I don't get why people think Sugar was wrong to take the last cookie. Randy chided her and lorded the cookies over her and said he was in charge of who got the one that he was going to give to her. She should not have said anything the first time and just given her cookie to Matty. And Randy offered her his last cookie, and said he wasn't hungry anymore, so what is the problem? She did what I would have done, after his 'performance' about who ruled the cookies.