Both Amber and Parvati were the obvious "WTF?" choice for All-Stars but the huge difference is that Parv proved she could kick it up a notch on her second try and show people that she deserved to be there.

Amber played the exact same way both times, never brought anything new to the table and won because the second time she picked the right person to hide behind.

Not to mention both started off with a showmance but Parv showed us it was only temporary and she wasn't afraid to kick it to the curb if that what she needed to do to win, whereas Amber probably would've withered and died had Mariano got voted off and in the end she was practically willing to give him the win.


So ultimately Parvati >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Amber.