troybfreewill wrote:

what if someone has a fake hidden immunity idol which erik thinks is real and he agrees to swap his immunity idol for the fake hidden immunity idol. i know right, why the hell would someone do that but in the probst preview natalie says "who would fall for that, like i feel stupid listening to you guys" if erik saw it to be somehow beneficial for him to swap then i dunno, it could happen you never know.

Well technically having an immunity idol gives you more power then just regular immunity. You can decide who leaves with the idol, if you play it right like Amanda did. Erik might have been wanting to do the same thing Amanda did. So if he stupidly thought it was a real idol, I could see why he would want it.