| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
supersync4d |
Did our old presidents have British Accents? |
Lead | |
|
You know .. Washington, Adams, Jefferson and shit? Accents evolves through time and considering how close of an era their time was to the first american
colonialization by the British (Which probably means that they're direct British descendants themselves), what sort of accent did the speak with?
|
|||
khnum |
|||
|
dunno!
|
|||
sadllama |
|||
|
I bet Lincoln spoke in jive.
|
|||
1000Proof |
|||
|
|
|||
Beefcake |
|||
|
No one really knows. But Washington and Jefferson were from Virginia, so they no doubt had southern accents. And back then southern accents were probably
stronger -- most like Appalachian type accents today.
In college, I took a Shakespeare class and the professor talked a lot about how Shakespeare's plays sounded, because we don't really know. I remember him saying that Appalachian 'hillbilly' accents are probably the closest living language to Elizabethan English, and if you want to know how Shakespeare sounded, you shouldn't read his plays with the affected British accent most actors give them; you should try speaking the parts like a West Virginia hillbilly. |
|||
Shagnanigans |
|||
|
There was no one accent for all areas obviously. Back then, the states were even more distinct than they are now, with most areas having a heavy influence of a
particular mother country. I've read too that our accents have evolved a lot less than the British ones did, so some of our accents in the US are closer to
the British accents of a few hundred years ago than modern British is.
|
|||
Ann Margret Thatcher |
|||
|
The oldest regional accents can be traced back to their (mainly British) roots. Many Appalachian settlers were Irish, so hillbilly accents have that harder
"r" pronunciation, more akin to an Irish brogue, and low country and deep southern accents (think that soft "r", Jimmy Carter slow Southern
drawl) have more similarities to upper class British. If I had to bet, I'd say Jefferson and Washington would have had that Virginia drawl, but with a hint
more British kick to it, but like Beefcake says, we don't really know for sure.
|
|||
Jitensha |
|||
|
THANK YOU YAHOO!ANSWERS!
Short answer: what Washington spoke would doubtless have sounded more like English accents in certain parts of England in his day, because it had descended from them (in the previous century). The answer to your question depends on what you have in mind by an "English accent". If you're thinking of something like the 20th century British "Received Pronunciation", the question is, did ANYONE in Washington's day speak that way?! Start by noting two simple facts: 1) there never was ONE variety of English spoken in England. (In fact, England of the 17th century and of today has more dialects, with more variations, than ALL the dialects of ALL its former colonies!) 2) NO ONE --British or American-- speaks the same English as was spoken in the colonial period! BOTH have changed significantly (including what LATER became the "Received Pronounciation" based on a politically dominant London-area dialect) So, whatever era you're looking at, comparing "American English" and "British English" is not a simple matter. Now about the type of English spoken in the American colonies -- During the colonial period (1607-1775) there for FOUR main migrations of English speaking people to America from the British Isles. These resulted in four main dialect areas, each based on the dialect of the area of the British Isles from which most of its early settlers ("founders") came. In fact, many of the distinctive features of English in the different regions of the U.S. today can be traced to these. Thus the English of the American colonists was based on VARIOUS dialects of 17th century BRITISH English. Of course, since they all spoke a LIVING language, BOTH Amerian dialects and British dialects continued to change. Already by the time of the American Revolution there were significant changes had taken place on BOTH sides of the Atlantic. Note that in some cases some British dialects might preserve older patterns (words, accent, etc) and the colonists might innovate; but in other instances older forms would be preserved in AMERICAN dialects, while the British innovated. As for Washington -- One of these four migrations was that of the Cavaliers from South England (migrated in 1642-1675). This group eventually dominated the coastal region from Virginia to Florida. Their speech laid the foundation for the development of American Tidewater speech, or Coastal Southern English. Since George Washingon would have been typical of the people who settled his region, he would have shared this Tidewater accent (in its 18th century form). It would have been something like the English dialect (and accent) of the area of Southern England from which his forebears came, but with some changes due to over a century since their separation. summary of the linguistic features of the four regions http://pandora.cii.wwu.edu/vajda/ling201... |
|||
supersync4d |
|||
|
What an unbelievable response, Jitesha. You got all that from Yahoo Answers?? How long was it before someone came up with that answer for you?
|
|||
CBRetriever |
|||
|
my bigoted granny hadthat tidewater thingie going
|
|||
SardonicallyIrrelevant |
|||
|
Interesting. |
|||
JugheadSpock |
|||
|
I always look to Kevin Costner and Keanu Reeves' interpretations of accents.
|
|||
CBRetriever |
|||
|
Costner did such an excellent job with a British accent in Robinhood
|
|||
RazorrzzEdge |
|||
supersync4d wrote: My thoughts exactly. There are fucking morons on Yahoo Answers. Someone thought the song "Lido Shuffle" was a Christmas Carol.
|
|||
ginaf20697 |
|||
|
How stupid. Everyone knows that it's the Curly Shuffle.
|
|||
IndifferentCow |
|||
|
I thought the Puritans had an accent similar to a maine accent, but yea we should go with the actors interpretation clearly.
|
|||
Ann Margret Thatcher |
|||
|
The midwestern, Fargo-type accent comes from the Scandinavian influence there, yah?
|
|||
Beefcake |
|||
|
Yah, you betcha.
|
|||
U91731 |
|||
|
Say what you want about the Brits.
Bastards. All of 'em. Provo U9 |
|||
angelinab |
|||
|
Do the presidents in Disneys hall of presidents have accents?
|
|||
Ann Margret Thatcher |
|||
|
No, they all sound like Don LaFontaine.
|
|||