It's stupid if someone like Chad wins the S13 poll because he generates mildly positive indifference, and all the real favorites have their lovers and haters. The 1-10 ranking is meaningless for players like Mariano or Steph (Parvati tends that way too), because they are widely LOVED AND HATED, AND THE 1-10 FORMAT CANNOT DISTNGUISH THAT FROM INDIFFERENCE.

A format where people list all their faves is more meaningful, especially looking back on past seasons.