ILovegreeneyes wrote:

realityshowfantard wrote:



ILovegreeneyes wrote:



SurvivorFanGP wrote:

Right, because if Simon says a performance is the best of the season, that MUST mean he's right and that's final. "Without You" stank.
"Stuff Like That There, "Natural Woman" > Without You




well in Season 1 it meant more cuz he wasn't the lying manipulative fuckwit he is now image


Simon has always been a lying manipulative fuckwit.




not true... if he were he wouldn't have praised Nikki in top 4 of season 1 and criticized Tamyra... He didn't understand how easily manipulated
the American voting public was yet....



Given HOW bad Tamyra was, there was no way not to criticize her and maintain any credibility. Praising Nikki also seemed to be a no-brainer. He could have spun it a bit, though, if he wanted to influence the voting...