Yuku free message boards

panurge46 wrote:

---

kishuu wrote:

He just admitted he ranked the players by 'How strategic they were and how physically fit they were' in his previous post so obviously someone doesn't understand the meaning of a popularity poll and that others ranked characters by how much they like so and so players... Crystal is likely going to be top 50 in all popularity surveys here. If you want to put Crystal as the worst in Gabon and the worst survivor player ever...

You're the one that can't understand what I'm writing. I never wrote that I "ranked the players by How strategic they were and how physically fit they were". I wrote that I ranked players by their story, their game play and Survival skills. Survival skills imply much more than being physically fit. Sandra, Chris, Cirie and Danni displayed great survival skills despite not being the most physically fit players.

Winning is usually a strong factor in popularity and the source of good stories.
(For example: Who is the more popular team outside of its own fanatics: The Detroit Lions or the Pittsburgh Steelers?)
Underdogs are all fine and good and players like Peih Gee had a very good story for being a fighter but she made some bad moves and lost. Top 50 for her? Sure. Top 20? I wouldn't put her that high.

As for Crystal: Finding it utterly ridiculous to call her a Goddess doesn't mean that I "want to put Crystal as the worst in Gabon". Top 100? Maybe, as long as she's behind Sugar and Bob. Crystal had a very interesting story but it was the story of a loser. Matty was boring to many but he had a better story, one of growing up from being a wide-eyed kid to finding his true values.