| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 kishuu |
|||
|
Posts: 1069 (01/12/09 8:23 AM) |
Confession: I forgot to put Trish in.
also, Stacy had to be there cause she was you know, sucky pre-merge. Jenna L was there cause she was one of the few all stars who improved their game. |
||
|
kishuu |
|||
|
Posts: 1108 (01/24/09 10:42 PM) |
k i needa finish a list for once.
40. TIE ::: Trish (Pearl Islands/11th -> 13th) & Jacque (Gabon/15th) 
k Jacque is so boring that THIS is the only pic of her that comes out for her search in Google. Yes, this pic appears 10x +++. Anyway, they're tied because they are well, pre merge boot. Trish is a smart player, remaining UTR till the ep presumed to be the one just before the merge, where she decided that yanno, Rupert's a threat physically, he's got good ties with Morgan hence gonna be a jury threat and he could flip over to them too! However, that failed as Sandra decided to be a sob and prevent that from happening. Ohwell, that strategic move was her only one and best and it's certainly much more than most pre-merge boots. Jacque is here because she pretty much had an alliance with everyone on her tribe except Paloma/Kelly. Oh, and she's strong and smart too. There's nothing much to describe her but if she didn't get screwed by a twist (well, literally I mean), she probably would've won over Marcus/Charlie. 39. TIE ::: Kelly G (Africa/9th) & Alexis (Micronesia/6th) 
I really should've put Kelly G higher but she was a last minute addition as said. And she didn't do that well too =(. Kelly G is rather smart imo. She was the only female in the know how of the Boran Boys Club (Tom/Ethan + Kelly/Lex) and she was feared by the Mallrats ('Kelly's like a walking thesaurus or whatever') so yea. Either ways, she had a good social game too since she pretty much was the one person everyone on Samburu wanted to turn over. However, Brandon screwed her over with Lex and Lex screwed her too so =(. I can't rank her much higher. Alexis is one note and boring. Yes, that girl sucks. She was a huge social threat (omg can you say motivational speaker?) and quite good physically till she hurt her leg. Everyone thought she was a triple threat so duhhh. Anyways, she got killed by the repeating occurence of the HII (or else she really would've made it into the finals I suppose) and idk what else I can say about her. That girl is at here just because. 38-35 er... Well, next update I guess. |
||
|
Katy Carney |
|||
|
Posts: 3857 (01/24/09 11:56 PM) |
I'm surprised to see Tracy and Kelly G this low. I think they'd probably rank higher for me but it's hard to say without seeing the rest of your
list. And I think Stacy is pretty under appreciated in terms of strategy, but I do understand her place on the list.
|
||
|
kishuu |
|||
|
Posts: 1109 (01/25/09 12:07 AM) |
Kelly didn't really have much outside of her last two episodes tbh. She should be higher but she was a last minute add in. She wasn't on the list till
I realized 'crap she's as good as half of these people'. Tracy... I had to consider her social game as well, which wasn't as great compared to
her strategic one. I definitely would put her higher if I redid the list but I'm lazy =x. Stacy is under appreciated yes but I can't rank her higher
when her game was pretty bad post-swap till the merge.
|
||
|
Pulau Tiga |
|||
|
Posts: 4635 (01/25/09 12:36 AM) Registered user |
Wow, is this list arbitrary.
|
||
|
ModernDayClyde |
|||
|
Posts: 1933 (01/25/09 12:36 AM) |
OMG Kelly G and THAT GIRL in one update <33333
|
||
|
CatLurvesDorothy |
|||
|
Posts: 3842 (01/25/09 12:47 AM) OMEDETO, CATHY!! |
kishuu <333
MDC <333 |
||
 pinoyako |
|||
|
Posts: 5757 (01/25/09 1:11 AM) Registered user |
Alexis?
pinopalin :) |
||
|
kishuu |
|||
|
Posts: 1113 (01/25/09 1:18 AM) |
Everyone loves THAT GIRL <333
|
||
|
RobVanStratus |
|||
|
Posts: 7701 (01/25/09 3:30 AM) Registered User |
I don't get why Kelly w. gets hated on for poor social skills. Do we forget how she befriended Pagong and had Gretchen been on the jury instead of Greg,
she actually wins the game for her good social skills. The only person she really had problems with was Sue because Sue got pissed Kelly was outplaying Tagi
for the Pagong votes. Greg planned to vote for Rich regardless, he refused to lose to an uneducated raft guide, same thing with Sean, Rudy and Rich had an
alliance that Rich never outright betrayed him, which makes 3 votes. The Sue vote did decide it in favor of Rich, but it also swung Colleen's vote
Kelly's way.
She certainly wasn't the best social player in Survivor, but for a naive and morally conflicted person, she played an excellent game. She may not have admitted it, but she was playing a social game by befriending Pagong and it ended up helping her in the end. Lil is another one that gets underrated. Yes she was voted off 3rd initially, but that season was played where the first 6 boots could get back into the game. Taking that into account, she dominated the merger. Every person she voted against got the boot. Sandra even used that in her jury questioning as a reason why Lil shouldn't win, but Tijuana saw it as a reason to vote FOR Lil to win the game. For someone that seemed to be out of the loop in Morgan, which was due to her age, she came back into the game and used her status as an Outcast to first worm into the Drake alliance with Burton, and later wormed into an alliance with Burton/Jon, and even countered Burton/Jon trying to vote her off by forming an alliance with Sandra/Darrah to get rid of the guys. She was a crafty and underrated player that if brought back for another All-Stars edition, if she can last through the pre-merge portion as a challenge liability, she could definitely make it to the finals and potentially win. |
||
|
kishuu |
|||
|
Posts: 1140 (01/30/09 9:52 PM) |
k i'm lazy to find pics and do descriptions ;o;
|
||
|
maldoror122 |
|||
|
Posts: 5341 (01/30/09 9:55 PM) |
Kishuu's back <3
|
||
|
kishuu |
|||
|
Posts: 1141 (01/30/09 10:12 PM) |
maldoror122 wrote:
maldoror<333 |
||
|
maldoror122 |
|||
|
Posts: 5342 (01/30/09 10:18 PM) |
I wonder how popular Scout was in the show, before she started blogging for CBS afterwards. I mean, obviously, once she started blogging, she became a
laughingstock, but in Vanuatu I liked her, and I am sure there are others who didn't hate her while she was on the show...
|
||
|
kenc333 |
|||
|
Posts: 7404 (01/30/09 10:42 PM) |
Micronesiamanda was robbed
But I'm trusting you when you say Chinamanda is still here, kishuu! Hopefully near the top =) I put Amanda at #4 on my list of strategic females. |
||
|
Survivaholic |
|||
|
Posts: 1300 (01/31/09 11:10 AM) Registered User |
Jaime <3333
I am hoping Peih-Gee, Kathy, and Parvati make top 10... but Teresa FTW!!! |
||
|
kishuu |
|||
|
Posts: 1175 (02/12/09 4:37 AM) |
NEXT 10
|
||
|
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Posts: 51 (02/12/09 2:36 PM) |
wtf at Scout (SCOUT!) being higher than Steph.
Twila should've been higher. Deena should've been, too. Those two are two of the most underrated players ever. |
||
|
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Posts: 52 (02/12/09 2:38 PM) |
I meant to say that I, personally, would've ranked Twila and Deena higher. Your opinion, though, so you can rank however you want.
|
||
|
Katy Carney |
|||
|
Posts: 4284 (02/12/09 2:41 PM) |
I agree with a lot of these placements. I truly feel as tho Danielle is an underrated player.
|
||
