A number of this year's semifinalists still have fans mourning their quick demise (Kady, Alaina, Alexandrea and Danny). Even Amy has one serious fan in sucks (Screerider). So I think it's noteworthy that Robbie's slightly unexpected departure upset absolutely no one, even though he sang pretty well on top 10 guys night. Obviously his personality is the cause. His huge ego, obvious delight at being on camera, wig, general phoniness and having the bad taste to date Britney Spears all pissed people off. Still, I'm sure that in the future we will see him at rock concerts appearing in front of thousands of people. As a roadie.