| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
Cool. I'll catch up.
|
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
#25: Madison Allen
Okay, I will fully admit that in many forms of media, particularly the horror genre, little kids are the scariest motherfuckers you will ever
find. I mean, The Ring had creepy ass Samara. The Grudge had that Japanese kid that hissed like a cat. Identity had the most random and amazing spoiler
ever. So why is it, when the Harper's Island people added a single little kid into their cast, with the sole intention of making her a creepy
motherfucker...they fucked it up?
|
|||
CrystalOwnage |
|||
|
X
Below: Something concering Madison |
|||
A Lying Down |
|||
|
I heartily agree with KC's Bottom 3. And I agree with KP's point, except calling Madison the only dead weight on the show. Because wtf is Danny if not
a completely useless character?
But I expect Shea to show up soon, before Beth and Hunter, which will be profoundly saddening. Cal & Chloe F2 <3 |
|||
Mikester |
|||
|
Katy's Ranking: Nikki Bolton is a fierce name. But Biker Chick? Ew.
Kitty's Ranking: Ohmigod Kitty you can't rank an eight-year-old dead last you heartless bitch. |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
#24: Lucy Daramour
|
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
#23: Hunter Jennings
Yeah, I know that Hunter had a pretty big role in the three episodes he was in, but I still always forget about him, mainly
because he's so disconnected from the cast. He wasn't involved with the wedding. He wasn't connected with any of the townies. He basically was
connected to two characters, Trish and Mr. Wellington, both of whom had so many more memorable connections that Hunter gets lost in the shuffle.
|
|||
Mikester |
|||
Mikester wrote:Kitty, you did that on purpose. Your ranking ends now plz. |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
Mikester wrote: Oh come ON, Mikester. If they were fugly with the same personalities, you'd rank them low too. |
|||
Katy Carney |
|||
|
#22: Danny Brooks
"the College Buddy" "the Token"
Danny is so irrelevant that I couldn't even find a picture of him by himself. I had to use photoshop on this one just to get him alone. Anyway, Danny is black. And that's all. He doesn't have any semblance of his own storyline, which is remarkable considering he's still alive. All he does is follow Henry around like a dutiful sidekick. He seems nice I guess idk who cares. Hopefully at least his death is spectacular. To demonstrate how inconsequential he is: I couldn't find a video of him either. |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
#22. Christopher "Sully" Sullivan
Seriously, he starts off by trying to steal Chloe from Cal, leaves Cal hanging upside down in a position that could've even killed him WITHOUT a psychotic killer loose on the island. Thankfully, Cal got him back with the whole tarring and feathering situation. But seriously, I like Cal, and Sully has been an ass to him ALL season, belittling him and acting like he's a complete pussy because he's not a jock and because he's British. But really, Sully's been the biggest pussy in the cast. Ever since Mr. Wellington died, Sully has done everything he can to make sure other people die so that he can get off the island. He wanted to leave Madison to die (granted, who wouldn't?), he bitched out Cal when he wanted to think things through rather than acting on impulse. He's been calling out one person or another every five minutes as being the killer. And overall, his womanizing, cowardly ways irritate me and I hope he dies the second he saves Cal from his bullet wound. |
|||
Mikester |
|||
|
Sully looks like Spencer Pratt.
And |
|||
pinoyako |
|||
|
Cal/Chloe FTW!
|
|||
Katy Carney |
|||
|
#21: Madison Allen
"the Flower Girl" "the Vaguely Annoying Girl"
I cannot stand this little girl. It took me forever to figure out why, but my theory is that the cute/creepy ratio is off. Madison is too adorable to pull
off scary, so she just becomes annoying. She's not the kind of creepy kid you run from, she's the kind of creepy kid you slap and scream "pull
yourself together and act normal for once goddammit". You know? I know what she's going for and she's just not "there".
It's my opinion that Madison will survive til the end of the series because CBS has been handling this whole mystery with kid gloves, which I do not understand because on CSI they have cases with death children's body parts and shit all the time. Whatever. Enjoy this actually creepy tribute vid (described as a "preteen actress" |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
#21: Kelly Seaver
Then came episode two, where she completely defied all goth stereotypes in a bad way. She went from semi-important goth girl to psycho-obsessive-stalker. I mean, we find out that her mom was killed by John Wakefield, just like Abby, essentially making her a more boring and pathetic version of the series' main character. She also basically went about stalking Abby for the whole episode in the creepiest way possible, asking if she could live with her, or telling her she sees John Wakefield, or just generally popping up at bizarre times. In general, it was like the editors knew she was dying in episode two, so they didn't bother giving her a decent personality and just randomly made her bipolar or something. She was also the first character to be discovered dead, so that's something, I guess. |
|||
Pulau Tiga |
|||
|
NOW GUEST STARRING PT (for one post)!
25. Madison I don't care how young she is, it doesn't make her immune from my hate. The girl is an awful actress and clearly the most annoying character on the show. She acts nothing like a normal child, or even a normal human being. And I can't figure out how old she's supposed to be, because she acts like a retard yet is clearly more knowledgeable than the 2 year-old she pretends to be. I have hated literally every second she's been on my screen. I was hoping her disappearance meant they had killed her off without actually killing her or something, but nope, she's back and being as annoying as ever. 24. Hunter Dude, fuck you. I don't respect guys who show up at weddings trying to ruin them by getting the bride to sleep with him. If he was in love with Trish, then maybe it's reasonable for him to step in, but he leaves for cash, so clearly he's just a total douchebag with no redeeming qualities. 23. JD What the fuck is wrong with this guy? Not only does he look weird as shit, but he goes around lighting firecrackers as a prank? Really? That's how badass you are, you mildly irritate the grown-ups by startling them with semi-loud sounds? And he's depressed and a loner, which is to be expected from someone who acts like he does. His friends are the zombie man and the annoying-as-fuck little girl. Yeah, you really should have tried harder to kill yourself. And when you witness a cop shot in front of your face, you don't grab the keys and run, dumb shit. Nor do you let your brother stab you on the dock, and then don't say his name when the main character asks you who killed you. 22. Shane Grow up and stop acting like some junior high fucktwat. You're a grown man, you should know better. Control your emotions and be logical for once in your life, dumbass. I mean jesus, you're in the middle of a murdering spree and you take the time to carve your name in a table? Real mature. 21. Richard He did nothing but act like a douche and fuck his wife's stepmom. Not particularly endearing. Plus, he's into kinky controlling shit, which I hate. 20. Mrs. Wellington Gotta put her this low for cheating on her husband with her stepdaughter's own husband. Even if she's been okay since then. And really, getting killed by a prick from gardening shears? How embarassing. 19. Booth You're not a nerd, and you supposedly killed yourself by shooting your own leg. What the fuck, dude. You're just an incompetent pussy with no first aid skills. And if you're still alive, then you're the only thing complicating what would otherwise be an incredibly straightforward show. You really only get bumped up to #19 due to all the hilarious conspiracy theories in the HI thread in OSTS. Most of which originated prior to you even getting any screen time, and which might end up panning out as you're revealed to be Henry's accomplice, lawl. 18. Nikki INV1 much? Also, for a badass biker chick, you don't do much that's badass. You're a pretty girly bartender. 17. Kelly The bitch hooked up with JD, of all the ugly people on the island to hook up with. And whatever her issue was (I don't quite remember, something about Abby leaving) just made her seem like a grown-up Madison, retarded and not fully developed. But we got rid of her pretty quickly and I feel bad that one of her last experiences was banging such an ugly looking freak. 16. Lucy I don't remember if she was hot, but she probably was, and she brought a dog, so that's nice. Too bad she was inconsequential and worthless. And she died by falling into a fucking pit. Come on. 15. Beth Anyone who flirts with Malcolm is seriously fucked up in the head. And her death scene sucked, since we just got a quick shot of her body stuffed in some tunnel. I couldn't even tell she was cut up until Sully described her as such. Hell, we didn't even see her taken or anything, she just up and disappears until her corpse is found. Lame. 14. Malcolm He annoyed the fuck out of me. His obsession with money was both cliche and stupid, and he wasn't even the jovial funny fat guy, he was the sniveling worthless one. I only comend him for his ability to get Beth interested in him, and his decision to burn the cash. 13. Sheriff I honestly don't know what it is about him, but he annoys me. Just his acting and overall demeanor, I guess. He's probably one of the smarter characters on the show, but that's not saying much. And his facial expressions make me want to punch a baby. Plus, he's caustic and mean for no reason. But I know he'll probably die heroicly, so I'm trying to make myself dislike him less. 12. Mr. Wellington In such an unlikable cast, even the asshole father can make it pretty far in the rankings. I mean, he kinda turned a new leaf before getting his head chopped in half. I don't think he would have changed much and I'm sure he would have remained the same douche who invited Hunter to the island just to ruin his daughter's love, but eh, there was potential for growth. And I'm sorry your wife cheated on you for someone as fug as Richard, dude. You must have really sucked in the sack. 11. Sully He's a little bitch, but at least he's decently entertaining. Not in any likable way. He'll probably die saving someone and it'll be valiant and shit, but clearly he's rotten and I'm going to remember him as a villain, yw. 10. Jimmy There's nothing really wrong with him, I just don't see what Abby finds appealing about him. He's pretty nice. And that's about it. I thought he'd end up being our hero, but his edit hasn't really supported that too much. He'll get the girl, but I'm not so sure he deserves it, because he doesn't bring much to the table. And he clearly doesn't get the least bit excited by things that would elicit more of a reaction from most people. I think it's because he's a bit slow. 9. Maggie She's dumb and only serves to further the plot, but her random knowledge and obsession over mundane things is entertaining. 8. Danny As a useless side character, Danny's someone I've ended up liking more than I might expect. Since I hate most of these people, that puts him at #8. 7. Shea There's nothing wrong with her, except perhaps that she still loves her daughter despite the fact that her daughter is that fucked up Madison. And having your husband cheat on you for your stepmom must suck pretty badly. She's handled herself surprisingly well considering what she's had to put up with. 6. Uncle Marty He was totally involved in major shit that we never found out about, and he pretended to be laid-back and fun-loving when clearly he was a deadly go-getter. Alas, his bottom half was hacked off by a machete. Check where you're walking, dude. Even if you hadn't been chopped up, falling through a bridge is pretty gay and liable to get you injured. 5. Abby I don't really like her that much, but overexposure to her has forced me to slowly come to appreciate her more and more. She's nothing great and I'd much prefer a different female protagonist, but oh well, she's aight. Even if she's interested in simple Jimmy for no reason other than nostalgia, and hasn't lost her innocence despite living in LA. 4. Trish She's hot, which is a plus. Besides that? She actually does things and is one of the only people to survive a kill attempt (although I suspect the closing pool screen wasn't a real murder attempt at all, just an odd happening). Freaking out on Henry because her father was chopped was kinda a bitch move, but being as Henry's the killer, I can understand her reluctance to want him all over her following that event. I really hated how it seemed she was close to hooking up with Hunter (at least she denied him) and I hated how she's become a complete mess ever since her dad was offed. Hmm, I guess I don't really like her much after all. I thought she could be good early on, but she hasn't gone anywhere decent. Well, take #4 simply because I want to bone you, then. 3. Chloe The only bad thing she's done is ruin a man's marriage simply to get her fiance's ring back. That was totally unnecessary. Besides that, she's been enjoyable. And hot. Mostly hot. Remember when she was so horny she decided she had to bang Cal while the Sheriff was laboring to breathe outside the door? Lawl. 2. Henry I really just appreciate that he's obviously the killer, and I watch him in that light. So every time he interacts with someone, it's "haha, he's totally lying to you and wants to slice your jugular." At least he's smarter than all these people and, like me, wants to see most of them dead. I can relate. Even if he's doing it to avenge his father, Wakefield. That's not really much of a motive. I hope he legitimately despises them all, too. 1. Cal Everyone loves Cal, I don't have to justify this. He's the only thoroughly likable character on the show. Sure, he's not that savvy and bumbles quite a bit, but he's cute and has a certain charm that gets girls like Chloe to totally dig him. Plus, he's got book smarts and a willingness to keep trying despite all his lacking social skills. I admire his tenacity. And his hot fiance. And his accent. Oh, and I haven't seen last night's episode yet, so don't go spoiling it for me, tia. |
|||
Blondzilla5150 |
|||
|
P Tiga, Last night's episode was pure ownage. <3 You will love it!
This is like the hottest 3way ranking I have ever seen, btw. <33333333 |
|||
XtremeInnovator420 |
|||
|
Agreed, last night's episode was awesome. Though, I don't really think Henry's the killer.
|
|||
Dan Down Under |
|||
|
DDU's rankings
25-2: Who cares? 1: TRISH!
|
|||
maximillian |
|||
|
Jimmy FTW!
|
|||