Does anyone put any stock into what Jeff Probst said regarding Survivor: Tocantins making him push for a second all-stars due to some of the great characters this season or is was it just pre-season hype? And IF he's serious, and they ARE considering All Stars 2, what would the criteria be for eligible contestants?
Could ANYONE from Seasons 1-18/19 be eligible, including original All-Stars?
Would only contestants who appeared on Seasons post-AllStars be eligible (Seasons 8-18/19)?
What about the "Favorites" from Micronesia? Would they get a call for All-Stars? They competed against fans, but this would be the best vs. the best
And would that mean Bobby Jon and Stephanie would also be considered?
My thoughts.... EVERY original All-Star should NOT be considered for All-Stars: 2
ANY contestant who did not appear on the original All-Stars SHOULD be considered (Seasons 1-18/19)
If a contestant has appeared on a season twice (BobbyJon, Stephanie and the "Favs") they also could be brought back for All-Stars 2, but with a great deal of scrutiny, and second thought as to their worthiness.
I would include Stephanie. Was a major player in BOTH her seasons. Made it to the F2.
Of the "Favorites," I would only consider 3 players:
Ozzy (love him or hate him, he is what a Survivor All-Star should be, especially physically)
Cirie (one of THEE best social players to ever play the game, TWICE made the Top 4)
Jonathan (one of the best Survivor characters to play the game. Plays hard, and plays to win)
Other possible contestants::::
Survivor Borneo: Kelly (F2, decent social game, great female competitor)
Survivor: Australia: Mike (Leader of tribe, victim to the injury)
Survivor: Africa ---
Survivor: Marquesas Sean (GREAT charater, decent player)
Survivor: Thailand ---
Survivor: Amazon ---
Survivor: Pearl Islands Sandra (Outspoken winner of the season)
Survivor: Vanautu Twila (Deserved the win imo, great competitor and plays to win)
Survivor: Palau Tom or Ian (Alpha male, Type A player)
Survivor: Guatemala Rafe (So close to winning... "nice guy")
Danni (Winner of her season, nice on the eyes i guess, but somewhat boring)
Stephanie (A survivor "legend" lol)
Survivor: Exile Island Shane (GREAT character)
Terry (Physical powerhouse)
Survivor: Cook Islands Yul (VERY GOOD player, winner of his season)
Ozzy (see above)
Jonathan (see above)
Survivor: Fiji ---
Survivor: China Todd (Winner of his season, controlled game from very early on, decent character)
Pei-Gee (Another good character who fought all the way to the end)
Survivor: Fans vs Favs Cirie (see above)
Erik (made the "Dumbest" survivor move ever, looking for redemption, stong competitor, and if Amber can make the original.... why NOT Erik?)
Survivor: Gabon Kenny (Also a player who PLAY the game)
Crystal (Good player, not afraid to make moves and play the game)
Randy (GREAT Survivor character)
Sugar (Underrated Survivor player, made it to the Finals)
Still too early to say exactly on Tocantins, but early favorites would be Brendan, Taj, Stephen, Coach.... and possibly JT
