| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
Editted, Astro.
|
|||
YemaGrl1988 |
|||
81. Parvati Shallow (Survivor: Cook Islands - 6th Place & Survivor: Micronesia - 1st Place)=\ |
|||
A Dying Clown |
|||
|
I pretty much agree with all the Micronesia rankings (except I'd swap James' position with Joel, as entertaining meatheads go. And move everyone down
about 30 places, but they'd still be roughly in the same order). I'm looking forward to Gabon rankings
|
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
117. Michelle Chase (Survivor: Gabon - 18th Place) Going into this season, I expected Michelle to be as boring and shitty as Amanda was. After all they're a very similar demographic of seemingly sweet, young, athletic brunettes. But once the show began and Michelle was the last player picked, the love began. She was basically like an unsuccessful Courtney because she hated how stupid her tribe was and she hated the fact that they were all losers. She was one of the only players on the tribe worth anything, and yet they voted her out because she had a bad attitude. So ironic. Also, she was more than willing to try a termite and establish a friendship with a nerd like Ken, which was surprising for a relatively attractive cast member to bother forming an alliance with someone scrawny and obviously socially inept. It was a really sweet pairing.
170. Gillian Larson (Survivor: Gabon - 17th Place) I'll give Gillian credit for being a true fan of the show and applying for it as many times as she did. I'll also give her credit for believing so firmly in the dream that she'd get on the show that she wouldn't buy a buff from the online store, preferring to get her own. But on the show, she was just too perky and too useless. She couldn't do anything, so she tried to cheerlead way too much, so she wasn't even fun and adorable like Lydia was. She was just the crazy old lady that didn't fit in with anyone. She seemed more interested in being back home in Africa than she was in playing Survivor...you know, the game she signed up for and applid so many times for.
162. Paloma Soto-Castillo (Survivor: Gabon - 16th Place) My biggest issue with Paloma was that she was just so bland in the first two episodes, and then she was like a negative sweetheart, which just doesn't work as a personality type. I knew from the minute I saw her bio and her casting video that she would do little more than take up space in the season, and fortunately, she didn't take up space for too long. I rank her as high as I do mainly because of her final tribal council performance when she was just coming up with gold in terms of how and why she disliked Ace. We could be brother and sister in another life...AFTER I'M DEAD. Classic.
196. Jacquie Berg (Survivor: Gabon - 15th Place) Honestly, there's not a whole lot to say about Jacquie, because she's boring. She's one of those typical, non-descript girls that doesn't do anything but attempt to look pretty and goes far because no one has her on their radar. I rank her as high as I do, just above Mary (who I also moved up a few spaces) because of the fact that Jacquie really had the game in the palm of her hand. She had a solid alliance of four and she had a side alliance with two of her tribemates. Unfortunately, she got split up from her alliance of four and was forced onto a tribe of complete losers that couldn't win a challenge to save their lives. She also got stuck with the one player from her original tribe who desperately wanted to jump ship and the strongest player from her original tribe. As a result, she was an easy target when the losers went to tribal council, and as a result, I feel bad for Jacquie, because she really got screwed.
249. Danny "GC" Brown (Survivor: Gabon - 14th Place) And Danny comes in as one of my bottom four players of all time, just above asshole Rocky, and quitting bitches Osten and Lisi. Honestly, GC may not have physically quit like Osten did, but he's pathetic and I'm really glad he's gone. Seeing players get taken out before him because of his strength, when he never even tried in some of the challenges, is disgusting. And the fact that he was just so negative and loserish is unforgivable. His tribe gave him the role of leader, which granted, was a mistake on their part, but still, he could've tried a little harder. He constantly tripped up and bitched and moaned about wanting to eat more when his tribe was running low on rice by the third episode. Everything had to go GC's way, or else he would get all stubborn and confrontational. And in his last episode, he was so much of an asshole that he took off in his tribe's canoe and almost caused them to go to the immunity challenge without him. Did he care? No. And because he basically asked his tribe to vote him out, they were prevented from taking out the hidden immunity idol when it was their best chance to do it. Danny ruined the early part of Gabon and we can only hope it improves now that he's gone. |
|||
spnintendo |
|||
|
GC HATE <333 Well earned.
|
|||
Edinboro |
|||
|
Paloma could have been the next Fijis Michelle...I miss her..
|
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
|
"My strategy is like the animals in the wild... to watch, and then I'm going to prounce on someone and eat 'em up." -Paloma
"I'm trying to like plant things in people's heads and make them go all like crazy with ideas..." -Paloma "Paloma, did Ace stand out to you as a big character?" -Jeff "Yah. Ace is like the head honcho at our campsite." -Paloma "How do you feel about that?" -Jeff "I mean, he can be the big guy all he wants, I could care less. But as far as I'm concerned, I'm not even going to go there." -Paloma "Not even going to go where????" -Jeff "Do the whole like, Ace is my hero thing." -Paloma "So clearly Ace is not your hero?" -Jeff "No." *Smile* -Paloma ... "He didn't bring his back with him so he can't be that worried." -Paloma "Wow. Do you think you could have been brother-sister in another life?" -Jeff "Maybe. In another world. A thousand years from now. When I'm ... DEAD." *Smile* - Paloma <333 |
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Oh and I thought GC was actually funny and cool in his post show interviews, but he was pretty bad on the show.
|
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
His post-show interviews came off as someone who was desperately trying to save face.
|
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
|
I guess its perception... I got the saving face feeling from many survivors over the years, but GC seemed pretty "real" to me... like he didn't
care what people thought, he accepted that he quit, and unlike several survivors who bitched about editing, he knew that editing is part of making a good show,
and he understood/accepted that he was probably portrayed like a douche because of the way he left. I found it refreshing to hear.
|
|||
5urvivor |
|||
|
Yeah I thought GC was an alright guy
|
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
|
|||
maldoror122 |
|||
|
Kelly <3
Fang <3 Actually, Fang is fast becoming one of my favorite tribes of all time. |
|||
CSCin3D |
|||
|
Gillian-hating scum
|
|||
Thailandsurvivor |
|||
|
They talk about everything out there, so of course they'll bring up that Dan could have found the idol. Just because the editors decided to show it (and fake you out) doesn't mean they're a bunch of idiots. And I loved Michelle, but someone who brings a negative energy to camp or becomes an outcast needs to leave over a challenge liability (same reason GC needed to leave). Then again, not like it worked out for Ogakor, Chuay Gahn, and Drake. |
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Fang was awesome, definitely a great tribe to root for. Then came NuFang, which is even better, entertainment wise. I thought Kota was boring the first 2 eps
as well, but brought something interesting in episode 3, IMO. On the other hand, NuKota is one of the most boring tribes in survivor history. They are about a
million times more boring than NuLaMina ever was.
|
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
I rank NuFang low for the same reason I rank Osten, Rocky, Lisi, etc. low. Boring is bad, but bad is worse. It's not entertaining to see this group of
failures suck so badly physically, strategically, socially, and more. They ate all their rice early on and have been starving, and it's just painful to
watch them try to succeed. NuKota has Randy, who provides entertainment, and Bob, who's always entertaining in the challenges with his random moves, and
Marcus is just cute and smart and did I mention cute? Kota has people I could actually root for, whereas Fang just has a bunch of losers who I only started
rooting for this episode because they finally made some smart strategic moves.
|
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
111. Ace Gordon (Survivor: Gabon - 12th Place) Honestly, as a person, I despised Ace. He was arrogant and he was a complete douchebag during his time on the show. Pretty much the main reason for liking him early one was the fact that British accents and bald heads (like, completely bald) are hot. But despite his douchiness, Ace proved that he was dominant in the game. He may have done poorly in some physical challenges once joining NuFang, but compared to the rest of the rejects on his tribe, he was Terry and Tom put together. Strategically, Ace was above everyone else on his tribe and was able to get away with being an arrogant tool for so long because he was just so good at snaking his way through the game. In the end though, he was taken out by his own little pocket ally, which is truly the best way he could've gone out. Better to go down in flames like a true villain than to limp through the game and be taken out as a threat after the merge. It's a lot like Fairplay losing to Lill and getting voted out at the final 3.
151. Dan Kay (Survivor: Gabon - 11th Place) Honestly, there's not a whole lot that's interesting about Dan, at least not enough to rank him about thirty places higher than my list of boring, forgettable alpha males. But Dan was different. He was never cocky and he was never arrogant, and he really did seem like a nice guy who wanted to help his tribe succeed. Seriously, he was EXACTLY like Michael Cera in mannerisms, appearance, voice, and everything. It was adorable because he's like this lovable little loser from high school that wants to be popular, but he's too sensative to be a douchebag like most popular kids are. Dan's story was cute, but still, he was boring enough to rank low. |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
98. Marcus Lehman (Survivor: Gabon - 10th Place) Yes, I know Marcus is somewhat boring, but I don't care. I thought he was awesome. Prior to the season, I hated him, because he was a typical mactor and they kept repeating his same confessional over and over in the commercials, but then the show started and I fell in love. He was extremely cute (the hottest guy of the season, and ranks up there with Edgardo and Bobby Jon), and he was strong and he was smart. Sure he was arrogant, but he was right to be arrogant. I mean, for fuck's sake, it was like up until his boot episode, he was playing against a cast filled entirely with retards. He was the silent leader of the Onion alliance, which, while not the most interesting alliance in the world, at least seemed to play with precision and strategy. For the first seven episodes of the season, he was completely immune, including individual immunity at the two tribal councils he had to go to. But honestly, none of this really sets Marcus apart from countless other bland to semi-bland alpha males. What ranks him in my top 100 (for now) is the fact that he got completely screwed by a twist. YES, you should be prepared for a tribal swap at some point during the show, but expecting two is overthinking things. Plus, Marcus happened to get paired up with the biggest flake in the game, someone who was on the outs with him even before the previous vote, along with the two biggest schemers from the opposing tribe. He never stood a chance. At least he seems to have accepted defeat graciously and he's actually pretty funny in his interviews, including when he mentioned his air guitar skills and the need to buy more secure boxers.
64. New Fang (Ace, Crystal, GC, Jacquie, Kelly, Ken, Matty, Sugar) Honestly, prior to the double boot episode, I hated this tribe. Ace was an ass, albiet a clever one that was the brains of the tribe. GC was a lazy quitter. Sugar was comically inept. Crystal was bitchy and mean...and I could go on and on. The tribe was dysfunctional, but not in a fun way like New Casaya. The tribe never enjoyed themselves, they lost EVERY challenge, and each week it was like watching a bunch of five year olds trying to strategize. It was honestly like they were trying to play two different games at the same time. First, they booted Jacquie, which was good from a strategic standpoint because she was not in the majority alliance and she was a threat with Sugar joining the tribe. But then, they booted GC and Kelly, two members of that majority alliance, and left a massive schemer in the game along with his ally who had the idol. Meanwhile, Matty jumped ship in an emotional decision when he ws in a great position! This tribe was fucking stupid until Ken finally got his act together and tricked Sugar into booting her closest ally, keeping Crystal in the game. That's the main reason this tribe isn't the worst ever, because they made ONE smart move, whereas New Ravu never made a smart move EVER.
40. New Kota (Bob, Charlie, Corinne, Dan, Marcus, Randy, Susie) Boring or not, I liked this tribe just like I liked Marcus. They were very strong players and they basically had their shit in gear, strategically. Had it not been for the tribe swap, I think New Kota could easily have dominated the game. The biggest reason for my love of this tribe was basically the amount of greatness Randy brought to it. From taunting Fang to tricking Ace, he was epic in every challenge. And he was smart and game-saavy enough to take Bob's place as the fourth member of the Onion alliance. Meanwhile, Bob has hd his moments of complete zaniness, like his boxer-wearing chicken dance or his sobbing over the letters from home. Even Susie had some good moments when she set off Corinne into one of the craziest bitch rants of the season. For a boring tribe, I liked Kota a lot, so they manage to just crack the top 40 (for now at least). |
|||
kenc333 |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 wrote:I love reading your rankings, Kitty, but I kinda have to disagree with this one point. I dunno, but Marcus' post-show interviews aren't the most gracious things in the world... |
|||