Top 3 most underrated players (excluding winners) in Lions, Tigers, Survivors

0 Points

Top 3 most underrated players (excluding winners)

Started By	Comment
SpadeSafety		#41	[-]
Posts: 7 (10/28/11 10:22 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Cheese� milk's leap toward immortality. Remove this ad EverySurvivorEver wrote: LemmeSmashIt wrote: EverySurvivorEver wrote: Rupert is the most consistent player. There. Sandra is the most consistent player. THERE. Two does not equal more than three. Insert capitalized 'there' thinking I'm clever and that I'm definitively correct. No, but 2 wins is greater than 0. Any argument you can make about Rupert's gameplay, you can make about Sandra's, plus tack on the fact that she actually manages to win and people like her.
EverySurvivorEver		#42	[-]
Posts: 52 (10/28/11 10:26 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	SpadeSafety wrote: EverySurvivorEver wrote: LemmeSmashIt wrote: Sandra is the most consistent player. THERE. Two does not equal more than three. Insert capitalized 'there' thinking I'm clever and that I'm definitively correct. No, but 2 wins is greater than 0. Any argument you can make about Rupert's gameplay, you can make about Sandra's, plus tack on the fact that she actually manages to win and people like her. I made no arguement about anyone's gameplay. Rupert also wins, and lots of people like him. Just not sucks. Youtube pages still amass Rupert love.
SpadeSafety		#43	[-]
Posts: 8 (10/28/11 11:08 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	EverySurvivorEver wrote: SpadeSafety wrote: EverySurvivorEver wrote: Two does not equal more than three. Insert capitalized 'there' thinking I'm clever and that I'm definitively correct. No, but 2 wins is greater than 0. Any argument you can make about Rupert's gameplay, you can make about Sandra's, plus tack on the fact that she actually manages to win and people like her. I made no arguement about anyone's gameplay. Rupert also wins, and lots of people like him. Just not sucks. Youtube pages still amass Rupert love. Then what are you arguing, his personality is underrated? His dumb ass got him $1million while he swam around catching fish, oblivious to the game, while everybody else was actually playing. There's no way he deserves more popularity than what he currently has. If you're not talking about his strategy, why did you call him "consistent"? Also, if you're basing quality of character on how many times a player appears on the show, you're admitting that he is inferior to both Boston Rob and Russell. Rob has been on 4 and Russell has been on 3, plus they liked him so much they got his nephew. And these "games" you clam he wins at, he's still inferior to Russell, Russell has wan twice, once against Rupert. But just looking at sheer personality, Rupert is a complete self obsessed buffoon As a list of things he has done: threatened to beat up Fairplay after voting against him spent half of HvVillains complaining about his toe lost most of the Heroes' flint on day 1 starts HvV obsessing over how much better being a hero is (never mind the fact that our introduction to Rupert is stealing peoples' shoes) 39 days later, as a member of jury he stands up and makes Sandra an honorary Hero, seemingly the only person who still gives a shit about the titles holds grudge against Stephenie for becoming new icon of Survivor years after he's even been on the show runs for governor when he clearly can't strategize for shit plays up his grudge against Fairplay, while Fairplay lives his life not giving two shits about Rupert *digs a trench for a shelter (to be fair though, I did that too when I was 12 years old)
white lancer		#44	[-]
Posts: 109 (10/29/11 01:06 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Penny (Thailand) Jenn (Palau) Austin (Panama)
EverySurvivorEver		#45	[-]
Posts: 54 (10/29/11 08:28 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	SpadeSafety wrote: EverySurvivorEver wrote: SpadeSafety wrote: No, but 2 wins is greater than 0. Any argument you can make about Rupert's gameplay, you can make about Sandra's, plus tack on the fact that she actually manages to win and people like her. I made no arguement about anyone's gameplay. Rupert also wins, and lots of people like him. Just not sucks. Youtube pages still amass Rupert love. Then what are you arguing, his personality is underrated? His dumb ass got him $1million while he swam around catching fish, oblivious to the game, while everybody else was actually playing. There's no way he deserves more popularity than what he currently has. If you're not talking about his strategy, why did you call him "consistent"? Also, if you're basing quality of character on how many times a player appears on the show, you're admitting that he is inferior to both Boston Rob and Russell. Rob has been on 4 and Russell has been on 3, plus they liked him so much they got his nephew. And these "games" you clam he wins at, he's still inferior to Russell, Russell has wan twice, once against Rupert. But just looking at sheer personality, Rupert is a complete self obsessed buffoon As a list of things he has done: threatened to beat up Fairplay after voting against him spent half of HvVillains complaining about his toe lost most of the Heroes' flint on day 1 starts HvV obsessing over how much better being a hero is (never mind the fact that our introduction to Rupert is stealing peoples' shoes) 39 days later, as a member of jury he stands up and makes Sandra an honorary Hero, seemingly the only person who still gives a shit about the titles holds grudge against Stephenie for becoming new icon of Survivor years after he's even been on the show runs for governor when he clearly can't strategize for shit plays up his grudge against Fairplay, while Fairplay lives his life not giving two shits about Rupert *digs a trench for a shelter (to be fair though, I did that too when I was 12 years old) Why'd you write me an essay just because Rupert has always made the jury? And won a million dollars more than you? :S
super pole2000		#46	[-]
Posts: 550 (10/29/11 09:34 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	The idea of what an over or under rated player is changes from the hardcore to the casual fanbase. Rupert is a perfect example of this: overrated amongst casuals, underrated amongst hardcore.
The Very Insane Shark		#47	[-]
Posts: 5271 (10/29/11 09:56 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	EverySurvivorEver wrote: SpadeSafety wrote: EverySurvivorEver wrote: I made no arguement about anyone's gameplay. Rupert also wins, and lots of people like him. Just not sucks. Youtube pages still amass Rupert love. Then what are you arguing, his personality is underrated? His dumb ass got him $1million while he swam around catching fish, oblivious to the game, while everybody else was actually playing. There's no way he deserves more popularity than what he currently has. If you're not talking about his strategy, why did you call him "consistent"? Also, if you're basing quality of character on how many times a player appears on the show, you're admitting that he is inferior to both Boston Rob and Russell. Rob has been on 4 and Russell has been on 3, plus they liked him so much they got his nephew. And these "games" you clam he wins at, he's still inferior to Russell, Russell has wan twice, once against Rupert. But just looking at sheer personality, Rupert is a complete self obsessed buffoon As a list of things he has done: threatened to beat up Fairplay after voting against him spent half of HvVillains complaining about his toe lost most of the Heroes' flint on day 1 starts HvV obsessing over how much better being a hero is (never mind the fact that our introduction to Rupert is stealing peoples' shoes) 39 days later, as a member of jury he stands up and makes Sandra an honorary Hero, seemingly the only person who still gives a shit about the titles holds grudge against Stephenie for becoming new icon of Survivor years after he's even been on the show runs for governor when he clearly can't strategize for shit plays up his grudge against Fairplay, while Fairplay lives his life not giving two shits about Rupert *digs a trench for a shelter (to be fair though, I did that too when I was 12 years old) Why'd you write me an essay just because Rupert has always made the jury? And won a million dollars more than you? :S Way to just ignore every single valid point SpadeSafety made. And FYI, Poopert didn't win shit. CBS just handed him the $1 million to appease all the unwashed Poopertards who were crying and crying about how it wasn't "fair" that Poopert lost twice.
EverySurvivorEver		#48	[-]
Posts: 56 (10/29/11 11:53 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	super pole2000 wrote: The idea of what an over or under rated player is changes from the hardcore to the casual fanbase. Rupert is a perfect example of this: overrated amongst casuals, underrated amongst hardcore. Darn every time I see you, you make the best posts. Not even commenting on that last fail :P
Contrarian		#49	[-]
Posts: 7 (11/01/11 04:13 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Chase (Nicaragua) Julie (Vanuatu) Rafe (Guatemala)
UlongWinsImmunity		#50	[-]
Posts: 2207 (11/01/11 07:16 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Cheese� milk's leap toward immortality. Remove this ad Danielle Rafe Peih-Gee
Sole Survivor		#51	[-]
Posts: 7 (11/01/11 10:06 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Gregg (Palau) Holly (Nicaragua) Kathy (Marquesas/All-Stars)
Sole Survivor		#52	[-]
Posts: 8 (11/01/11 10:08 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Oh and maybe Becky (Cook Islands). In the beginning, she made decisions with Yul but his intelligence and actual execution of their ideas overshadowed her thinking. I don't think she's underrated so much as she's forgotten. I don't give her much credit for her firemaking skills though...
tango		#53	[-]
Posts: 353 (11/01/11 11:59 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	LemmeSmashIt wrote: EverySurvivorEver wrote: AHumbleDiscipleOfGregBuis wrote: lol come on, Rupert? CHASE?? Opinions are opinions, but come on now. Rupert is the most consistent player. There. Sandra is the most consistent player. THERE. Rob Mariano is the most consistent player. One season he misses to jury by one episode (episode 7 both times), the next one he reaches the FTC.
owopolmaster		#54	[-]
Posts: 226 (11/01/11 02:02 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Joel was his name? The guy who was voted off RIGHT before the merge in Borneo. T-bird, as stated. Misty
Lexxan		#55	[-]
Posts: 11261 (11/01/11 02:11 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Deena Gregg Tracy
Putter		#56	[-]
Posts: 25 (11/01/11 02:52 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	1. Chase- He made THE BEST final tribal council speech I have ever heard on the show. 2. Tracey (Micronesia)- She was one of the few fans on the "fans" tribe, and would have done really well if she wasn't surrounded by recruited douchebags who only wanted to get famous, and therefore ostracized her for no reason. 3. Becky- There was no way she WOULDN'T be overshadowed by Yul, and both clearly made equal decisions, but since Yul had the idol, he was given all the power, and since Ozzy won all the challenges, he was never in danger either. Becky is the only one who was actually able to be voted out that whole season. I admit she wasn't the greatest at challenges, but since when has that ever been a factor for anything. Courtney is terrible at challenges and people love her for it, not to mention, if you can't get a fire started with matches, which if I recall it took them a while to do, there must be something else going on there, not just "the girls were idiots."
StonehengeEmo		#57	[-]
Posts: 19 (11/01/11 03:42 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Rafe, Scout, Lill
Nods		#58	[-]
Posts: 11155 (11/01/11 03:56 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	People who would have could have won their seasons had twists and idols taken them out. Michelle Yi Aaron Reisberger Brett Clouser
SomeGoodBubbles		#59	[-]
Posts: 539 (11/01/11 04:39 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	1. Scout 2. Clay 3. Erinn Honorable Mention- Sue Hawk
Hippochinfat		#60	[-]
Posts: 5884 (11/01/11 04:55 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Cheese� milk's leap toward immortality. Remove this ad Chase Edgardo Brett Charlie

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Top 3 most underrated players (excluding winners)