Thailandsurvivor is ranking Survivor alliances! FINISHED!

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
Thailandsurvivor		#1441	[-]
Posts: 8332 (10/18/09 10:52 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Here is the final list. I'll add the Tocantins' alliances in with Samoa's at the end of the season. Spoiler [+] 1. Matt, Rob, Butch, Christy 2. Tagi 4 (Richard, Rudy, Susan, Kelly) 3. ClusterFang (Ken, Crystal, Sugar, Susie, Matty) 4. Samburu Elders (Frank, Teresa, Linda, Carl) 5. Rob and Kathy 6. Kathy, Sean, Neleh, Vecepia, Paschal 7. Yaxha 4 (Gary, Danni, Brandon, Bobby Jon) 8. Eliza, Chris, Scout, Twila 9. Rudy and Rupert 10. Stephenie and Bobby Jon 11. Mike, Elisabeth, Rodger, Jeff, Alicia, Nick 12. Misty and Sally 13. Black Widow Brigade (Natalie, Alexis, Amanda, Parvati, Cirie) 14. Matt and Jenna 15. Boron Boys (Tom, Lex, Ethan) 16. Zhan Hu 5 (Frosti, Peih-Gee, Erik, Jaime, Sherea) 17. Angie and Stephenie 18. Shane, Courtney, Danielle, Aras, Cirie, Bruce 19. Tina and Ethan 20. Crystal, Ken, GC, Kelly 21. JAYE (Jonathan, Ami, Yau Man, Eliza) 22. Brian and Ted/Brian and Clay/Brian and Helen 23. Axis of Evil (Judd, Cindy, Stephenie, Rafe, Lydia, Jamie) 24. Rupert, Sandra, Christa, Jon, Trish 25. Gina, Hunter, Patricia 26. Kathy, Chet, and Tracy 27. Fei Long 6 (Amanda, Todd, Courtney, James, Denise, Jean Robert) 28. Rafe and Danni 29. Tagi Woman's alliance (Stacey, Kelly, Sue, Sonja) 30. Tina, Keith, Colby, Elisabeth, Rodger 31. Gary and Amy 32. Jason and Eliza 33. Ken and Michelle 34. Lill and Skinny Ryan 35. Erin, Ken, Jake, Penny, Shii Ann 36. Candice, Jonathan, Becky, Yul, Sundra 37. Ace and Sugar 38. Barbecue alliance (Gervarse, Jenna, Colleen) 39, Fat Five (Rory, Bubba, Chris, Sarge, Chad) 40. Courtney and Leslie 41. Morgan 5 (Osten, Andrew, Tijuana, Ryno, Darrah) 42. Michelle, Earl, Yau Man, Cassandra, Dreamz 43. Matt, Ryan, Daniel 44. Amanda, Todd, Aaron 45. Lydia, Brian, Jamie 46. Raro girls (Parvati, Jenny, Rebecca, Brad, Cristina, Stephannie) 47. Bobby and Bruce 48. Tina, Keith, Colby, Jerri, Amber 49. Rocky, Jessica, Erica 50. Cristina and Cecilla 51. Tom, Ian, Katie, Jenn, Gregg 52. Cassandra, Dreamz, Papa Smurf 53. Danielle and Terry 54. Burton, Jon, Michelle, Shawn 55. Bobby Jon and Ibrehem 56. Chris, Julie, and Eliza 57. Coby and Janu 58. Chris, Twila, Julie, Sarge, Chad 59. Nate and Parvati 60. Ami, Scout, Twila, Leann 61. Chapera 6 (Rob, Amber, Jenna L., Rupert, Tom, Alicia) 62. Susie, Dan, Matty, Randy 63. Deena, Rob, Jenna, Alex, Heidi 64. Lex, Kathy, Shii Ann 65. Sean, Vecepia, Rob, Sarah 66. Young pretty girls + Deena (Jenna, Heidi, Shawna, Deena) 67. Joel, Mikey B, Mary, Alexis, Natalie, Erik, Jason 68. Aitu 4 (Becky, Sundra, Yul, Ozzy) 69. Ozzy, Cecilla, Sundra 70. Jerri's friends (Jerri, Amber, Colby, Mitchell) 71. Hiki girls (Sundra, Rebecca, Stephannie) 72. Guys alliance (Roger, Butch, Dave, Rob, Matt, Alex) 73. Chuay Gahn girls (Ghandia, Jan, Helen) 74. Ozzy, James, Parvati, Amanda 75. Nick and Austin 76. Sekou and Nate 77. Rotu 4 (John, Tammy, The General, Zoe) 78. Stephenie, Ian, Tom, Katie 79. Jed, Stephanie, Robb 80. Lill and Burton 81. Erik and Ozzy 82. Jeff and Kim 83. Rob, Amber, Lex, Kathy 84. Tom and Caryn 85. The Bowheads (Mia, Lisa, Julie, Eliza) 86. Matty and Ace 87. Dan and Terry 88. The Onions (Marcus, Jacquie, Corinne, Charlie, Randy) 89. Rob M. and Rob C. 90. Coby and Angie 91. Raro Brats (Jonathan, Candice, Adam, Parvati) 92. 4 Horsemen (Mookie, Alex, Edgardo, Dreamz) 93. Lisi, Stacy, Alex, Edgardo, Boo 94. Rocky and Mookie 95. Ozzy and JP 96. Jerri and Jenna L. 97. Ghandia and Ted 98. Mall Rats (Brandon, Lindsay, Silas, Kim. P.)
JackSparrowBauer		#1442	[-]
Posts: 2561 (10/19/09 8:37 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Great list ThaiSu! I thought the Amazon outcast alliance was great, mainly due to Rob C. I was also severely disappointed when Jenna won those last two IC's. Matt and Rob's relationship was classic. The Tagi 4 were the best part of Borneo for me, even though Kelly W was in that alliance dragging it down. Hatch/Rudy/Sue <3
goohst		#1443	[-]
Posts: 1281 (10/19/09 8:56 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Your taste in alliances <33
Quiddity		#1444	[-]
Posts: 6504 (10/19/09 4:28 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Congrats on finishing! <3 the final 2!
craig		#1445	[-]
Posts: 16313 (10/19/09 7:56 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [-] 1. Matt, Rob, Butch, Christy 2. Tagi 4 (Richard, Rudy, Susan, Kelly) 3. ClusterFang (Ken, Crystal, Sugar, Susie, Matty) 4. Samburu Elders (Frank, Teresa, Linda, Carl) 5. Rob and Kathy 6. Kathy, Sean, Neleh, Vecepia, Paschal 7. Yaxha 4 (Gary, Danni, Brandon, Bobby Jon) 8. Eliza, Chris, Scout, Twila 9. Rudy and Rupert 10. Stephenie and Bobby Jon 11. Mike, Elisabeth, Rodger, Jeff, Alicia, Nick 12. Misty and Sally 13. Black Widow Brigade (Natalie, Alexis, Amanda, Parvati, Cirie) I'd cool that you gave the Black Widows spooky number 13. They and the Tagi 4 and the only two listed above that deserve Top 10. I guess your criteria is 100% personal taste - not gameplay and success, not loyalty or really liking one another. Rupert and Rudy - voted together one episode, thus empowering Jenna Lewis. I like them both, but not much of an allaince Steph and Booby Jon- were in opposite allainces on Ulong and in S11, and didn't really like each other. Remember when Steph tried to Christy-boot snotrocket man because he was indecisive between keeping her or Ibe. Amazon Losers - Rob assembled them for strategic reasons, not because he liked them more than the Cool Kids. Christy thought Matt was cweepy and voted with them once. Butch and Matt were on opposite alliance at the beginning. Matt made a deal with Jenna and threw the final IC. The real legendary Amazon alliance, that produced a winner and was incredibly loyal, was Jenna and Heidi.
JackSparrowBauer		#1446	[-]
Posts: 2569 (10/19/09 8:06 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	craig wrote: Spoiler [-] 1. Matt, Rob, Butch, Christy 2. Tagi 4 (Richard, Rudy, Susan, Kelly) 3. ClusterFang (Ken, Crystal, Sugar, Susie, Matty) 4. Samburu Elders (Frank, Teresa, Linda, Carl) 5. Rob and Kathy 6. Kathy, Sean, Neleh, Vecepia, Paschal 7. Yaxha 4 (Gary, Danni, Brandon, Bobby Jon) 8. Eliza, Chris, Scout, Twila 9. Rudy and Rupert 10. Stephenie and Bobby Jon 11. Mike, Elisabeth, Rodger, Jeff, Alicia, Nick 12. Misty and Sally 13. Black Widow Brigade (Natalie, Alexis, Amanda, Parvati, Cirie) I'd cool that you gave the Black Widows spooky number 13. They and the Tagi 4 and the only two listed above that deserve Top 10. I guess your criteria is 100% personal taste - not gameplay and success, not loyalty or really liking one another. Rupert and Rudy - voted together one episode, thus empowering Jenna Lewis. I like them both, but not much of an allaince Steph and Booby Jon- were in opposite allainces on Ulong and in S11, and didn't really like each other. Remember when Steph tried to Christy-boot snotrocket man because he was indecisive between keeping her or Ibe. Amazon Losers - Rob assembled them for strategic reasons, not because he liked them more than the Cool Kids. Christy thought Matt was cweepy and voted with them once. Butch and Matt were on opposite alliance at the beginning. Matt made a deal with Jenna and threw the final IC. The real legendary Amazon alliance, that produced a winner and was incredibly loyal, was Jenna and Heidi. Did you even read his write-ups for those alliances?
Thailandsurvivor		#1447	[-]
Posts: 8342 (10/19/09 8:34 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	JackSparrowBauer wrote: Did you even read his write-ups for those alliances? X I'd cool that you gave the Black Widows spooky number 13. They and the Tagi 4 and the only two listed above that deserve Top 10. I guess your criteria is 100% personal taste - not gameplay and success, not loyalty or really liking one another. This is a biased ranking list based on my personal taste. I've never denied that. With that said, loyalty and success did play a factor, but how much I like them trumps that by a long shot. Rupert and Rudy - voted together one episode, thus empowering Jenna Lewis. I like them both, but not much of an allaince Wrong. They voted together at both TCs Rudy attended, and they would have kept that loyalty until the very end. Steph and Booby Jon- were in opposite allainces on Ulong and in S11, and didn't really like each other. Remember when Steph tried to Christy-boot snotrocket man because he was indecisive between keeping her or Ibe. Of course Steph tried to get Ibe to vote for BJ over her, why would she simply accept a 50/50 chance at getting knocked out? Still, BJ pulled through at the end, and that's what mattered. Amazon Losers - Rob assembled them for strategic reasons, not because he liked them more than the Cool Kids. Christy thought Matt was cweepy and voted with them once. Butch and Matt were on opposite alliance at the beginning. Matt made a deal with Jenna and threw the final IC. The real legendary Amazon alliance, that produced a winner and was incredibly loyal, was Jenna and Heidi. So since Janu tried to quit to keep Steph in the game, those two should be #2? There were plenty of people as loyal to each other as Jenna and Heidi were, so what if one didn't try to quit multiple times to save the other?
craig		#1448	[-]
Posts: 16314 (10/19/09 9:23 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Wrong. They voted together at both TCs Rudy attended, and they would have kept that loyalty until the very end. Technically you're right, but Rupert tacitly agreed that Rudy should go. I think of BJ keeping Steph as an anti-allaince move - putting challenge strength above previously made deals and personal loyalty. I love Jenna refusing to betray Heidi when Rob offered her F2, then giving Heidi immunity, and remaining fast friends to this day. The Loyalist beat the Schemer in the end. Meanwhile the Amazon outcasts probably haven't spoken in years (maybe Matt and Butch, that's it).
JackSparrowBauer		#1449	[-]
Posts: 2577 (10/19/09 9:25 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Jenna only won because she got lucky that Matt randomly became really smart and threw the Final 3 IC. Without that, she never would've won.
Thailandsurvivor		#1450	[-]
Posts: 8344 (10/19/09 9:25 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Steph was in no way, shape, or form weaker than Ibe. Tina and Colby were more loyal and successful than Jenna and Heidi. Rob wasn't playing the game to make friends, but I'm sure he still keeps in contact with Matt. Same goes for Matt and Butch. And Matt, Ryan, and Daniel.
JackSparrowBauer		#1451	[-]
Posts: 2578 (10/19/09 9:28 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Thailandsurvivor wrote: Steph was in no way, shape, or form weaker than Ibe.
craig		#1452	[-]
Posts: 16316 (10/19/09 9:46 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I think of BJ keeping Steph as an anti-allaince move - putting challenge strength above previously made deals Thai, you are agreeing with me. Steph was strong, her and BJ weren't really an alliance. Tom\Ian\Katie\Steph were the master alliance of Palau. Poor Steph got stuck with the losers, but still managed to outlast them and put on a Koror buff at the "absorbtion."That why it's so fitting that BJ leave by losing a challenge to Koror girl in spirit, Steph.
Thailandsurvivor		#1453	[-]
Posts: 8345 (10/19/09 9:53 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Angie was not a loser, and the late merge in Palau was a terrible twist.
survivorisdabest		#1454	[-]
Posts: 3763 (10/20/09 4:41 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Amazon cool kids > Amazon losers Raro were robbed
cardswin5		#1455	[-]
Posts: 2114 (10/20/09 12:28 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I disagree with your top few, but I'm much too lazy to make a list this intricate so thanks for doing all this. :)
Thailandsurvivor		#1456	[-]
Posts: 8351 (10/20/09 2:59 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Feel free to post your top 5 or 10 if you'd like. I've gave my reasonings, but I'd definitely like to here others' opinions.
Katy Carney		#1457	[-]
Posts: 9024 (10/20/09 4:25 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Jerri's friends <3 Mallrats <3 Deena and the pretty girls <3 Morgan 5 <3 Chaperatards <3 Axis of Evil <3 Rarotards <3 BBW <3
JackSparrowBauer		#1458	[-]
Posts: 2590 (10/20/09 7:14 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	BWB <3 JAYE <3 Coach/Tyson/Debbie <3 Casaya 6 <3 Steph/Angie <3 Chris/Twila/Scout/Eliza <3 Fat Five <3 Rob/Heidi/Deena <3 (Jenna and Alex were in that alliance too, but I hated them) Rob/Sean/Sarah/Vee <3 Vee/Neleh/Kathy/Paschal/Sean <3 those are my top 10. I don't know how I'd rank them, though.
Thailandsurvivor		#1459	[-]
Posts: 8362 (10/20/09 9:48 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	No short explanations?
JackSparrowBauer		#1460	[-]
Posts: 2601 (10/21/09 8:27 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I'll do short explanations I guess Coach/Tyson/Debbie (I LOVED all three of them, and the dynamics between them were hysterical. The three of them constantly kept everything entertaining, and were the only people who were actually interesting post-merge (other than Erinn). Coach and Tyson were my two favorites in Tocantins and Debbie was in my top 5, so three people so awesome aligned together amongst a bunch of dull people ranks them really high. Tocantins would've been much higher in my list of seasons if they succeeded and made F3) BWB (They were just epic. All the ridiculous blindsides they pulled off were so awesome, and just when it was getting old, they pulled off the most ridiculous blindside in the history of the show with the Erik boot. Add in the fact that Parv/Cirie/Natalie are all in my top 15 of all time, and Amanda was really awesome for a couple episodes down the stretch, that's one of my favorite alliances of all time) JAYE (Going into Micronesia, the 4 people I was most looking forward to seeing again were Jonathan, Ami, Eliza and Cirie. Seeing 3 of them aligned was awesome, and they countered one of the most repulsive alliances of all time, I liked them a lot.) Casaya 6 (the dynamics between the 6 of them were so hilarious. Easily the biggest trainwreck of an alliance of all time, but watching them succeed was even more hilarious. The lolworthy moments they provided were endless. Cirie also gave us one of my 3 favorite blindsides of all time in Courtney's boot. The 6 of them were just all so different and watching them interact never failed to entertain me.) Steph/Angie (Steph is my favorite contestant of all time, and Angie was awesome, too. They were so different, but watching their friendship/alliance grow was great to watch, particularly seeing as Ulong was a boys club for a while.) Chris/Twila/Scout/Eliza (they formed in one of the most epic overthrows of all time, and the dynamics between the 4 of them were hilarious. I pretty much agree with your entire write-up) Fat Five (They were just a really interesting group. Sarge/Rory's relationship was hilarious, Chris is my 2nd favorite contestant of all time, and Rory's in my top 10. Collectively, they were such an odd group, but I loved them. Probably my least favorite out of my top 10, though). Rob/Heidi/Deena/Jenna/Alex (This alliance pretty much brought a whole new spin to Amazon, seeing as it was nothing but a gender war before that. Rob/Heidi/Deena were easily my three favorites in Amazon. Even though I hated Alex and Jenna, the way they started off the Amazon post-merge was epic, even though they failed soon after). Rob/Sean/Sarah/Vee (They were such a unique alliance. Watching them succeed amongst their tribe even though they were so lazy was great. They were also a huge reason why Maraamu is one of the most entertaining tribes of all time, imo. Sean, Rob and Sarah were my three favorite in Marquesas, and watching this alliance was always entertaining) Vee/Neleh/Kathy/Paschal/Sean (This alliance was epic because their overthrow of the Rotu 4 was awesome, but they didn't start going "ZOMG GO US WE ARE THE BEST PEOPLE EVER LET'S NOT EVEN PLAY THE GAME FOR OURSELVES LET'S JUST LET THE DESERVING PEOPLE GO TO THE END <3" like the Aitu 4 did (o_O)), once Rotu was all gone, they still had a bunch of drama to provide within themselves and it was very entertaining to watch (ty Sean <3) so yeah Marquesas is in my top 5 seasons mainly because of this alliance. The open strategizing at F5/F4 TC's was great, too. Pretty much what you said in your write-up about them)

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Thailandsurvivor is ranking Survivor alliances! FINISHED!

Quick Reply