'd do in any season (returning to the house is not a viable judge of their first win, because people already know their reputation, i.e. Dick, Jordan, Will). I feel like some of the winners wouldn't always end up in the end in every situation, but amazing players like Dan would, nine times out of ten.
Surfing Hippo in Trouble		#39	[-]
Posts: 6415 (09/15/11 02:51 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Gameplay: 1. Dan - I can hear the Dan haters screaming now. "HIS FIRST WEEK WAS HORRIBLE!!!!!" I know. But the rest of his game was superb and there's no denying he's an incredible player and probably one of the best in BB history. 2. Hayden - Never EVER a target despite being one of the strongest social players in the game. No one went after him even after he nominated so many people. 3. Will - One of the best but similar to Dan his first few weeks were AWFUL. I don't understand how anyone can criticize Dan's early game when Will was 10000 times worse. Once Shannon left he stepped up his game like no other though and there's no question he's a legend. 4. Maggie - Played an excellent game. Had a constant target on her back, but she was lucky she was playing against a bunch of retards. 5. Mike - Played a pretty solid game. Not many mishaps. Definitely wouldn't have won if it weren't for Will. 6. Adam - He gets a lot of hate, but I think he was a pretty decent player. He played an AMAZING social game. And everybody loved Baller. Plus he never made any huge mistakes. 7. Jun - Played the floater game to perfection. The only thing that I fault her on is the fact that she would have lost to anybody else and she got really lucky that everything worked out for an Ali/Jun F2. 8. Drew - Another solid game. Diane kinda made all the big moves while he sat back and played a social game. But at the end of the day he was a pretty good winner. 9. Lisa - Not a strategic player at all. But she definitely stepped up her game once Eric left. She got lucky that she was playing in a pre-sequester season. 10. Rachel - Horrific social game. One of the few people who will ever win relying solely on a physical game and nothing else. I do admit she stepped up her social game once Brendon left the second time. 11. Dick - Obviously he wouldn't even be on this list if not for AP, but I do think he's a lot more game savvy then people give him credit for so who knows. But I highly HIGHLY doubt it. His name always has an asterisks next to it in my book along with... 12. Jordan - Awful winner. Zero strategic game. Bumblefucked her way to the end. Wanted to quit so Jeff could continue on. Just zero strategic brain on her original season (I saw a little more smarts this season, I'll admit)
franklin		#40	[-]
Posts: 97 (09/15/11 03:01 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Ads no more Remove this ad Dan gets the number one spot because he excelled at every aspect of the game (comps, strategy, social) on a season that was almost entirely free of rigging/twists. Rachel's not the worst winner, but she's below average because this season had five twists and all of them benefited her in some way -- usually at the expense of her F2 mate Porsche. She benefited from a sixth twist if you count the vet-centric edit that guaranteed they'd win every AC vote.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Rank the winners