Why don't you do a simple "Top 5" poll for this season to see if that producers a different result than the rank on a scale of 1-10 format. That might be a better measure of true popularity, than the old 1-10 format which forces people to rate players they are indifferent to, mixes up most loved with mosr hated, and encourages the strategic voting down of players thought to be to popular.

People list their 5 top favorites:

Parvati
Eliza
Cirie
Natalie
Tracy

You tell us how many 1sts, 2nds, etc each player got.