| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
token lunatic |
|||
|
I didn't see the movie so I got it after I googled it.
|
|||
nomii |
|||
|
i hope there's an uncut dvd/torrent if they supposedly censored even this.
|
|||
GoodNeighborgirl |
|||
|
They usually do show the uncut version after midnight, right?
|
|||
cardswin5 |
|||
|
Fave jokes:
"Joan's been on more red carpets than an Irish lesbian" "Carl Reiner is so old he once owned Robin's grandpappy" |
|||
robbiefan |
|||
|
Where the fuck was Lisa Lampanelli?!?!?!?!>?!?
The funniest were Jeff's as usual and Whitney! Who knew! |
|||
codayoda1221 |
|||
|
Very very funny. Kathy kinda sucked though.
|
|||
Liquidsunshine |
|||
|
Okay, I watched this last night.
Roasts should NEVER take place without Lisa Lampanelli. Whitney Cummings was awesome. Mario Cantone - whose stand up routines I usually love - was being a little prick whenever someone ripped into him. What's with the bitchy facial expressions? It's a roast, jesus, lighten up. |
|||
PAPAYOKE |
|||
|
Mario was awful. On these roasts, you should either be funny because your jokes are, or because you're so much of a trainwreck, or some combination of
both.
Gilbert Gottfried was surprisingly enjoyable. And while I know it might be sacrilege in OSTS, I would've preferred Kathy as a roaster, and Lisa Lampanelli as the host. Overall pretty good, but not the best of the Comedy Central roasts. |
|||
JerseyJerk |
|||
|
I felt kinda bad for Joan...besides Reiner there were no real celebs THERE although Rickles taped shit.
They either should go the way of Saget roasts and focus on "younger" comedians like Ross and Giraldo and Lampanelli or should have went with Reiner, Billy Crystal, Rickels (there), Goldberg, Robin Williams, Tomlin.....the BIG names. Idk kind just looked like a mash up...I had high hopes but def one of the worst roasts. |
|||
SmalltownBoy |
|||
|
Joan's roast was great.
As far as no celebrities there, I think that has to do with Joan's humor. She is not well liked. She knows it. Best of the night was Gilbert. I laughed at everything he said. Greg Geraldo was pretty funny too. Kathy, not so funny. She's losing her game. She needs to stick to her standup and her TV show and stop trying to branch out. Can't wait to read her book though. |
|||
pjadedd |
|||
|
I didn't watch the roast yet, but I think Kathy has problems when she's hosting something. I like her more if you just put her out there and let her
go. If she has to read something pre-written or something, she's not as good.
|
|||
Liquidsunshine |
|||
pjadedd wrote:I agree. As funny as she was on LKL, she kept doing that thing where she'd make a wry comment to Joan then immediately smile to let the audience know she was joking. It got a little tiring. But, she was much better on the roast because, well, obviously there wasn't a need to placate the audience. |
|||
A Dying Clown |
|||
|
The lack of Norm Macdonald made me sad
But there were a lot less duds than on that one - is it bad that I got probably the biggest laugh out of Tom Arnold's pop-up blocker jokes? It's the first one I thought Greg Girardo easily topped Jeffrey Ross' set. Also: Holy fuck, I hate Mario Cantone. He's probably the worst person I've ever seen on a roast. Including the old Dean Martin ones where they'd bring on someone like Omar Bradley |
|||
McWolcott |
|||
|
Greg Giraldo is one of the funniest roasters ever. I am so gonna watch his special this sunday. I hope it translates to a whole set cuz he cracks my ass up. I
really wish Lisa Lampanelli had been there though.
|
|||
Drew B |
|||
|
I was surprised that Robin Quivers' material was as good as it was. The delivery was just okay, and it got annoying with her laughing at all of her jokes,
but the writing was the best of anybody there.
I don't get the appeal of what Gilbert did. I was cringing; not laughing. |
|||
colt13 |
|||
|
This was one of the better roasts. And for those complaining about the roasters, those from Joan's era are already gone.
Since i watch Til Death, i was hoping Brad would be funnier, plus that someone would say that the only reason the show is still on is because of Joely Fisher's boobs, not another Ray Romano joke. |
|||
seaguy |
|||
Drew B wrote:The only thing I was laughing about is after he got up on stage and called Kathy "Swamp Thing in a Dress". That was pretty damn funny. The rest...meh. As annoying as Mario Cantone. I thought Whitney was pretty funny but I didn't think the AIDS joke was all that funny (the low T cell count). I just don't find making fun of disease all that funny, but that's just me I guess. |
|||
Drew B |
|||
seaguy wrote: X Not just making fun of the disease, but also equating being gay with having AIDS... |
|||
McWolcott |
|||
|
Gilbert's stories are always these long drawn out versions of the Aristocrats it seems like with a different punchline.
|
|||
seaguy |
|||
|
Yeah, I was gonna say that too. I have no problem with the gay jokes at all, but that stereotype that all gay men have AIDS was pretty stupid.
|
|||