Survivor 20: Heroes vs Villains

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
matty p	Survivor 20: Heroes vs Villains	Lead	[-]
Posts: 1 (02/18/09 11:34 PM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Just an idea for Season 20: Survivor: Heroes vs Villains (Using All-Stars from China to Season 19) Heroes Tribe: Erik - Micronesia Kenny - Gabon Matty - Gabon Coach - Tocantins JT - Tocantins Peih-Gee - China Sugar - Gabon Sierra - Tocantins Erinn - Tocantins/Other Tocantins/Season 19 Female Tocantins/Season 19 Female Villains Tribe: Todd - China Jean Robert - China Randy - Gabon Ace - Gabon Tyson - Tocantins Courtney - China Natalie - Micronesia Crystal - Gabon Corrine - Gabon Tocantins/Season 19 Female There's been a lot of big characters on the show in the last few seasons, justifying another All-Stars season in Season 20, and I think a Heroes vs Villains theme with this cast utilises these characters and encapsulates their personalities and ideals strongly.
taigark		#1	[-]
Posts: 515 (02/19/09 1:30 AM) Hey! I kinda like it here! More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	How is Kenny a hero? And how do you know Coach will be one?
hagiz1		#2	[-]
Posts: 306 (02/19/09 1:48 AM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Tyson a villain? Kenny a hero? Coach a hero? I'm wondering what category you're using to separate them? coz that's absurd
taigark		#3	[-]
Posts: 516 (02/19/09 4:57 AM) Hey! I kinda like it here! More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	hagiz1 wrote: Tyson a villain? Kenny a hero? Coach a hero? I'm wondering what category you're using to separate them? coz that's absurd Jeff said Tyson would be a villain and be a person we'd love to hate. The other 2, I agree.
Zesty66		#4	[-]
Posts: 1190 (02/19/09 5:02 AM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	sexual
matty p		#5	[-]
Posts: 3 (02/19/09 7:33 AM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Obviously the Tocantins cast is up for review depending on how the season plays out. I placed them in tribes based on Jeff's pre-game comments and the 1st episode. Tyson: Will be villain according to Jeff. Coach: While he may be edited negatively, thinks of his himself as a hero, and so I think should be put on the Heroes tribe. Kenny: I had trouble placing Kenny and also had him in the Villains tribe at 1 stage. He was edited negatively towards the end of Gabon, but had an underdog edit before that. Plus I didn't want to have 5 Gabon people in the 1 tribe, as Randy, Ace, Crystal and Corinne are already in the Villains tribe. It will also be good to have another strategic player like Kenny in the Heroes tribe, as Erik, Matty and JT seem to have limited strategy compared to most of the males in the Villains tribe.
valentine79		#6	[-]
Posts: 6 (02/19/09 8:35 AM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	How about season 20: applicants vs applicants? You only have it based on 3 seasons. There will still be season 19. Plus all the other seasons post the last allstar season.
matty p		#7	[-]
Posts: 4 (02/19/09 8:56 AM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	valentine79 wrote: How about season 20: applicants vs applicants? You only have it based on 3 seasons. There will still be season 19. Plus all the other seasons post the last allstar season. We all know that applicants vs applicants is never gonna happen lol. I think they have struck a nice balance over the last few seasons. I have based the cast of Heroes vs Villains on China, Micronesia, Gabon, Tocantins and left additional spots open for Season 19. The all-stars from seasons 9-15 (plus Fairplay) mostly already appeared in Fans vs Favourites. I have put a couple more people from season 15 in this season as well though as there were limited spots available in the short amount of time between their season and Micronesia, meaning some of the memorable characters missed out, and deserve a spot in this All-Stars season. I do not believe that there were as many memorable characters between seasons 9-14, which I think was the weaker era of Survivor. From China onwards, the show has once again become strong and has produced many more standouts in the cast. People from these seasons, the 2nd strong era of Survivor, would be the ones represented in this season.
Sole Survivor Genius		#8	[-]
Posts: 1422 (02/19/09 1:18 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	taigark wrote: hagiz1 wrote: Tyson a villain? Kenny a hero? Coach a hero? I'm wondering what category you're using to separate them? coz that's absurd Jeff said Tyson would be a villain and be a person we'd love to hate. The other 2, I agree. Jeff also said that Carolina would not be the 1st person voted out.
taigark		#9	[-]
Posts: 517 (02/19/09 6:07 PM) Hey! I kinda like it here! More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Sole Survivor Genius wrote: taigark wrote: hagiz1 wrote: Tyson a villain? Kenny a hero? Coach a hero? I'm wondering what category you're using to separate them? coz that's absurd Jeff said Tyson would be a villain and be a person we'd love to hate. The other 2, I agree. Jeff also said that Carolina would not be the 1st person voted out. Okay, that was probably misdirection.
matty p		#10	[-]
Posts: 5 (02/20/09 5:32 AM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Taking Tocantins episode 2 and people's opinions into account: Heroes Tribe: Todd - China (Yeah, I know he's not really a hero but he gives hope to all lifelong fans of the show) Erik - Micronesia (Hilarious guy) Matty - Gabon (Had a great evolvement throughout Gabon) Coach - Tocantins (Thinks he is the hero) JT - Tocantins (Will be one of the most popular people in Tocantins amongst viewers) Peih-Gee - China (An underdog in China) Sugar - Gabon (Wanted the good to prevail in Gabon and it did because of her) Sierra - Tocantins (The underdog of Tocantins) Taj/Tocantins/Other Tocantins/Season 19 Female Tocantins/Season 19 Female Villains Tribe: Jean Robert - China (Lazy villain) Kenny - Gabon (Big schemer) Randy - Gabon (Great villain) Ace - Gabon (Provided some great lines in Gabon) Tyson - Tocantins (Jeff says he may be the villain in Tocantins) Courtney - China (Will be interesting to see her vs Jean-Robert again) Natalie - Micronesia (Schemer after the merge in Micronesia) Corrine - Gabon (Self-professed villain in Gabon) Erinn/Tocantins/Season 19 Female Tocantins/Season 19 Female This is just my opinion and I'm sure you all have different opinions on certain players, but no need to criticise, I invite healthy discussion.
taigark		#11	[-]
Posts: 520 (02/20/09 6:37 AM) Hey! I kinda like it here! More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	matty p wrote: Taking Tocantins episode 2 and people's opinions into account: Heroes Tribe: Todd - China (Yeah, I know he's not really a hero but he gives hope to all lifelong fans of the show) Erik - Micronesia (Hilarious guy) Matty - Gabon (Had a great evolvement throughout Gabon) Coach - Tocantins (Thinks he is the hero) JT - Tocantins (Will be one of the most popular people in Tocantins amongst viewers) Peih-Gee - China (An underdog in China) Sugar - Gabon (Wanted the good to prevail in Gabon and it did because of her) Sierra - Tocantins (The underdog of Tocantins) Taj/Tocantins/Other Tocantins/Season 19 Female Tocantins/Season 19 Female Villains Tribe: Jean Robert - China (Lazy villain) Kenny - Gabon (Big schemer) Randy - Gabon (Great villain) Ace - Gabon (Provided some great lines in Gabon) Tyson - Tocantins (Jeff says he may be the villain in Tocantins) Courtney - China (Will be interesting to see her vs Jean-Robert again) Natalie - Micronesia (Schemer after the merge in Micronesia) Corrine - Gabon (Self-professed villain in Gabon) Erinn/Tocantins/Season 19 Female Tocantins/Season 19 Female This is just my opinion and I'm sure you all have different opinions on certain players, but no need to criticise, I invite healthy discussion. Erinn hasn't exactly made any impression if she's a villain or hero, yet. Also, just because someone thinks they're a hero doesn't make them automatically one.
matty p		#12	[-]
Posts: 6 (02/20/09 7:09 AM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	taigark wrote: Erinn hasn't exactly made any impression if she's a villain or hero, yet. Also, just because someone thinks they're a hero doesn't make them automatically one. Yeah but I think it would be more entertaining placing Coach on the Heroes tribe. He may have been edited negatively so far but he doesn't really have the strategy of a villain. Obviously Erinn, like the other Tocantins cast members, are still up for change.
survivorjordancontestant		#13	[-]
Posts: 1897 (02/20/09 8:16 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	matty p wrote: Yeah but I think it would be more entertaining placing Coach on the Heroes tribe. He may have been edited negatively so far but he doesn't really have the strategy of a villain. strategy of a villain? oh please, if you're an asshole, you're a villain, and Coach is one huge asshole.
Mypoody2		#14	[-]
Posts: 8763 (02/20/09 11:45 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	the fuck is this?
matty p		#15	[-]
Posts: 7 (02/21/09 12:13 AM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Mypoody2 wrote: the fuck is this? That was a helpful response. It's pretty obvious what it is.
TheEasyOne		#16	[-]
Posts: 1387 (02/21/09 12:43 AM) Registered user More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	matty p wrote: Mypoody2 wrote: the fuck is this? That was a helpful response. It's pretty obvious what it is. a lame thread?
diRkdARyL.survivorphilipp...	HUWAHT?? COACH = HERO	#17	[-]
Posts: 221 (02/21/09 12:56 AM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	HUWAHT?? COACH = HERO [+] CLOSE THIS THREAD IMMEDIATELY!!
Goosehead		#18	[-]
Posts: 1452 (02/21/09 2:17 AM) Registered User More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	This thread lacks a convincing premise.
Yeaster		#19	[-]
Posts: 6034 (02/21/09 7:07 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Would Crystal really count as a villain? I never thought she was a bitch, honestly. In fact, she seemed quite sweet. The only people she bitched at were Randy (who deserved it) and Matty.
matty p		#20	[-]
Posts: 8 (02/21/09 9:53 PM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Yeaster wrote: Would Crystal really count as a villain? I never thought she was a bitch, honestly. In fact, she seemed quite sweet. The only people she bitched at were Randy (who deserved it) and Matty. In my revised cast, I removed Crystal from the tribe. She was at times painted negatively but I agree that she is not really a villain.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Survivor 20: Heroes vs Villains

Survivor 20: Heroes vs Villains