Hot and Not

S1: Colleen and Susan
S2: Jerri and Debb
S3: KimP and Linda
S4: Sarah and Patricia
S5: Stephanie and Jan
S6: Heidi and Jeanne
S7: Tijuana and Lillian
S8: Amber and Sue
S9: Dolly and Twila (assuming Scout looked atleast average in her youth)
S10: Jenn and Janu
S11: Brooke and Brianna
S12: Misty and Tina
S13: Cecilia and Jessica
S14: Stacy and Cassandra
S15: Courtney and Denise
S16: Alexis and Kathleen

OVERALL
Dolly and Denise