Hey everyone. Welcome to my Fanfic of a Survivor Allstar season. The cast only contains people that played after the first Allstars, and who have only played once. This is the first fanfic I wrote, so hopefully I can improve more as I finish more episodes. Unlike guat's and pacific's fics I prefer to write mine in a sort of script style, so the volume text may appear longer, even though it's actuall not that much =D. I selected the constestants based on their performance in their season, as well and the synergy that they might have with each other. So far I have completed the first episode, which you can read below.
Here are the tribes of this season
Maha Tribe:
- Natalie White (Survivor Samoa, Winner)
- John Cochran (Survivor South Pacific)
- Ian Rosenberger (Survivor Palau, 3rd place)
- Crystal Cox (Survivor Gabon, 6th place)
- Brenda Lowe (Survivor Nicaragua, 10th place)
- Holly Hoffman (Survivor Nicaragua, 4th place)
- Fabio Birza (Survivor Nicaragua, Winner)
- Andrea Boehlke (Survivor Redemtion Island, 5th place)
- Matt Elrod (Survivor Redemption Island, 7th place)
- Shane Powers (Survivor Exile Island, 5th place) Kalu Tribe
- Phillip Sheppard (Survivor Redemption Island, 2nd place)
- Marty Piombo (Survivor Nicaragua, 11th place)
- Kenny Hoang (Survivor Gabon, 5th place)
- Corinne Kaplan (Survivor Gabon, 7th place)
- Natalie Bolton (Survivor Fans vs Favorites, 4th place)
- Eric Reichenbach (Survivor Fans vs Favorites, 5th place)
- Brandon Hantz (Survivor South Pacific)
- Erinn Lobdell (Survivor Tocantins, 3rd place)
- Taj George (Survivor Tocantins, 4th place)
- Sierra Reed (Survivor Tocantins, 7th place) (I don't know what fucked up the formatting like that when I copy pasted the text here. If you want read the version that doesnt have such large indents, I will post a download link tomorrow)
Episode 1: "I hate this game"
Part 1:
Jeff Probst: Deep in Indian Ocean, 20 castaways are marooned in the remote, dangerous lands of Sri Lanka. These people are not new to the game. They are Allstars, who have already played once and are back for another chance to win a million dollars.
[The castaways are shown paddling towards the beach on two rafts, each containing 10 people. Quick consecutive shots of several castaways take place]
Phillip (confessional): I have waited for this since the time I left Survivor: Redemption Island. I am back. I am still “the Specialist”. However - This time - I am NOT playing for somebody else to win. I am playing for ME towin. I promise – on my LIFE – after thirty nine days – you will be writing me a check – for a million dollars.
Natalie B. (confessional): I am back and I am out for BLOOD. And looking around, while paddling on the raft I can see that the others are too. Whatever happened to people in the original seasons – doesn’t matter anymore. THIS is the real deal and it is gonna be a bloodbath, I can tell you that.
Ian (confessional): Oh I still can’t believe I’m back playing this game. Man, this feels so surreal to me. I certainly look forward to playing with the people sitting beside me and this time I am not handing the million dollars to anybody else *laughs*.
They are forced to work together while battling the elements, and each other. They must learn to adapt – or they’ll be voted out. . In the end – only one will remain to claim the one million dollar prize, and the title – of Sole Survivor. 39 days – 20 people – 1 Survivor!
[The intro song is played]
[The castaways are shown arriving at the beach as the two groups walk onto two mats – a green one and a blue one respectively.]
Jeff Probst: Welcome. To Survivor –
[The castaways cheer. Phillip does his gorilla noise.]
Jeff Probst: You’ve already been divided into two tribes, named after two of the islands in this archipelago – Maha – wearing blue and Kalu – wearing green.
Jeff Probst: Phillip. Now you’ve got to chance to size up both tribes. Who do you see as the biggest threat?
Phillip: Oh I think everybody is a threat here Jeff, without a question. We’ve all been chosen – a SELECT FEW out of however many people have played this game. I think that this says something about how dangerous EVERY SINGLE ONE OF US is.
[Corinne is shown rolling her eyes]
Corinne (confessional): Phillip’s speech at the beginning was ri-diculous. Pfft, the only reason he’s here is because he is a complete nutjob, and I wouldn’t expect him to be here for long anyways.
Jeff Probst: Well then it’s time to see how the tribes match up right now. This was the first challenge in our other Allstar season – Heroes versus Villains, and now you guys get to experience it first hand
Jeff Probst: There are nines lanes in this sand strip, with each lane having one bad buried somewhere in it. Every round, a pair from each tribe will race towards the designated lane, trying to dig up a bag, and bring it to the mat. Each bag is worth one point. The team that gets to three points first wins.
Jeff Probst: The reward you are playing today is flint. Having fire so early in the game means water and can result a huge advantage in the challenges that are to follow.
[The first pairs prepare to square off. Representing Maha are
[Jeff announces that the Kalu tribe wins reward, both tribes gather up their belongings and leave for their respective camps.]
Day 1
Maha Tribe
[Maha tribe is shown to arrive at their camp, all in low spirits.]
Holly: How are you feeling Matt? You got hit pretty hard there.
Matt: Noo, I’m feeling fine. Just a little bit dizzy.
Matt: (confessional): Ma-a-an, I got tackled pretty hard there. I can still feel my head spinning. Of course I understand the concept of giving it all, in order to win, but I know I would never try and intentionally hurt anyone like that just for a piece of metal and a chance to make a fire three days early…
Andrea: Well…. Here we are guys. Let’s get to work, I guess. We’ve got to build something quickly before the sun sets.
Andrea (confessional): Am I disappointed that we lost the challenge? Absolutely! It’s always hard when everybody gives it one hundred percent and then gets nothing from it, but hopefully people won’t brood over the loss and just pick themselves up and get ready for what’s coming up next!
[The shot changes to Brenda and Andrea in the jungle gathering firewood.]
Brenda: Sooo… what do you think?
Andrea: About what?
Brenda: About this whole situation.
Brenda (confessional): So yeah, we all go to camp, everyone gets to know each other, everyone starts building the shelter, it’s all nice and wonderful, but I’ve been here before. I know how this stuff works. Even though it’s only day one, you’ve gotta play the game. If you don’t have an alliance, if you don’t have people who you can at least somewhat trust, you’re pretty much gone.
Brenda: We both know what’s going on. This is the part where the deals are done. I’ve got to find somebody I can trust, and I really think I could trust you. And if you want to make an agreement right now, I’d be happy to go to the end with you
Andrea: Oh yeah, of course. I think this sounds wonderful!
Brenda (confessional): Andrea is my main ally. But it’s obviously not enough, just to have one person on my side. Last time I got screwed because I didn’t really have a tight grip on my alliance. It isn’t happening this time. Nope. No way.
[The shot changes to Brenda, Andrea and Natalie W. sitting on the beach.]
Brenda: Have you thought about, you know, aligning with people yet?
Natalie W.: Well, if ya’ll wanna make an alliance right now I’m up for it.
Brenda: For sure. If we can work together I’m positive that three of us can make it to the end.
Brenda (confessional): I’ve included Natalie into my alliance because to be honest – and I don’t mean to come off rude or anything – I don’t think she’s too bright so she’s a perfect ally to manipulate all the way to the end. I’m not gonna let her into a final three or anything, I know how it went last time *laughs*, but she will probably be a bigger target than me because she’s a winner and I can easily get rid of her whenever I want.
Natalie W. (confessional): I got approached by Brenda who proposed an alliance between her, me and Andrea. I’ve made an alliance with Russell, who was scrambling for everybody’s loyalty on the first day, and I see Brenda doing the same thing. But of course I’m gonna say yes, when someone proposes an alliance. I’m just worried that Brenda’s playing the game too hard right now, while she doesn’t really have to, so hopefully this won’t come back to hurt mah own game.
[The shot changes to Holly who is standing behind the bushes, watching the three girls on the beach having a conversation.]
Holly (confessional): Brenda is a shady character. I see her going around to everyone, talking with them, maybe even making alliances. And you don’t do that on the first day. That’s the reason she was voted out in
Part 2:
Kalu Tribe
[We now go to the Kalu tribe’s camp, as the castaways arrive to their tribe flag. Unlike the other tribe, the Kalu castaways all appear to be cheery, since they have won the challenge.]
Phillip: We have arrived to our camp. Everyone was ecstatic, because we won the first challenge. And I know that, just like that challenge we just had, our tribe is going to DOMINATE the rest of the game.
Phillip: Ok guys! Please gather around here! I think we all know what needs to be done. So I think you three should start gathering materials for the roof of the shelter, and four of us will…
[Phillip goes off giving directions to everybody, and several people are shown to be pretty pissed at Phillip ordering everyone around.]
Sierra (confessional): Phillip… Oh my god… I just can’t keep listening to the guy. He goes up, starts giving everyone directions… I’m not gonna listen to him. He can go and do whatever he wants to do by himself. I’m not taking orders from a freakin’ psychopath.
[Even though some people were shown to be annoyed with Phillip, it appears that everyone are working but Sierra, who is sitting in the middle of the camp, looking around aimlessly.]
Phillip (confessional): We’re all building the shelter, everybody’s pitching in, and I’m working my ASS off. And then I turn around and see Sierra, just SITTING down, doing NOTHING. And you know, normally I wouldn’t mind when somebody does that. Maybe they are resting, I don’t know. But after quite some time, I look around again, and she’s still not doing jack squat. This kind of slacking off, on the first day, is UNNACEPTABLE!!
Phillip: Excuse me, young lady…
Sierra: Phillip, what the hell do you want?
Phillip: What do I want? I WANT YOU TO GET OFF YOUR LAZY ASS AND DO SOME WORK AROUND HERE!!!
Sierra: DON’T YELL AT ME, YOU PSYCHOTIC #######!!!
[Sierra walks away, covering her face. Everybody around Phillip and Sierra watches the scene with dumbfounded at what just happened.]
Sierra (confessional): *crying* I don’t understand, why people always pick on me! In
[Sierra is shown sitting outside the camp, still crying.]
Kenny: You really need to come back to camp. You can’t really sit here on day, people will get mad at you.
Sierra: People are already mad at me. Apparently I’m stupid and worthless, according to Phillip at least.
Kenny: But it’s Phillip, what did you expect? You’ve gotta learn to ignore stuff like that, it’ll make the game that much easier for you!
Kenny (confessional): Well it looks like I’m on the crazy tribe again. It’s weird that I’m the one going around and calming people down after the Phillip and Sierra argument. But actually, as long as people like me and don’t want to vote me out, I’m all for being a good guy!
Day 2
Kalu Tribe
[Sierra, Taj and Erinn are sitting in the shelter, chatting.]
Sierra: I feel so bad about that stupid argument yesterday. I know it put a huge target on me now, and I really don’t wanna go first.
Taj: Da-amn, you gotta relax girl, you’re fine. Don’t worry you ain’t goin’ nowhere.
Sierra: I hope… I really think if we stick together, we could easily get Phillip out of here. I feel like everyone is about done with his crazy antics. He hasn’t even apologized to me for what he did yesterday!
Taj (confessional): Sierra’s lookin’ worried as hell. I mean come on girl, we haven’t even had the immunity challenge yet, and you’re already paranoid. Stuff like that ain’t never good for your game, if you know what I’m talkin’ about.
[The shot changes to later in the day, as Marty is sitting near the fire, observing everyone who is walking around.]
Marty (confessional): So it’s day two already. And of course I see people walking to the jungle together, I see them hanging out in the shelter, talking. And of course it worries me – people making alliances that early. This is an Allstar season, and at the end of the day I don’t want end up at the short end of the stick, when things really get messy
[We now go to Marty and Kenny gathering firewood, good distance away from the camp.]
Marty: So Kenny, dude. I’m gonna be straight up with you. I want me and you to go to the end together.
Kenny: Oh, I would love to work with you, Marty… I’m actually pretty excited that you offered an alliance to be. Last time I was playing, nobody came up and talked to me until day five or six *laughs*
Marty: The thing I like the most about Kenny is that the guy has a strategical mind. And that’s someone I would want to align with right off the bat. Because I really feel, it’s easier to predict the actions of a strategist like me or Kenny, than someone who is a loose cannon, like Phillip or Brandon.
Marty: Well you know what man? This time it’s different. This time we’re both gonna make it to the end.
Maha Tribe
[Holly and Fabio are sitting in the shelter chatting, while most of the tribe is away from camp.]
Holly: Can you believe we’re back Fabio?
Fabio: I kno-ow, man! I can’t believe we get to play this game again!
Holly: So what are your thoughts on our tribe after the first day?
Fabio: Oooh… I don’t kno-ow… everyone just seems to be soo… I don’t even know how to describe it.
Holly: Well you know what… I’m worried Fabio… I’m really worried
Fabio: What are you worried about Holly? It’s only been like thirty eight and a half hours and you’re already worried!
Holly: I don’t know. Brenda worries me. It just seems she’s doing the exact same thing she did in
Fabio: I know, man! That’s totally what I was seeing too!!!
Holly: You know she’s a threat Fabio. In my opinion we need to get rid of her as soon as possible.
Fabio: Oh I am totally on board with this, Holly.
[As the pair is talking, even though the camp appears to be empty, the shot switches to Shane who was about to come in with several bundles of firewood, but stopped as he overheard Holly and Fabio’s conversation.]
Shane (confessional): It seems that wherever I go, the people are already SCRAMBLING. You know like these little cockroaches. And I think it is absolutely AMAZING. I mean it’s GLORIOUS, it’s FANTASTIC!!! Since Fabio apparently is louder than a working jackhammer, I’ve just got some pretty wonderful info about WHO do these two think is the biggest target. And you know what? I might just spill some of this info to some other people. Why? Well because I don’t really care about these two much… Fabio annoys the crap out of me actually. It’ll be fun watching these two get annihilated just because some surfer boy couldn’t keep his voice down!
Day 3
Immunity Challenge
Jeff Probst: Come on in, guys!
Jeff Probst: Today we are playing for immunity. In this challenge, teams have to assemble four wheels out of the large puzzle pieces that are given. Then they have to put these wheels onto a large cart, which then has to be navigated by the entire tribe though some rough terrain up until the finish line. When the entire tribe crosses the finish line, the tribe wins Immunity people from that tribe are safe at tomorrow’s tribal council. I’ll give you a minute to strategize and then we’ll get going.
[As the challenge starts, both teams race to open their bags, and free all the puzzle pieces. Both tribes seem to be neck and neck as they assemble their puzzle pieces into four wheels. They complete their carts roughly at the same time, with the winner of the challenge still unknown. However, as both tribes begin navigating their carts though the jungle, Kalu’s cart suffers a huge wipeout, slowing them down considerably. Meanwhile The Maha Tribe uses this opportunity to gain a lead, and finish first, as the Kalu tribe is unable to catch up, thus winning the first immunity.]
Jeff Probst: Maha! Wins! Immunity!
[Triumphant music is played as the Maha members are shown to leave in high spirits.]
Shane (confessional): Well, we won the first Immunity challenge. This just shows that even though you are behind, it’s never too late to swing the momentum in your favour and kick some ass. And that’s what happened to the other team. They got their asses kicked today.
Part 3:
Kalu Tribe
Phillip (confessional): Today… at the Immunity challenge… it was a humbling experience. To be honest I expected us to DESTROY the other team. But nope… not so easy… They just showed us that they ARE worthy opponents indeed, and I’m looking forward to going against them in the challenges that are to come to see – which tribe, ultimately, has the best warriors.
Sierra (confessional): Ugh, we lost. That sucks so badly. Now we have to go to Tribal tonight. I’m really scared, but hopefully Phillip will be the one voted out tonight and not me.
[Sierra is shown to be talking to Taj and Erinn again]
Sierra: Well here we are now… We gotta go voted somebody out
Taj: We sure do…
Sierra: It’s Phillip, right? That who ya’ll are voting for?
Taj: Yeah, I guess so… We have any other choice?
Sierra: I don’t know… It just seems the most obvious to me that Phillip should go, because, you know…
Taj: Yeah, well… I guess we gotta do what we gotta do. This is what the game’s about after all…
[Sierra leaves, as the two women remain seated in the shelter.]
Taj: I don’t know Erinn, what are you thoughts about the vote?
Erinn: I don’t know… are you sure we’re making the right choice here?
Taj: Yeah that’s what I’m thinking about… I mean to be honest with you… There are reasons to vote out both Phillip and Sierra.
Taj (confessional): This tribal is gonna be hard for me. I’ve played with Sierra in
[Meanwhile, as the scene changes, Phillip is shown talking to
Phillip: Sierra needs to be the one to go.
Phillip: Well I see then…
Phillip (confessional): After a talk with
[As the tribal council looms near, minutes before they are off, Sierra is shown talking to Kenny.]
Sierra: The tribal council is just around the corner. I’m really scared, I feel like I’m gonna be the one going home.
Kenny: Why do you think so?
Sierra: Everybody I’ve talked with seems undecided between voting for me or Phillip. But how do I know they’re not lying to me? You can never know things like that!
Kenny: But at one point you’ve just gotta trust in the alliances you’ve made.
Sierra: But what if everybody betrays me? What if I’m voted out FIRST??
Kenny: When… then the game’s over for you. I can’t word it differently, this is just a fact.
Kenny: I like Sierra. She’s a very nice girl. But it seems like she really isn’t cut out for this game. She’s too emotional! From a personal standpoint, I don’t want Sierra to go, but this game isn’t personal. It’s strategic. And that’s why I really don’t know what I’m going to do…
Tribal Council:
[The players arrive at tribal council.]
Jeff Probst: Welcome to Tribal Council. Behind each of you is a torch. Grab it and dip it into fire. Here, on the island fire represents your life. When the fire is out, so are you.
[Survivors ignite their torches and sit down on the benches.]
Jeff Probst: This is your first Tribal Council. Let’s talk about personalities. Natalie, who are the biggest personalities in your camp?
Natalie B.: Well the biggest “personality”, is by far Phillip. I don’t think you’d ever able to find another guy like that.
Jeff Probst: You mean that in a positive or negative way?
Natalie B.: None of those, to be honest. I was just stating a simple fact, that’s all…
Jeff Probst: Alright. Phillip. You’ve been with your tribemates for three days already. Who do you think is not cut out for this game?
Phillip: Oh, definitely Sierra. I think she’s too insecure. She’s too emotional and…
Sierra: Well it’s hard not to be emotional when someone’s yelling at you!
Phillip: …Excuse me… I don’t think I’ve ever interrupted YOU when YOU were talking, so let me finish…
Sierra: …Seriously? You’ve been yelling at me from DAY ONE
Phillip: … Sierra… I’m going to ask you calmly – please let me finish what I was going to say!
Sierra: No! I’m not gonna let you finish! You’ve said enough already!
Corinne: Oh, please would you two just shut up already. This is what it’s like every day, Jeff. It’s getting ridiculous…
Jeff Probst: Well, it’s obvious that there is a conflict that is needed to be resolved at Tribal Council tonight. Let’s see how everybody’s gonna vote. Marty, you’re up…
[One by one the survivors go up to the urn and cast their votes. Phillip votes for Sierra…]
Phillip: This game is not for you, Sierra. You are too immature for it
[…while Sierra votes for Phillip.]
Sierra: You are a psycho. Go away!
[Everybody else’s vote remains concealed.]
Jeff Probst: I’ll go tally the votes…
[Jeff goes to get the urn. The close up shots of Sierra and Phillip are shown. Sierra looks miserable while Phillip looks somewhat angry.]
Jeff Probst: Once the votes are read, the decision is final. The person voted out will be asked to leave the Tribal Council immediately. I’ll read the votes…
[Jeff opens the urn and holds up the vote.]
Jeff Probst: First vote – PHILLIP
[Phillip nods in acknowledgment.]
Jeff Probst: SIERRA
Jeff Probst: SIERRA
Jeff Probst: SIERRA
[Sierra looks really nervous while Phillip begins to smile.]
Jeff Probst: SIERRA
Jeff Probst: That’s four votes Sierra, one vote Phillip
Jeff Probst: SIERRA
Jeff Probst: …First person voted out of Survivor: … SIERRA. That’s six votes, that’s enough, you have to bring me your torch
[Sierra looks completely miserable, on the verge of crying.]
Jeff Probst: Sierra… The tribe has spoken.
[Phillip has a triumphant look on his face, while Sierra slowly walks away, sobbing.]
Jeff Probst: Well… your tribe had two people as a source of conflict. You’ve voted out one of them. Let’s see if it improves your performance in challenges. You can now head back to camp. Good night.
[As the outro music plays, Phillip is shown once again, walking out of the Tribal council triumphantly.]
NEXT TIME ON – SURVIVOR
Jeff Probst: At Maha Tribe, the old conflict between two former enemies reaches its peak
Brenda (confessional): Holly is the next to go, no question.
Holly (confessional): If everything works out as I planned, Brenda WILL be gone!
Jeff Probst: While at Kalu – with Sierra gone and nowhere left to hide, people are scrambling for alliances.
[Corinne and Taj are shown shaking hands. Marty and Natalie B. are shown making a pact.]
[The clips change to Sierra talking to the camera.]
Sierra: I’m so devastated right now… *sobbing*. I can’t believe everybody voted me out like that. It sucks that you think you trust people… you think they’re on your side… And then they stab you in the back without any kind of remorse. It’s just so unfair.
I would love to hear your feedback about the first episode =D
Ill post all the extra stuff tomorrow.


