| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
cindidindi76 |
|||
|
Where are people getting the "Nikki showed up at the Inn" thing from? I was actually watching for her because someone had mentioned it, and
didn't see her.
|
|||
myopics |
|||
|
This episode was really strange to me in terms of the timeline. It seems pretty tight for any one of the characters (save Nikki) to be doing any of the
killings, as many people have already pointed out.
What was up with the blood trail? Maybe the vent or tunnels or whatever were connected? Whoever left the blood trail could have went one direction down the fork, use the tunnels to emerge through the other direction of the fork... then go back either way to leave via the tunnels. If I didn't see that picture of Beth cut in half, I would have guessed that Beth was guilty to some extent and was the one who grabbed Abby since she was already in the tunnels. I don't get how the chair could have been trapped. The hotel is big as fuck with guests wandering around all through it. How could the killer have guessed that Katherine would sit on that random chair? Its more likely that the killer spotted her sleeping there and decided to take advantage of the situation. |
|||
Coachocd |
|||
The Purple Parrot wrote:Except for Maggie and Nikki. Did Henry have time in jaunts between the Sheriff's office and the Inn? Is it wrong that I liked Katherine more and more as the show went on? I was sort of sorry to see her go. |
|||
superkyle |
|||
Coachocd wrote: |
|||
Coachocd |
|||
myopics wrote:I think the bags of blood show how the killer lured them down to find Beth. It was drips, instead of the smears had that been Beth being dragged. I have a feeling Beth was chopped in half elsewhere down in the tunnel, then planted in the crawl space. But clearly the killer grabbed her while she was in the kitchen. All these people wandering off by themselves... Ridiculous. Where are people getting the "Nikki showed up at the Inn" thing from? I was actually watching for her because someone had mentioned it, and didn't see her.
Last Edited By: Coachocd
06/14/09 12:33 AM.
Edited 2 times.
|
|||
AmightyRo |
|||
|
when Maggie came up to Shane and asked him what he was doing, does anybody think she was getting ready to kill him somehow, but stopped because she saw he had
a knife? Probably not, because she didn't have any weapons on her, unless she set something down before she approached Shane.
|
|||
GoHomeAndEatYoRice |
|||
|
Posts: 845 (06/14/09 12:53 AM) |
I didn't want Katherine to die after she was rudely owned by Shea.
Her blood everywhere was cool though. Beth!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! </3333333333333333333333333333 |
||
Dan Down Under |
|||
|
Does anyone have a screen-cap of who grabbed what tools when they were trying to free Abby? Did anyone grab anything that resembles what killed mama
Wellington?
|
|||
The Annoying Hater |
|||
myopics wrote:Shea, Cal and Chloe were all unaccounted for when Beth was murdered. Shea was later seen looking at the tarot card. Chloe is seen walking into the room where Cal was finishing up with the sheriff, which implies she wasn't in there the whole time. The sheriff was knocked out, so Cal could have slipped out too with Chloe gone. The blood trail came from Beth getting wacked in that room and then dragged away. Which again leaves only 4 suspects. Also, I don't know why people think the chair was booby trapped. All someone had to do was sneak up behind Katherine when Trish and Shea came back, and killed her. Katherine's murder scratches Shea off the list because she was in the truck with Trish. All roads lead to Cal & Chloe....oh and Nikki too I guess. |
|||
Coachocd |
|||
|
Since this show is like crack and it's Saturday night on gay pride weekend and I don't have a date and I feel like taking it out on all the people
who've mocked me for even considering the possibility that Booth is still alive, I just wanted to prove that I am not alone.
Barmaid posted the following on HG on why she thinks Booth is still alive (I'm using my own bandwith from pics and using good message board ethics.): BOOTH...THE EVIDENCE AGAINST DEATH
Wakefield's Grave
Booth's supposed grave
Q1. Did you SEE Henry and Abby digging (up) a grave? Yep. Q2. Did you SEE Malcolm digging a grave? Nope. Q3. Did you SEE remains in the grave Henry and Abby dug? Yep. Q4. Did you SEE Malcolm put Booth's lifeless body in a hole? Nope. Conclusion: Not dead. ------------------ Barmaid has done a stellar job trying to proving her point. If Booth were not dead, it solves all the timeline
issues. A faked death plot was part of And Then There Were None, the original story of people trapped on an
island with a serial killer and realizing it must be one of them.
Granted, I still think Henry is the most likely suspect. However, Booth not being dead as a theory still has merit.
Flame away. |
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
The Annoying Hater wrote: Beth's dead proved it was somebody she was close too as she wouldn't be alone w/ somebody she didnt' trust. Katherine's death. . . .could have been anyone. I'm thinking that the killer has more than one trap available and ready for whoever. Rule out - Cal and Chloe since I dont' think they would be able to make it from town to the inn and then from the inn to town again w/out anyone knowing. Henry grabbed bolt cutters while Jimmy just held a shotgun. They were together. Sully and Danny could have been the kilelr but Danny I think is too nice and hasn't done anything crazy |
|||
Coachocd |
|||
The Annoying Hater wrote:The problem with that theory is the angle of the weapon in the chair being so near the wall. It is more likely that the chair was boobytrapped and Katherine placed in it. Her seated position doesn't look that natural. She looks placed.
Last Edited By: Coachocd
06/14/09 1:21 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
The Annoying Hater |
|||
|
You know what Coachocd, that's some good detective work. For the first time I could actually buy Booth not being dead. He was one of my top suspects before
he died because he took that bag from the luggage cart in episode 1.
One problem though. If Malcolm buried him, how did he survive without suffocating? |
|||
Coachocd |
|||
|
Thanks, TAH. That detective work goes fully to Barmaid on Harper's Globe.
If nothing else, it is obvious the writers and editors want us to talk about this as a possibility even if it isn't true at the end. Whoever tied Ben under the boat had to have experience diving and probably had amazing breath control. We don't know what the grave looked like when Malcolm dug it. For all we know he wasn't fully covered. Whoever the killer is has amazing scientific knowledge. Think if all that had been put to good. I'd still put my money on Henry. But even if Booth is really dead, Barmaid's work proves that at least that the filmmakers did a really sloppy job in filming it. |
|||
The Annoying Hater |
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote:Beth's death happened in a small window. She is seen with Sully and Danny and then the Henry/Shane fight happens. Sully and Danny leave, but Beth is never seen again. The blood trail is in the room she was last seen so it's safe to assume that someone snuck up behind her and killed her. That excludes however, everyone in the room where the fight occurred. And I definitely can't rule out Cal or Chloe. it's not like there were tons of deaths when they were "gone". In fact, i'm trying to remember who exactly died during that time and under what circumstances. |
|||
Coachocd |
|||
|
Zankoku87 pointed out on HG that "Katherine might have been dead before she was stabbed with the shears... it would explain why she seems to be dead
before we see that she's lost blood - which she can't have lost too much of anyway, unless she's sat on a load of cotton wool or something."
----------- The blood trail is in the room she was last seen so it's safe to assume that someone snuck up behind her and killed her.Not necessarily. Maybe I've watched too much CSI, but the blood trail seems more deliberate to lure them to the crawlspace. Also the shelves were reset with the door closed. I think it is more likely that Beth was taken and killed and the blood trail was made in reverse from the type of bags we saw at the clinic. I also don't understand how Beth was taken without noise. Perhaps the killer uses needles to give injections to numb people and then kills them more easily. Isn't that from an old episode of Charlie's Angeles? Chloroform? The killer in And Then There Were None used drugs to subdue someone before killing them.
Last Edited By: Coachocd
06/14/09 1:30 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
Coachocd wrote:
4.) Booth's body was removed so people didn't panic. Even though Booth's death may / may not have been an accident I'm sure the killer didn't want the cops involved and people prematurely discovering dead bodies are piled up. 5.) We didnt' see Malcom dig a grave b/c who wants to watch a fat fuck get sweaty and dirty. . .nobody. Had it been Chloe, Trish, or Beth they would have been in their white bra and panties during a thunder storm. 6.) Booth got one episode of screentime and was barely in that episode at all. Booth is not from the island and doesn't know his way around. 2ndly why? why booth? if its about Abby, Booth doesn't know Abby. If he's Wakefields child I think he'd have more camera time. They're not going to pull somebody who appeared in one episode and make him the killer. . . no way, no how.
------------------ If you go by that account then. We saw Lucy on fire but we never saw her fall down dead. Plus they haven't found her body. In addition Lucy's name
has been added back to "guess the victim" and "guess the killer" game while Booth's name has been not. Is Lucy still alive?
|
|||
superkyle |
|||
|
Wasn't there a fight going on when Beth was killed? Everybody was busy trying to pull Henry and Shane off of each other. Any noise Beth may have made could
have been covered by that.
And a lot of people have gone surprisingly quietly. Uncle Marty was chopped in half and I don't remember him screaming at all. |
|||
Coachocd |
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote:We'll post here whether it meets with your approval or not. If alternative theories are bothersome to you, perhaps you should do something a little less controversial, like blog American idol. I will be the first to laugh at myself when we see Booth's dead body next to Lucy's barbecued corpse. I've been posting on Survivor Sucks since back in the days of Black Gretchen and the Fake Final 4 pic. So go suck it.
There would still a small hole and there is NO hole in these pics.
Last Edited By: Coachocd
06/14/09 1:46 AM.
Edited 3 times.
|
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
Coachocd wrote: You can't even see in those pictures it so dark. The one leg is a close up and Booth's isn't. Its not Booth get over that fact. . . .damn you act like you love the guy. Booth's to Harper's Island what Angie was to Big Brother 10. |
|||