1. Alexandrea Lushington- Spinning Wheel
2. Michael Johns- It's All Wrong, But It's All Right
3. David Cook- Hello
4. Michael Johns- Go Your Own Way
5. Alaina Whitaker- More Today Than Yesterday
6. David Archuleta- Imagine
7. Syesha Mercado- If I Was Your Woman
8. David Cook- Daytripper
9. Brooke White- Hero
10. David Cook- Music of the Night

11. Kady Malloy- Groovy Kind of Love
12. David Hernandez- Pappa Was Rolling Stone
13. Michael Johns- Come on Baby Light My Fire
14. David Cook- All Right Now
15. David Cook- Little Sparrow
16. Chickezie- I Believe
17. Ramielle Malubay- In My Life
18. Syesha Mercado- Fever
19. Carly Smithson- The Shadow Of Your Smile
20. Brooke White- Every Breath You Take

21. David Cook- Bille Jean
22. Syesha Mercado- Vanishing
23. Syesha Mercado- Thank The Lord For the Nightime
24. Carly Smithson- Total Eclipse of the Heart
25. David Archuletta- Smokey Mountain Memories
26. David Cook- The World I Know
27. David Hernandez- It's All Coming Back To Me
28. David Archuletta- Long and Winding Road

I rated every performance on a scale of 1-5 and those are all the ones that were a 4.0 or above