I also think swim4life is being too nasty. Millions of people get cancer each year (I know--my mother died of cancer last year) but this site is about Idol, and Luke did make it to round 3 of the semis this year, one of only 16 out of the tens of thousands who auditioned. And not many people get cancer while they are still in their 20s. So yes, he is a nobody, but in a very real sense he's OUR nobody since we follow the show so closely and he WAS on the show long enough for some of us to care about him, however minimally. Nobody who's ever made it to the semis on American Idol has died so far, and that's a perfect record I'd like to see continue for as long as possible.