MikiBoi wrote:
yeah. Amerikan Idol 6 & OZ Idol 6 are my least fav evers. I go back and forth with CI6 because the winner and Amberly rocked and I loved Drew. CI4 I really only liked Eva in the 10 and I hated pretty much everyone else, especially Katy and Brandon who are some of the most atricious people to ever make a Top 10/12 round imo of any Idol franchise.

For me the worst seasons ever would be American & OZ Idol 6 and Kanadian Idol 4 with 6 a close second.
For me the worst season of OzI was 6, but 5 and 3 weren't that great either. 1,2 & 4 were really great though. CI3 was the worst because of the terrible top 10. Both CI3 & 4 had awful top 3s (Mel & Eva excluded). Gayry, TrainRex and Craigina were the worst top 2 finalists. Compared to those 3, Mitch and Jaydee don't look so bad. CI2 was the best but season 6 is my second favorite. At least CI5 had a decent top 3 but the top 22 wasn't good as a whole unlike CI6. So many things to factor in. I just like a lot of people in season 6.


suckshardcore wrote:

I love Amberly and she's my favourite Canadian Idol contestant ever and I did love Earl and I think Theo is good but overall Season 6 was all kinds of atrocious. The problem with CI though is that it's best season came too early. CI2 was so amazing that everything since then hasn't been nearly as good in comparison. Taking CI2 out of the equation some of the other seasons aren't that bad, and actually quite good. In any case everything about CI6 was pretty much fucked up and it ruined any momentum or potential it had going in the beginning. I hate CI6 with a seething passion.

CI2 was long enough ago that it shouldn't matter anymore. Mookie, Amberley, Earl and Theo still made it pretty far. What ruined season 6 was the elimination of Amberley, Mookie and Earl leaving a top 3 of Drew, Theo and Mitch. I actually like them all to a degree but it was the wrong top 3.

suckshardcore wrote:
I'm starting to see a tend here though American Idol 3/6 - WORST SEASON EVER!, Canadian Idol 3/4 - WORST SEASON EVER!, Australian Idol 3/5/6 - WORST SEASON EVER! It's the curse Shrieky-Lee

Fixed