Besides Sherea's low ranking I like PT's list

#7
Colleen Haskell
image

OMGWTFBBQ!!!!!

Yeah yeah I know, how can I dare rate America's Sweetheart out of the final four? HOW DARE I!

Let me explain. For those of you that don't know, I am pretty darn new to Survivor. Cook Islands was my first season that I actually watched. I watched the Borneo finale with my grandparents and some bits of AllStars and heard about the highlight of the premeire of PI from my dad who isn't a fan but liked that episode. I slowly but surely always had little experiences with Survivor, like accidentally discovering FGC way before I was a survivor fan. I was always interested in the concept, and would scetch out random seasons of Survivor with video game charachters and/or my friends in class. Finnaly I found CI on demand and, despite how bad it was in retrospect, got hooked.

After coming to Sucks via FGC, I decided to go back and watch the old seasons [the only one I've finished before CI is Borneo though]. There was all the hype about how wonderful and adorable Colleen was...

But then I watched Borneo. And yes, she was adorable, and cute, and wonderful and all those lovely things but the sad thing was that because of all the hype I was underwhelmed by her. She was great, but not nearly so great as I had been lead to believe by folk. So I am sullen in my belief that, sort of like Sephiroth, she's awesome but overrated.