I thought their freestyle was the best choreography of the three (by FAR), adorable, perfectly suited to her....and she danced the hell out of it - and to my thinking, that's what won it for her
And I'm perfectly happy with her win
wtg Shawn!
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
azcanadienne |
|||
|
I thought their freestyle was the best choreography of the three (by FAR), adorable, perfectly suited to her....and she danced the hell out of it - and to my thinking, that's what won it for her And I'm perfectly happy with her win
|
|||
ericartman |
|||
|
It's funny people trying to justify Shawn's win. Voters just liked her. If it had anything to do with dancing she wouldn't have even been in the
final three. Kim is alot better dancer than her.
|
|||
SentinelHeart |
|||
|
Cheryl totally dropped the ball with the freestyle dance. Guess she was too sure she'd win whatever she does.
|
|||
tomash |
|||
|
Lil Kim is way too classy for that tacky mirror ball trophy anyways <3 <3
|
|||
Willy2Fun |
|||
|
Yup, it's a Mark win in my books. I cannot stand Shawn and I'm so disappointed she won. I can't watch this 'popularity' fest again,
ever...nope, I'm not watching it EVER again. Okay, that's a wrap!
and as I type this THUNDERSTORM!! YEAH!! God has added his pissy opinion too! She's going down. No more bloody Olympic athletes ..please. |
|||
Mel P |
|||
anders332 wrote:I think it DID cost him the trophy...while a lot of voting has to do with popularity, there was less than 1% separating Shawn and Gilles as they said last night, so I think a better freestyle would have gotten Gilles the votes needed to give him the trophy. |
|||
ZombieLinda |
|||
|
ATHLETEOWNAGE returning <3 I do agree that Olympians have an innate and almost unfair advantage though. They're obviously naturally more coordinated
than the average D-List celeb, not to mention they're usually massively popular and well known. Most of the others just have niche fanbases going in to it.
Maurice was the only Olympian that's been voted off and he wasn't nearly as popular as Kristi, Apolo, and Shawn (or Misty who probably would have been
top 3 despite being a boring, wooden hag). But yeah, Shawn won with her freestyle and Gilles lost with his. Shawn's was just so much more fun and exciting
than the other two, which didn't really give anyone a reason to vote for them.
And didn't a lot of the people complaining about Shawn's win love Ty? You can't really complain about popularity trumping dance ability when you were cheering on that uncoordinated doofus. I also love how there's now been three female winners in a row when everyone was whining that a woman would NEVER win if Mel B couldn't (including Maks, who wasn't paired with any of the three and whose popularity seems to have plummeted lately <3). And in case it hasn't been pointed out yet, the HOUGH TRIO has completely dominated the last five seasons.
I guess Corky really does control what partners they get. Mark is defo the best male pro though. He's had frontrunners as partners in 3/4 of his seasons, but his dances are almost always more fun and modern than ultra lame Victorian bores like Jonathan. His only shining moment was Marie's psycho doll freestyle. |
|||
swim4life227 |
|||
|
Last Edited By: swim4life227
05/20/09 9:34 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Ethel Mae Potter |
|||
she314 wrote: Someone in this thread made that same joke pages back! When I heard it I was like "heard that one already at OSTS" we should be fucking comedy writers. |
|||
Kenscookie |
|||
dissimilis wrote:I tend to agree. All 4 of the above mentioned are on the same level. Each pulled out great dances and each made their mistakes. I'm happy for Shawn; but I still was hoping for a Tony win. It's true that he's just not that great a choreographer, but I still love the guy.
Last Edited By: Kenscookie
05/20/09 10:20 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
James Barber |
|||
ericartman wrote:Kim had a stronger personality, but she also had limited practice time and some injury. She also had a rougher around the edges persona. I think it was a big accomplishment that Kim got to F5 (in most seasons she would have at least gotten F4 but people loved Ty -- if Nancy had been there instead of Melissa she would have gotten F3). Sabrina and her fellow Cheetah Girl Kiely were both upset Mark won. They said so on Twitter. Sabrina's comments she claims are because she wanted Cheryl and Gilles to win, but her friend is more direct. "I am upset Mark wond dancing with the stars. I think he is a gump, and he's short." "I'm mad that mark (sold no records) won dtws. He's a gump, and he's short." "Yu can be mad at me world, but if you love puppies, you'll hate mark" "Guys, I only watched when Sabrina was on or when she makes and will admit that I don't like Mark because well...I'm allowed...I'm American." Now I'm ever more amused he won. The meltdowns are priceless. |
|||
croakrqueen |
|||
|
I was a Melissa fan, but based off the last several episodes, Shawn/Mark did deserve to win.
|
|||
Carboys Desire |
|||
dissimilis wrote: And he has a fug face. |
|||
LPMA |
|||
|
Can Edyta be paired with a frontrunner next season? Please?
|
|||
Ahminept |
|||
LPMA wrote: x |
|||
Carboys Desire |
|||
|
I like Edyta well enough, but she's never really stood out as a frontrunner herself and that can't be by accident. Aside from her hot body, is she
really that good? Maybe if I were straight that wouldn't matter.
|
|||
Screerider |
|||
|
Edyta's choreography is the problem.
And what was that awkward moment with Bergeron, Edyta, and LT about? He asked her "What's it like to have a partner even you can't make smile?" or something? |
|||
CAPSattack |
|||
|
Gilles sucks. I am glad the pimped one did not win.
MC Lyte for next season plz |
|||
Carboys Desire |
|||
|
Every time I remember that Cheryl didn't win I get a happy tingle inside.
|
|||
Monsieur Muggles |
|||
James Barber wrote:How bad was that breakup??? I thought they were friendly to each other. |
|||