| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 cantthinkofaname |
Re: S11 Relationship Chart - Steph | ||
|
Posts: 1610 (12/23/05 5:50 PM) Registered User |
She hardly said anything. (nothing that'd be counted as a sentence) A little SPV. But pretty much nothing.
thank you btw I'm working on one for amazon (one with MORP, MORN, INV, and the numbers.) I can't find my Africa or Thailand tapes right now. So, I thought I'd just do Amazon. |
||
 Unregistered(d) |
Re: S11 Relationship Chart - Steph | ||
|
Posts: 0 (12/23/05 6:31 PM) |
This is an interesting thread.
|
||
|
survivoronline2005 |
Re: S11 Relationship Chart - Steph | ||
|
Posts: 927 (01/02/06 8:04 PM) Guatemala |
What do all the dveribations means? Middle of the road and Under the radar are the only ones I know
|
||
|
craig |
Re: S11 Relationship Chart - Steph | ||
|
Posts: 16620 (01/02/06 11:15 PM) Registered User |
OTT - over the top
CP - complex personality MOR - middle of the road UTR - under the radar INV - invisible P - positive tone N - negative tone |
||
|
cantthinkofaname |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 1610 (01/07/06 5:51 PM) Registered User |
bump
changed Marquesas edgic chart on page 7 |
||
|
cantthinkofaname |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 1610 (01/17/06 5:23 AM) Registered User |
My finished Amazon Edgic
 Any comments or different opinions? |
||
|
Survivor2345andbeyond |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 3633 (01/17/06 8:11 AM) Registered User |
Matt the Machete Man with not one negative?
No Negatives for Jeanne? 1 Negative for Joanna? why does jenna get a neagtive for episode 5? |
||
|
TheIsraeliDevil |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 2147 (01/17/06 12:41 PM) Registered User |
Matt was OTTN at the merge.
|
||
|
Oowatanite |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 9592 (01/17/06 10:03 PM) Registered User |
Why didn't Roger get an "N" tone overall?
Matt got 8 Ps and 0 Ns? Wow. I didn't think that Matt was very positive in the first half of the game. And the "creepy machete sharpening" deserved an N as well. Alex had 4 ps and 1 N and ended up neutral overall? Was Dan that bad? (2 Ns and one INV) |
||
|
MasterDarkNinja |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 2939 (01/17/06 11:46 PM) Registered User |
I've never seen S6 and I can't understand how Dan got a UTRN rating overall when getting a MOR3 and CP5 for two of his three ratings. Shouldn't that be MORN?
|
||
|
cantthinkofaname |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 1610 (01/18/06 12:06 AM) Registered User |
I'm gonna make some changes. I just wanted to get as much feedback as I could before I do that.
Maybe you guys could tell me which episodes certain people deserved a neutral rather than positive or negative rather than neutral and the like. |
||
|
cantthinkofaname |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 1610 (01/21/06 10:16 PM) Registered User |
bump
need some feedback (like described in the post above) |
||
|
guatemala fanfic |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 5480 (01/21/06 10:45 PM) |
Cantthinkofaname:
Please check the S11 Edgic thread. I posted an updated version of proposed changes for Marquesas based on our ratings and what other people replied with - please let me know if there is anything you are strongly opposed to. |
||
|
craig |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 16620 (01/27/06 7:20 AM) Registered User |
I guess the season charts at the beginning of this thread should be updated to include s3 and S4.
I think there must be some mistake with Rudy and Jan's final ratings as we currently have them. Rudy is UTR, should be UTRP. He was givien 6 Ps and only 2 Ns over the season. The Ns came when he was UTR, the Ps in his more prominent episodes. Besides he's one of the most loved Survivors ever. Jan is UTRP, should be UTR. She was given 2 Ps and 2 Ns over the season, and was neutral in her final episodes. I don't know how S5 final ratings were decided, since the thread fell victim to the hacker. Clay is MOR (there was no MORN in Thailand), should ne MORN. That should be uncontroversial, since he got 6 N and 1 P over the season, including 3 OTTN. Having him MOR besides Brian CPN is deceptive as to tone. We should probably leave re-rating Amazon to post S12, since it was already done reasonably well and is very controversial. With those changes, the winners are as follows: CPP - Tina, Sandra, Tom CP - Chris CPN - Richard, Brian MORP - Ethan, Amber MOR - Jenna UTRP - Danni UTR - Vee And the 2nd to 4th place finishers are: OTTP - Elizabeth OTT - Eliza OTTN - Sue, JFP CPP - Kelly W, Tom, Kathy, Helen, Matt, Ian, Rafe CP - Colby, Twila, Steph CPN - Lex, Rob C, Rob M MORP - Kim J, Neleh, Paschal, Rupert MOR - Keith, Lillian, JLew, Scout MORN - Clay, Katie UTRP - Rudy, Butch, Lydia UTR - Jan, Darrah, Jenn |
||
|
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 6458 (01/28/06 1:50 PM) Registered User |
^ Those are really good, except for Colby. He seems like CPP, he had like a kingly edit (aside from a short period of time where Ogakor seemed to have a negative edit when compared to Kucha).
|
||
|
9RedWing19 |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 2695 (01/29/06 12:00 PM) Registered User |
Quote: Craig, the S1 ratings are primarily my handiwork, although there was some participation by others and KQ did agree to change the ratings. I'd direct you to the discussion in the S1 Edgic thread (in the Attic), but unfortunately it did not survive last May's attack. I think Rudy was a borderline P / Neutral call that fell into the Neutral side. FWIW, his original rating was MOR, not MORP. |
||
|
craig |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 16620 (01/31/06 9:59 PM) Registered User |
The question is "how P is P?" We've been more and less generous different times. If Neleh is P, if Gary is P just because he was a fan fave and had a couple P episodes out of 11, then heroes like Rudy and Colby should be P.
|
||
|
MasterDarkNinja |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 2939 (02/28/06 12:10 AM) Registered User |
Here's some relationship charts I made for S12, don't completely rule out someone making it to the F2 from a lack of relationships though (as S11 showed).
Key  Aras  Cirie  Danielle  Shane  Terry 
|
||
|
Survivor2345andbeyond |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 3633 (04/24/06 8:39 PM) Registered User |
.
|
||
|
cantthinkofaname |
Re: Edgic Charts | ||
|
Posts: 1610 (04/25/06 12:29 AM) Registered User |
Bump, I edited my Amazon edgic.
It's on this page |
||
