| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
survivorisdabest |
|||
|
Exactly, natalie can beat erik in immunity for them. Now its a position where one of the two immunity threats is going to lose ANYWAY, so they'll just vote
them out.
|
|||
AllMenAreIslands |
|||
WatchMeNext wrote: Yes, they all did say that. And yet editing went to the effort of showing us later how Parvati GOT HER WAY when it came to whom to boot, Alexis or Natalie.
Remember, Amanda wanted to target Natalie probably in a bid to reduce the number of solid allies Parvati would have left in the game. Never mind that
people's opinions are Parvati is mistaken, we were shown that she is actually running the game because the person she wants booted is the one who gets
booted. Maybe they had to show that question & answer because it was an integral part of the challenge, but what they did not have to show was Amanda NOT
getting her wish (to boot Natalie.) Including that information is what strengthens the argument that Parvati wins.
|
|||
AllMenAreIslands |
|||
WatchMeNext wrote: Um... think it through, WMN. Think about what Parvati stands to gain from keeping Natalie, making & keeping promises to her. From PARVATI's perspective, having "Natalie the Challenge Threat" is actually preferable, since if it's a surprise F2, it will be NAT who boots Amanda out keeping Parvy's hands clean. Cirie isn't a threat to win an endurance challenge, so she cannot be counted on to do dirty work for Parvati. And Parv needs someone else to boot her closest ally. If it's an F3, but it ends in a 3-3-1 tie, perhaps the person getting 1 vote will be asked to cast a vote right there and then at the Final TC. It's
more likely that Natalie would vote for Parvati than for Amanda. Nobody knows how a tie at the final vote will be handled, but it doesn't hurt to install
as many players in the F4/F3 as possible who would pick you to stay in the game over anyone else left. With Alexis out of the picture, Natalie is more likely
to vote for Parvati over just about anyone else. It's sure not thanks to Erik that she's still in the game.
Last Edited By: AllMenAreIslands
05/04/08 2:07 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
WatchMeNext |
|||
|
ok, I concede
|
|||
yosimtesam |
|||
|
it may appear that the logic is impeccable; but i ask you this; if you pour a glass exactly half ful... is it half full or half empty... is it.... is it.... im
just saying...
|
|||
Loony Moonie |
|||
|
Your logic was astonishing, AllMenAreIslands! At first glance, I thought it was a bad move, but after reading your post... yeah, Parvati is smarter than I
thought.
|
|||