Welcome to the new survey/list thread where we will ultimately come up with the list of the Top 25 greatest Big Brother contestants in terms of overall game
play. For the ballot, I chucked off those that didn't make it far (with the exception of Kaysar in All Stars who played a great game and ended up
slaughtered thanks to the veto competition) along with obvious non-players such as Bunky or Jameka. Also, you're given the option of not having to rate
those you feel won't be anywhere close to making the Top 25.
This has never been attempted at Sucks before so I'm crossing my fingers that this turns out alright. If so, then we can later finally have a Sucks consensus on Survivor players. Think of this as a test-run for that.
The list:
30. James Rhine, BB6 (on pg. 3)
29. Sharon Obermueller, BB9 (on pg. 4)
28. Jessica Hughbanks, BB8 (on pg. 4)
27. Monica Bailey, BB2 (on pg. 5)
26. Karen O'Neil-Ganci, BB5 (on pg.5)
25. Drew Daniel, BB5 (on pg. 6)
24. Marvin Latimer, BB5 (on pg. 6)
23. Hardy Ames-Hill, BB2 (on pg. 7)
22. Mike "Boogie" Malin, BB7 (on pg. 7)
21. Nicole Nilson Schaffrich, BB2 (on pg.7)
20. Adam Jasinki, BB9 (on pg.7)
19. Janelle Pierzina, BB7 (on pg.11)
18. Lisa Donahue, BB3 (on pg.11)
17. Danielle Reyes, BB7 (on pg.11)
16. Robert "Memphis" Garrett, BB10 (on pg.17)
15. Keesha Smith, BB10 (on pg. 17)
14. Janelle Pierzina, BB6 (on pg.11)
13. Maggie Ausburn, BB6 (on pg.11)
12. Jen Johnson, BB8 (on pg.12)
11. Lorenza "Renny" Martin, BB10 (on pg.17)
10. Diane Henry, BB5 (on pg.14)
9. Jennifer "Nakomis" Dedmon, BB5 (on pg.15)
8. Libra Thompson, BB10 (on pg.17)
7. Jason Guy, BB3 (on pg.15)
6. Jun Song, BB4 (on pg.15)
5. Dan Gheesling, BB10 (on pg.17)
4. Will Kirby, BB7 (on pg.15)
3. Alison Irwin, BB4 (on pg.15)
2. Danielle Reyes, BB3 (on pg15)
1. Will Kirby, BB2 (on pg.15)
Season Count:
BB2: 4
BB3: 3
BB4: 2
BB5: 5
BB6: 3
BB7: 4
BB8: 2
BB9: 2
BB10: 5
Season With The Most Players: 5 - BB5 & BB10
Least Players From A Season: 2 - BB4 & BB8 & BB9
Players On The List Twice: 3 - BB2/BB3/BB6 & BB7
Winners On The List: BB5, BB7, BB9, BB3, BB6, BB4, BB10, BB2
Lowest Placing Of Someone On The List: 9th Place - BB10 (Libra)
Of note, the Top 15 only houses four male gamers, two of which are Will Kirby so that means only three guys are in the Top 15 whereas there are nine females accounting for eleven games. It is a 19-11 split overall in favor of females.
This has never been attempted at Sucks before so I'm crossing my fingers that this turns out alright. If so, then we can later finally have a Sucks consensus on Survivor players. Think of this as a test-run for that.
The list:
30. James Rhine, BB6 (on pg. 3)
29. Sharon Obermueller, BB9 (on pg. 4)
28. Jessica Hughbanks, BB8 (on pg. 4)
27. Monica Bailey, BB2 (on pg. 5)
26. Karen O'Neil-Ganci, BB5 (on pg.5)
25. Drew Daniel, BB5 (on pg. 6)
24. Marvin Latimer, BB5 (on pg. 6)
23. Hardy Ames-Hill, BB2 (on pg. 7)
22. Mike "Boogie" Malin, BB7 (on pg. 7)
21. Nicole Nilson Schaffrich, BB2 (on pg.7)
20. Adam Jasinki, BB9 (on pg.7)
19. Janelle Pierzina, BB7 (on pg.11)
18. Lisa Donahue, BB3 (on pg.11)
17. Danielle Reyes, BB7 (on pg.11)
16. Robert "Memphis" Garrett, BB10 (on pg.17)
15. Keesha Smith, BB10 (on pg. 17)
14. Janelle Pierzina, BB6 (on pg.11)
13. Maggie Ausburn, BB6 (on pg.11)
12. Jen Johnson, BB8 (on pg.12)
11. Lorenza "Renny" Martin, BB10 (on pg.17)
10. Diane Henry, BB5 (on pg.14)
9. Jennifer "Nakomis" Dedmon, BB5 (on pg.15)
8. Libra Thompson, BB10 (on pg.17)
7. Jason Guy, BB3 (on pg.15)
6. Jun Song, BB4 (on pg.15)
5. Dan Gheesling, BB10 (on pg.17)
4. Will Kirby, BB7 (on pg.15)
3. Alison Irwin, BB4 (on pg.15)
2. Danielle Reyes, BB3 (on pg15)
1. Will Kirby, BB2 (on pg.15)
Season Count:
BB2: 4
BB3: 3
BB4: 2
BB5: 5
BB6: 3
BB7: 4
BB8: 2
BB9: 2
BB10: 5
Season With The Most Players: 5 - BB5 & BB10
Least Players From A Season: 2 - BB4 & BB8 & BB9
Players On The List Twice: 3 - BB2/BB3/BB6 & BB7
Winners On The List: BB5, BB7, BB9, BB3, BB6, BB4, BB10, BB2
Lowest Placing Of Someone On The List: 9th Place - BB10 (Libra)
Of note, the Top 15 only houses four male gamers, two of which are Will Kirby so that means only three guys are in the Top 15 whereas there are nine females accounting for eleven games. It is a 19-11 split overall in favor of females.
