Is Amber the most stale, characterless hag to ever win the game? in Lions, Tigers, Survivors

0 Points

Is Amber the most stale, characterless hag to ever win the game?

Started By	Comment
Lurlene McDaniels		#61	[-]
Posts: 1695 (01/26/12 08:26 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Forum Love Remove this ad ^Agree that Richard/Sandra/Parvati/Boston Rob are the four most entertaining winners. Todd and Fabio were pretty good too. Bob, Natalie, Tom, Tina, Ethan, Earl and Amber were all pretty boring as far as Survivor characters go, but seem like they would be pretty cool and overall nice people in real life. Sophie, Yul and Vecepia seem like they are boring in real life as well as on Survivor.
Boston Rob Mariano		#62	[-]
Posts: 398 (01/26/12 08:27 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	jonnyfairplay wrote: Zesty66 wrote: If we're ranking winners from the season that they won - then you can definitely throw BRob in the mix. He was as stale and characterless as they come. And Natalie White was not "characterless." She epitomised the sweet Southern Belle. Where was there any footage of Natalie White in that season to characterize? You can blink and not realize she's in Samoa until she kills the rat. Which is a shame, since Natalie could've been on Elisabeth Hassellback level of love and Brett could've been as loved as Colby if they weren't both robbed of edits. Samoa was, imo, the season that "Could have been" meaning so many characters could've shined through if Russell wasn't on the season (Dave Ball, Brett, Natalie, John, Laura, Shambo, Black Russell)
Boston Rob Mariano		#63	[-]
Posts: 399 (01/26/12 08:28 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Lurlene McDaniels wrote: ^Agree that Richard/Sandra/Parvati/Boston Rob are the four most entertaining winners. Todd and Fabio were pretty good too. Bob, Natalie, Tom, Tina, Ethan, Earl and Amber were all pretty boring as far as Survivor characters go, but seem like they would be pretty cool and overall nice people in real life. Sophie, Yul and Vecepia seem like they are boring in real life as well as on Survivor. This post is so correct, with the exception of Yul. I think Yul might be boring, but still one of the nicest people Yul ever meet.
jonnyfairplay		#64	[-]
Posts: 1805 (01/26/12 08:29 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Cuntella wrote: Vee is one of the people I'd actually like to see play again. Amber, not so much (not that she would). I think that's got to stand for something. I'd rather see anybody but Boston Rob play again, because he's become as stale as hell, especially Vee because she's only played game once and has shown a propensity to think strategically and play like a gamer, but I doubt anyone will ever beat Boston Rob's ASS season for me in terms of entertainment value. That or Richard's S1 is my favorite game (not best strategically, obviously, but most entertaining) of all time. In other reality shows the only thing that might beat it for me is Dick's BB8.
jonnyfairplay		#65	[-]
Posts: 1806 (01/26/12 08:31 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Boston Rob Mariano wrote: jonnyfairplay wrote: Zesty66 wrote: If we're ranking winners from the season that they won - then you can definitely throw BRob in the mix. He was as stale and characterless as they come. And Natalie White was not "characterless." She epitomised the sweet Southern Belle. Where was there any footage of Natalie White in that season to characterize? You can blink and not realize she's in Samoa until she kills the rat. Which is a shame, since Natalie could've been on Elisabeth Hassellback level of love and Brett could've been as loved as Colby if they weren't both robbed of edits. Samoa was, imo, the season that "Could have been" meaning so many characters could've shined through if Russell wasn't on the season (Dave Ball, Brett, Natalie, John, Laura, Shambo, Black Russell) I mean, Russell's confessional count, despite him being a very important character, was definitely way too high and partially to blame, but I want to keep banging the "20 people is way, way too many for a half-season reality show comprised of 15 episodes" drum.
Cuntella		#66	[-]
Posts: 815 (01/26/12 08:41 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	jonnyfairplay wrote: Cuntella wrote: Vee is one of the people I'd actually like to see play again. Amber, not so much (not that she would). I think that's got to stand for something. I'd rather see anybody but Boston Rob play again, because he's become as stale as hell, especially Vee because she's only played game once and has shown a propensity to think strategically and play like a gamer, but I doubt anyone will ever beat Boston Rob's ASS season for me in terms of entertainment value. That or Richard's S1 is my favorite game (not best strategically, obviously, but most entertaining) of all time. In other reality shows the only thing that might beat it for me is Dick's BB8. Nobody ever wants to see BRob play again but only because he's worn out his interest not that he ever had none.
Boston Rob Mariano		#67	[-]
Posts: 402 (01/26/12 08:54 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	As I much as love BRob, his story arc is done. He was the punk kid, he got the girl and almost won, reinvented himself as a hero but got taken out by the next generation villain, and then beat that villain and won. His 180 is finished, his character and Survivor life is complete and ended. There is no reason for him to come back, unless he really, really wants to make the jury. However, I have no doubt that the producers will likely beg him to come back if they do an "Ultimate All-Stars" for the final season or something like that.
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#68	[-]
Posts: 13013 (01/26/12 08:56 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	^ Absolutely. But for the record, he got taken out by JERRI, not Russhole.
Boston Rob Mariano		#69	[-]
Posts: 403 (01/26/12 08:58 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Dr Will Hatch two point oh wrote: ^ Absolutely. But for the record, he got taken out by JERRI, not Russhole. Yes, but that's how the whole season was set up. Rob vs. Russell so everyone assumed OMG RUSSELL TOOK OUT ROB. Believe me, I laugh and at everyone saying Russell got out Rob and how Rob was like "The new generation is getting smart and took me out." LOL You got taken out by someone on the SECOND season, not the new generation.
Polonium		#70	[-]
Posts: 10278 (01/26/12 08:58 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Forum Love Remove this ad And he didn't "beat" Russell in S22. The only thing worse than Probst, the producers, and CBS trying to peddle that Rob vs. Russell crap is the fact that there are actually people out there who bought into it. Russell was beaten by the Zapatera Six, who believe it or not, were also playing Survivor that season.
Boston Rob Mariano		#71	[-]
Posts: 404 (01/26/12 09:03 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Polonium wrote: And he didn't "beat" Russell in S22. The only thing worse than Probst, the producers, and CBS trying to peddle that Rob vs. Russell crap is the fact that there are actually people out there who bought into it. Russell was beaten by the Zapatera Six, who believe it or not, were also playing Survivor that season. Well technically Rob "beat" Russell because he placed higher, but yes, the Zaps "took out" Russell. Believe me, I'm a huge Rob fan, but I still find the entire Rob vs. Russell concept idiotic and pointless. I'm glad he won, but still, it was a stupid concept.
andrew51491		#72	[-]
Posts: 673 (01/26/12 09:04 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Actually, it can be said Russell beat Rob. Russell swayed Jerri's decision by voting out Rob. They were on the same tribe in HvV, but not RI. They should have used this One World season for Rob & Russell. It would have made things a lot more interesting.
jonnyfairplay		#73	[-]
Posts: 1809 (01/26/12 09:05 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	If Parvati leaves at the Tyson boot, is Rob on track to be in the final 3 with Courtney and Sandra? The Villains come into the merge with Timbira or Koror-type numbers (Tyson and Rob rapin' the Heroes people up). Rob, Courtney and Sandra were all insanely tight (the girls adored Rob and he was loyal to them) and were planning on going to the F3 together. Tyson was totally ready to flip at F7 (presumably with Danielle, Coach, and Jerri to boot Rob - in fact, his vote for Parvati was largely motivated by his desire to farm Russell for the jury/acquire him as a post-merge pawn to topple Rob) but Coach is never ever going to backstab Rob because he's an idiot and worships Rob. Rob probably will move to get rid of Tyson right after JT is gone, anyway. Rob beats Courtney (who doesn't get any credit) and Sandra (a previous winner) in a landslide. Jerri needs to win two ICs for the FTC to become competitive, though she still probably loses. Every time I think about Tyson's decision to vote for Parvati I cry, for a million reasons, one of which being I would have appreciated a Rob HvV win more than a Rob RI win.
Boston Rob Mariano		#74	[-]
Posts: 406 (01/26/12 09:08 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Well, it's as Rob said in RI, one person doesn't take out someone, it takes many people. So Parvati, Danielle. Russell, and Jerri all took out Rob. Unless it's a FIC winner catsing a vote or someone playing an idol and all votes are negated except theirs, it doesn't just take one person to get someone out.
marshal99		#75	[-]
Posts: 4214 (01/26/12 09:08 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Doesn't matter , i wouldn't want to see Rob (or Russell or James or Rupert or those 2-3 timers) in the next all-stars. Should let the players from recent seasons S16-24 to appear on the next all-stars. I wouldn't want to see Rob on survivor unless they do a all-winners season or the last season of survivor.
Katy Carney		#76	[-]
Posts: 14705 (01/26/12 09:09 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Parvati wouldn't have left, she played an idol that Russell gave her thinking he was sacrificing himself, so he would have given it regardless. Rob was too big of a target. If he did make it to the end despite all odds the Heroes would have just voted for some random background extra in the seat next him.
Boston Rob Mariano		#77	[-]
Posts: 407 (01/26/12 09:09 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	jonnyfairplay wrote: If Parvati leaves at the Tyson boot, is Rob on track to be in the final 3 with Courtney and Sandra? The Villains come into the merge with Timbira or Koror-type numbers (Tyson and Rob rapin' the Heroes people up). Rob, Courtney and Sandra were all insanely tight (the girls adored Rob and he was loyal to them) and were planning on going to the F3 together. Tyson was totally ready to flip at F7 (presumably with Danielle, Coach, and Jerri to boot Rob - in fact, his vote for Parvati was largely motivated by his desire to farm Russell for the jury/acquire him as a post-merge pawn to topple Rob) but Coach is never ever going to backstab Rob because he's an idiot and worships Rob. Rob probably will move to get rid of Tyson right after JT is gone, anyway. Rob beats Courtney (who doesn't get any credit) and Sandra (a previous winner) in a landslide. Jerri needs to win two ICs for the FTC to become competitive, though she still probably loses. Every time I think about Tyson's decision to vote for Parvati I cry, for a million reasons, one of which being I would have appreciated a Rob HvV win more than a Rob RI win. XXXX. Rob was likable and a hero in HvV, he was a douche and boring in RI.
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#78	[-]
Posts: 13015 (01/26/12 09:10 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	andrew51491 wrote: Actually, it can be said Russell beat Rob. Russell swayed Jerri's decision by voting out Rob. They were on the same tribe in HvV, but not RI. They should have used this One World season for Rob & Russell. It would have made things a lot more interesting. But he didn't sway her. She took out Rob for many reasons, one of which is that Rob is a better player than Russell and thus less of a FTC goat.
Boston Rob Mariano		#79	[-]
Posts: 408 (01/26/12 09:12 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Also because Jerri knew how Rob played on ASS and didn't trust him at all. And since she didn't know who Russell was, she sided with the unknown rather than the known double dealer.
andrew51491		#80	[-]
Posts: 674 (01/26/12 09:12 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Forum Love Remove this ad marshal99 wrote: Doesn't matter , i wouldn't want to see Rob (or Russell or James or Rupert or those 2-3 timers) in the next all-stars. Should let the players from recent seasons S16-24 to appear on the next all-stars. I wouldn't want to see Rob on survivor unless they do a all-winners season or the last season of survivor. Agreed. I wish they would have done Survivor 9-19 for only HvV.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Is Amber the most stale, characterless hag to ever win the game?