1. David Hernandez (The first performance of the season that actually made me think we could have a winner)
2. David Cook (A legit rock performance, he lost points by backtalking Simon but still as a singer, he should be in the Top 12 easily)
3. Danny Noriega (Much better than last week, I actually really liked this.)
4. Luke Menard (He reminds me of a much less vocally controlled version of Shane Wiebe from CI2. I really like him and this was an admirable attempt of a damn challenging song.)
5. David Archuleta (As much as I hate him for trying to do that to "Imagine", I cant deny that the vocals were at least good.)
6. Jason Castro (Not as great as last week, he's getting old very fast.)
7. Michael Johns (He had the right sounding voice but this was a very bad vocal)
8. Chikezie (Annoying and his voice was awful in the high notes despite being strong in the low)
9. Jason Yeager (I wanted to like him but this was so cheesy)
10. Robbie Carrico (No energy and yeah I think he's fake)

B: Yeager/Luke
H: Carrico/Yeager
G: Yeager/Chikezie