Fourth place goes to...

4. Muffy

image

I guess everyone will be happy with this choice. XD
Muffy is the waitress at the bar in town. She's like 35 and totally doesn't look it. She's always very nice and flirty to the point of flirting to all of the guys in town. She really does want to marry you, but I just don't find her the best choice to marry of the 3 (or 4 in AWLSE) choices. If y'all do get married, she doesn't know how to be the best mother, so that can spell trouble at times. Overall, a very nice person. :)
I will post third place soon!