Awful night. No way should Syesha or Kirsty be in the top half. Aside from Amanda, all the worst performances were from those who butchered ballads, even simple ballads (Hopelessly Devoted to You) that Carmen Rasmussen could handle.

1. Brooke
2. Carly

3. Alexandria

4. Syesha
5. Kristy

6. Ramiele
7. Kady

8. Asia'h
9. Alaina

10. Amanda