| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 chapera rocks |
|||
|
Posts: 10670 (04/08/09 10:14 PM) Registered User |
Katy Carney wrote:There's a difference between speculating what happens within a round (or even two) of the event and 6-7 rounds kthx (and before you spout off that James' evacuation was 6 rounds or so before the finals, remember that the final 2 switch wasn't known until the final 3, definitely). Its not hard to see that distinction. |
||
|
Katy Carney |
|||
|
Posts: 5447 (04/08/09 10:23 PM) |
Yeah for sure! Your random speculation is so much more factual and evidentiary than anyone else's bullshit! defo! gj!
|
||
|
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Posts: 505 (04/09/09 7:21 AM) |
Of course I'm not blaming Terry for Sally getting out, but at the time, I already hated him, and I wanted him to give her the immunity necklace, so that
way the Casaya people wouldn't know what to do since Terry had the idol, and they would've had a pretty good chance of someone from Casaya going home
without playing the idol.
But that's just what I wanted at the time. I'm happy with the way that season turned out. |
||
|
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Posts: 10672 (04/09/09 9:57 AM) Registered User |
Katy Carney wrote:So you're telling me that speculation within the same round or one round in advance (such as Fairplay saying what he would do, Jonathan saying what he would do, and almost every juror saying what they would do) is just as useless as speculation 7 rounds in advance (where no one discussed what would have happened had Sally stayed)?
|
||
|
Katy Carney |
|||
|
Posts: 5452 (04/09/09 12:51 PM) |
chapera rocks wrote: Yes. Not just useless but stupid. For instance: "If James hadn't been injured, Cirie would have beat Parvati."  Actually if James weren't injured the entire game would
have gone differently. Amanda wouldn't have used the idol on Alexis, and if she did James would have still be in the game. James could've beat Erik for
immunity. The fans could have taken control of the game. Parvati still could have won and Cirie still could have lost. James could have won. Erik could have
won. Alexis could have won. That's why it's such a stupid, hollow argument.
The Jonathan injury-less fantasies are similarly embarrassing and transparent and dumb. It's kind of pathetic. |
||
|
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Posts: 10678 (04/09/09 7:28 PM) Registered User |
Katy Carney wrote:Whatever you say to make Parvati look less lucky!
|
||
|
SwineForkbeard |
|||
|
Posts: 2188 (04/09/09 7:53 PM) Registered user
|
Do you realize you're just bumping a RavuRules ghostie thread with this off topic blather? Lock.ban.delete. |
||
|
mellow yellow16 |
... | ||
|
Posts: 73 (04/10/09 6:35 PM) |
Vanuatu - Tocantins (no winners/no repeats)
Ian - Palau Gary - Guatemala Judd - Guatemala Shane - Exile Island Jean-Robert - China Jason - Micronesia Randy - Gabon Tyson - Tocantins Stephen - Tocantins Julie - Vanuatu Twila - Vanuatu Cindy - Guatemala Danielle - Exile Island Candice - Cook Islands Peih-Gee - China Natalie - Micronesia Crystal - Gabon Sugar - Gabon Taj - Tocantins Borneo - Tocantins (no winners) Gervase - Borneo Colby - Outback Tom - Africa Sean - Marquesas Burton - Pearl Islands Ian - Palau Gary - Guatemala Shane - Exile Island Randy - Gabon Tyson - Tocantins Kelly - Borneo Jerri - Outback Kathy - Marquesas Shii Ann - Thailand Heidi - Amazon Twila - Vanuatu Cindy - Guatemala Peih-Gee - China Crystal - Gabon Erinn - Tocantins |
||
|
agent2424 |
|||
|
Posts: 3918 (04/10/09 7:57 PM) Registered user |
Tyson
Crystal Peih-Gee Yau-Man Parvati Cirie Shane Judd Stephanie Eliza Twila Sandra JFP Heidi Rob C Brian Sean R Rob M Jerri Richard --- All seasons but Africa represented... 9 previous all stars coming back & Stephanie.. for a 2nd time and 4 winners... |
||
|
chialphaforlife |
My Survivor All-Star Dream Cast | ||
|
Posts: 4 (04/11/09 1:05 PM) |
Gervase/Rich/Sue
Colby/Tina/Jerri/Elisabeth Lex/Ethan/Big Tom Boston Rob/Kathy Brian/Shii Ann Rob/Jenna/Matt/Christy Jon/Sandra/Burton Casting director(s): Trim as you feel necessary. |
||
|
chialphaforlife |
My Survivor (Micronesia) Fans vs. Favorites Dream Cast | ||
|
Posts: 5 (04/11/09 1:15 PM) |
Eliza/Ami/Twila/Rory/"Sarge"
Ian/Steph/Bobby Jon Judd/Rafe/Cindy Cirie/Shane/Danielle/Bruce "Ozzy"/Candice/Jonathan (with Parvati as an alternate, but we already know that she could win) Yau-Man/"Boo" (with "Rocky" as an alternate) Denise/Amanda/Courtney/James (or with James as an alternate) Erik, Jason, Natalie, Chet, Kathy ("KB"), Joel, Alexis, Tracy, "Mikey B", Mary Trim or add as you feel necessary. |
||
|
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Posts: 10728 (04/15/09 12:37 AM) Registered User |
Bored, so... IMO, the all-star worthy contestants of each season, in order... Italics are top-tier.
Survivor Borneo 1. Richard 2. Susan 3. Rudy 4. Colleen 5. Gervase 6. Kelly 7. Greg 8. Gretchen 9. Jenna 10. Sean Survivor Australia 1. Jerri 2. Colby 3. Elisabeth 4. Tina 5. Keith 6. Rodger Survivor Africa 1. Lex 2. Tom 3. Frank 4. Ethan 5. Kim P. 6. Teresa 7. Brandon Survivor Marquesas 1. Kathy 2. Sean 3. Rob 4. Paschal 5. John 6. Neleh 7. Tammy Survivor Thailand 1. Helen 2. Clay 3. Jake 4. Brian 5. Shii-Ann Survivor Amazon 1. Rob 2. Jenna 3. Christy 4. Matthew 5. Deena Survivor Pearl Islands 1. Rupert 2. Jon 3. Sandra 4. Lillian 5. Burton 6. Andrew On all-stars + on list - 16 (Richard, Rudy, Sue, Jenna, Tina, Colby, Jerri, Tom, Ethan, Lex, Kathy, Rob, Shii-Ann, Jenna, Rob, Rupert) On all-stars + not on list - 2 (Amber, Alicia) Survivor Vanuatu 1. Ami 2. Twila 3. Eliza 4. Chris 5. Lea 6. Rory Survivor Palau 1. Stephenie 2. Tom 3. Ian 4. Bobby Jon Survivor Guatemala 1. Judd 2. Gary 3. Rafe 4. Jamie 5. Danni Survivor Panama Exile Island 1. Terry 2. Cirie 3. Shane 4. Courtney 5. Aras 6. Sally Survivor Cook Islands 1. Jonathan 2. Yul 3. Ozzy 4. Candice 5. Parvati Survivor Fiji 1. Yau-Man 2. Dreamz 3. Earl Survivor China 1. Peih-Gee 2. James 3. Courtney 4. Todd 5. Jean-Robert On FvF + on list - 9 (Jon, Ami, Eliza, Cirie, Parvati, Ozzy, Jonathan, Yau-Man, James) On FvF + not on list - 1 (Amanda) Survivor Micronesia ~ Fans vs. Favourites 1. Erik Survivor Gabon 1. Sugar 2. Randy 3. Corinne 4. Crystal 5. Ken 6. Bob 7. Matty |
||
|
Ahora |
|||
|
Posts: 54 (04/15/09 1:21 AM) |
Vanuatu: Julie
|
||
|
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Posts: 620 (04/15/09 10:14 AM) |
wtf makes Matty All-Star worthy?
|
||
|
OrsNaz |
|||
|
Posts: 116 (04/15/09 1:18 PM) |
The following:
Season 11 - Judd - Jamie Season 12 - Shane - Terry Season 13 - Candace Season 14 - Michelle? Season 15 - Courtney - Peih Gee Season 17 - Sugar - Randy - Crystal - Kenny If repeats were included than Eliza and Cirie too. Season 13...Candace is really all that is left. Season 14 was terrible so I didn't really know who else to include. In fact, as long as the allstars doesn't include Marcus I am happy. |
||
|
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Posts: 10729 (04/15/09 1:25 PM) Registered User |
JackSparrowBauer wrote: Lets see, - Fan favourite - proposal - narrator (even if obnoxious to some) - fan favourite People here may hate him, but he's definitely all-star worthy give how much support he was able to drum up. |
||
|
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
Posts: 9261 (04/15/09 1:34 PM) |
chapera rocks wrote:Yup, just like Ozzy. |
||
|
srvivrfreakevelrich |
|||
|
Posts: 798 (04/15/09 1:36 PM) Admin |
Kitty Pryde1 wrote: so THATS why i hated matty so much! |
||
|
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Posts: 630 (04/15/09 1:49 PM) |
Ozzy at least won a bunch of challenges, that made him memorable. All Matty did was propose to his girlfriend.
|
||
|
Emcee Batley |
|||
|
Posts: 366 (04/15/09 6:07 PM) |
chapera rocks wrote:2 Episode narrator. Randy narrated the season. All he has going for him is fan favorite status and unless Jeff really wants to be on his balls again, then Matty won't be on ASS2. This isn't a dream cast, but I will rank the people from S9-S18 in terms of who will definitely get a call back to who could possibly get one. Will Definitely Be Asked Back: Twila Tanner - Vanuatu Tom Westman - Palau Judd Sargeant IV - Guatemala Shane Powers - Exile Island Yul Kwon - Cook Islands Courtney Yates - China Peih Gee Law - China Erik Reichenbach - Micronesia Randy Bailey - Gabon Kenny Hoang - Gabon Ben "Coach" Wade - Tocantins Will Probably Get Asked Back: Chris Daugherty - Vanuatu Ian Rosenberg - Palau Terry Deitz - Exile Island Courtney Marit - Exile Island Dre "Dreamz" Herd - Fiji Todd Herzog - China Jessica "Sugar" Kiper - Gabon Corrine Kaplan - Gabon Has a Good Chance at Being Asked Back: Rory Freeman - Vanuatu Gary Hogeboom - Guatemala Jamie Newton - Guatemala Candice Woodcock - Cook Islands Cao Boi Bui - Cook Islands Earl Cole - Fiji Jean-Robert Bellande - China Natalie Bolton - Micronesia Bob Crowley - Gabon Crystal Cox - Gabon Tyson Apostol - Tocantins Taj George - Tocantins Stephen Fishbach - Tocantins Will Be Asked Back if Top 3 Rows Decline: Rafe Judkins - Guatemala Cindy Hall - Guatemala Sundra Oakly - Cook Islands Alex Argenta - Fiji Jason Siska - Micronesia Alexis Jones - Micronesia Matty Whitmore - Gabon Brendan Synnott - Tocantins Who Would Be Most Likely Asked Back from Seasons 1-7: Gervase Peterson - Borneo Rodger Bingham - The Australian Outback Brian Heidik - Thailand Christy Smith - Amazon Sandra Diaz-Twine - Pearl Islands Who Could Be Asked Back From Previous Contestants Who've Played Once Before: Richard Hatch - All-Stars Colby Donaldson - All-Stars Ethan Zohn - All-Stars Rudy Boesch - All-Stars Jenna Morasca - All-Stars Rob Cesternino - All-Stars Rob Mariano - All-Stars Lex van den Bergh - All-Stars Stephenie Lagrossa - Palau/Guatemala Cirie Fields - Fans vs. Favorites James Clement - Fans vs. Favorites Jonathan Penner - Fans vs. Favorites Yau-Man Chan - Fans vs. Favorites Jonny 'Fairplay' Dalton - Fans vs. Favorites I wouldn't really be surprised at all if Survivor 20 included a little bit from all these lists. |
||
