I care, AMAI. Only insofar as I would never watch again if Archie wins. Two seventeen year olds in a row? And neither being the best? And if they lower the age even further? What would be the point of watching for anyone who is an adult? Of course, I would still have my life if I never watched again, so it really isn't that big a deal. :) But they WOULD have to change the name of the show to "American Tween Dream" or "American Tiger Beat(s Off)" or "Telegaspers" or something.