Login
ForgotPassword?
Sign Up
Search this Topic:
Forum Jump
Posts: 789
10/09/08 10:58 AM
10/09/08 01:23 PM
Posts: 6711
10/09/08 01:34 PM
Registered user
Posts: 4203
10/09/08 04:19 PM
bazzar trhead
10/09/08 05:08 PM
10/10/08 10:58 AM
Posts: 12035
10/10/08 11:04 AM
10/10/08 01:11 PM
10/11/08 09:41 AM
Posts: 9
10/11/08 10:05 AM
0 hail mary 0 wrote: Jim Norton would win it all =D
Posts: 5954
10/11/08 11:30 AM
10/12/08 12:46 PM
10/13/08 05:32 PM
10/14/08 06:46 PM
Posts: 3482
10/14/08 10:03 PM
Posts: 6626
10/15/08 01:09 AM
0 hail mary 0 wrote: #279 - Wanda (Palau)
#278 - Sonja (Borneo)
#277 - BB
#272 - Gary Stritseky (Fiji)
#271 - Johnny Fairplay (Micronesia)
#270 - Jim Lynch (Guatemala)
#269 - Kimmi Kappenberg (Australia)
#268 - Patricia Jackson (Marquesas)
#267 - Tanya Vance (Thailand)
Posts: 27212
10/15/08 01:17 AM
OMEDETO, CATHY!!
10/15/08 01:55 AM
Pulau Tiga wrote: 0 hail mary 0 wrote: #279 - Wanda (Palau) Wanda had plenty of relationships with plenty of people and would not have been the first boot of the game without that silly pick-'em twist. She was just no one's strong #2, which is what you needed to be in order to survive (either that, or a clear challenge asset). Wanda didn't do anything wrong, and she didn't make any mistakes. She was a victim of her age, and while she could have survived the tribal assignments with the right strategy, it's unfair to say she was a poor player for not developing that strategy, since it would have been unnecessary in any normal vote-off situation. #278 - Sonja (Borneo) Sonja would have done just fine for herself if not for Sue's bitter little betrayal of the female alliance. Sonja went into TC thinking she was safe, and was backstabbed by someone whose actions could not have been predicted. #272 - Gary Stritseky (Fiji) The man would have done just fine for himself if he hadn't been evacuated from the game. He was on the outs of the Moto alliance, but that alliance was more focused on eliminating "threats" like Liliana anyway. And even if Moto went on a losing streak, Papa Smurf was way more well-liked by his tribe than either Cassandra or Dreamz. #271 - Johnny Fairplay (Micronesia) Fairplay was damn impressive in the short amount of time he spent playing the game in Micronesia. Quitting is a pretty big minus, of course, but he played a hell of a lot better than any of the other quitters, like Osten or Janu. #270 - Jim Lynch (Guatemala) Eh, injury. Things might have been completely different if that hadn't happened. #268 - Patricia Jackson (Marquesas) Victim of Maraamu's power struggle. Not saying it excuses her, but again, she's not someone who really did anything wrong. She should have been safe, except the alpha males of the tribe caused a hell of a lot of pre-merge strategic controversy. #267 - Tanya Vance (Thailand) More sickness. She was well liked enough that she might have done very well had her body been able to cope better.
Posts: 14610
10/15/08 11:21 AM
10/15/08 02:11 PM
Kitty Pryde1 wrote: The problem with this list is that you automatically rank people low for placing low in their season, rather than looking at how well they could've done. Also, older, weaker players aren't poor strategists because they're weak. It's the young, strong players that are booted early that really suck at the game, because they're the ones that their tribe should want to keep around for challenges, and they boot them anyway. Examples: Debb, Kel, Carl, Peter, Hunter, John R., Jed, Ryan A., Daniel, JoAnna, Burton, Brook, Dolly, John P., Mia, Jonathan L., Jolanda, Jeff W., Tina S., Misty, Sekou, JP, Erica, Liliana, Chicken, Ashley, Dave C., Mikey, Michelle C., Jacquie.
Share This Link