1. Kelly - based on how i felt at the time, I hated Richard and would have voted for Kelly. I also thought she played well and did outwit everyone just she was to wishy-washy the whole time. Looking back I would have voted Richard.
2. Colby - I really like Tina but I was impressed by his ability to stay out of conflict for the most part (minus Keith) and win so much in a season when everyone was starving. That season was really tough with the flood and the lack of food. His move to take Tina in the end was stupid but showed loyalty. Looking back I'm not sure if I woul dhave changed my vote.
3. Ethan - Nothing would have made me vote for Kim J.
4. Neleh - This one was tough either way but I just didnt see Vecepia really playing the game until afterwards looking back. So at the time it would have been Neleh but either way I would have been upset at the F2
5. Brian - He dominated the game for 39 days.
6. Matt - As much as Jenna player the game, she whinned and was a bitch. Her social game would have been enough for me to think about voting. When you live with the same people for 39 days every waking minute, the social game really effects you. This would have been a vote against jenna not for matt.
7. Sandra - as much as Lill impressed me by making it to the end, Sandra never had her name come up. She was never silent and fought with peopl but she was never a target. Her move to follow Burton and Jon into the woods and have Tijuana listen was brillant.
8. Amber - a voted against Rob not for Amber. As much as rob deserved to win his social game was outright nasty.
9. Twila - at the time i respected Twila for just downright lying to the women's alliance. The promise made on her son was blown out of proportion and used against her. Its something thats been used before in survivor and always worked. She was panicy at times but I felt that she played the game the best. If it werent for Leann and Ami's moment of weakness to vote Eliza out and keep Chris another 3 days, Chris would never had been in the fina two.
10. Katie - Katie played the game, Tom just won challenges. He even said his strategy was not to be the leader but he ended up as one. Katie was nasty toward people but she was loyal and did play well. I think this would have been a vote against Tom not for Katie though
11. Danni - There is something to be said for someone who can outlast an entire allaince after they eat yours.
12. Aras - I'm not sure how well he played but he did appear to be in on every one of Cirie's moves. Plus he was a strong contributor at camp and in challenges. DAnielle did a lot of whinning and was extremely lazy.
13. Yul - His use of the idol to gain back Jonathon was brillant. His gameplay overroad Ozzy's physical challenges.
14. Earl - He was the only one who played smart in the f3. the other two were wasted spaces
15. Todd - perfect final tribal council performance. he had a plan and stuck to it. I was impressed with Courtney but Todd was the ring leader and Amanda boomed at the end
16. Parvati - if Amanda had taken out Parvati she would have gotten my vote (as long as Cirie wasnt there either) but Parvati played the best out of the two.
17. Sugar - she actually played the game unlike Bob who admitted that he wasnt good at the strategizing or the actaully ruthlessness of the game. Between Bob and Susie I would have voted Susie since she made moves that took down the Onions as well as being in the majority at the original Fang. She won important IC's and Bob would have been toast had Sugar not gotten weak at the end.