Who is the most underrated player ever?

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
Ahora		#201	[-]
Posts: 595 (11/02/09 7:14 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	OrsNaz wrote: Erik from China was not an underrated player. He was an idiot. Anyone would have tried to convince Denise flip. Does not deserve any credit. He voted for Peih-Gee during the whole James ordeal, thus if James played the idol she would have been ousted instead of Todd. He was disappointed in Jaime and Peih-Gee for throwing the challenge etc. No, Erik voted for James at that tribal council.
mtj1282		#202	[-]
Posts: 3214 (11/02/09 7:18 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	SurvivorGuy91 wrote: mtj1282 wrote: Lexxan wrote: Kim Johnson. Her game was equal to Ethan's, won two Immunities, and was as likeable as Ethan imo. She did very well for a 57-Year old Grandmother. (Take that, Gillian!!) There was one tribal council were frank had voted for her and the fans were like WTF? cause it was so random. She wasnt as nice or likeable as she came across in the editing. However, I think she would have made a very deserving winner. Over Ethan? Likeability gave him the win over her. If that didnt come into play and she had won i think she would have made a deserving winner.
toomanynachos16		#203	[-]
Posts: 483 (11/02/09 7:26 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	ilovekelly752 wrote: toomanynachos16 wrote: Then in ASS, she thought that she and Tom would flip to Kathy/Lex/Shii Ann/Jerri at the merge until Lex fucked things up. Wait, couldn't they still have done it? Tom, Alicia, Lex, Kathy, and Shii-Ann against Rob, Amber, Jenna, and Rupert? Are you sure she wasn't planning to stay loyal to Rob the whole time? Lex keeping Amber was Alicia/Tom's signal that they were going to try and work with Rob/Amber and not with them.
ilovekelly752		#204	[-]
Posts: 203 (11/02/09 7:26 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	toomanynachos16 wrote: ilovekelly752 wrote: toomanynachos16 wrote: Then in ASS, she thought that she and Tom would flip to Kathy/Lex/Shii Ann/Jerri at the merge until Lex fucked things up. Wait, couldn't they still have done it? Tom, Alicia, Lex, Kathy, and Shii-Ann against Rob, Amber, Jenna, and Rupert? Are you sure she wasn't planning to stay loyal to Rob the whole time? Lex keeping Amber was Alicia/Tom's signal that they were going to try and work with Rob/Amber and not with them. oh, thanks
toomanynachos16		#205	[-]
Posts: 484 (11/02/09 7:28 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	mtj1282 wrote: SurvivorGuy91 wrote: mtj1282 wrote: Lexxan wrote: Kim Johnson. Her game was equal to Ethan's, won two Immunities, and was as likeable as Ethan imo. She did very well for a 57-Year old Grandmother. (Take that, Gillian!!) There was one tribal council were frank had voted for her and the fans were like WTF? cause it was so random. She wasnt as nice or likeable as she came across in the editing. However, I think she would have made a very deserving winner. Over Ethan? Likeability gave him the win over her. If that didnt come into play and she had won i think she would have made a deserving winner. That is literally one of the dumbest things I've ever read on this board....It's like saying, "Well, if you could just take the bitchiness out of Twila, then she would've been a deserving winner." Or maybe, "If you would've taken the craziness out of Matt, then he would've been a deserving winner."
OrsNaz		#206	[-]
Posts: 276 (11/02/09 10:25 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Ahora wrote: OrsNaz wrote: Erik from China was not an underrated player. He was an idiot. Anyone would have tried to convince Denise flip. Does not deserve any credit. He voted for Peih-Gee during the whole James ordeal, thus if James played the idol she would have been ousted instead of Todd. He was disappointed in Jaime and Peih-Gee for throwing the challenge etc. No, Erik voted for James at that tribal council. Honestly thought he voted Peih-Gee, regardless, either way it could have screwed Peih-Gee had James played the idol
Lexxan		#207	[-]
Posts: 47 (11/03/09 5:32 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	If you're not sure who voted for whom, consult Wikipedia ;)
chaddie		#208	[-]
Posts: 99 (11/03/09 5:45 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Mellisa McNutly
SurvivorGuy91		#209	[-]
Posts: 80 (11/03/09 6:45 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	mtj1282 wrote: SurvivorGuy91 wrote: mtj1282 wrote: Lexxan wrote: Kim Johnson. Her game was equal to Ethan's, won two Immunities, and was as likeable as Ethan imo. She did very well for a 57-Year old Grandmother. (Take that, Gillian!!) There was one tribal council were frank had voted for her and the fans were like WTF? cause it was so random. She wasnt as nice or likeable as she came across in the editing. However, I think she would have made a very deserving winner. Over Ethan? Likeability gave him the win over her. If that didnt come into play and she had won i think she would have made a deserving winner. There is nothing that she did that Ethan didn't, except he played his likability card as a strategy, whereas she didn't, which helped him get the win. Also, what plans did she concoct? Ethan orchestrated Silas' elimination (if I remember correctly) which is really his only major move, but Kim really didn't do anything. Besides, she was saved by the switch, because if Boran lost another immunity, it would've been her gone.
OrsNaz		#210	[-]
Posts: 277 (11/03/09 7:45 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Lexxan wrote: If you're not sure who voted for whom, consult Wikipedia ;) Hold on while I change Eriks vote to Peih-Gee :p
mtj1282		#211	[-]
Posts: 3216 (11/03/09 6:02 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	toomanynachos16 wrote: mtj1282 wrote: SurvivorGuy91 wrote: mtj1282 wrote: Lexxan wrote: Kim Johnson. Her game was equal to Ethan's, won two Immunities, and was as likeable as Ethan imo. She did very well for a 57-Year old Grandmother. (Take that, Gillian!!) There was one tribal council were frank had voted for her and the fans were like WTF? cause it was so random. She wasnt as nice or likeable as she came across in the editing. However, I think she would have made a very deserving winner. Over Ethan? Likeability gave him the win over her. If that didnt come into play and she had won i think she would have made a deserving winner. That is literally one of the dumbest things I've ever read on this board....It's like saying, "Well, if you could just take the bitchiness out of Twila, then she would've been a deserving winner." Or maybe, "If you would've taken the craziness out of Matt, then he would've been a deserving winner." What I meant was that there wasnt much that ethan did that made him a better player than her, therefor is she beat him i think she would have deserved it rather than thinking "oh ethan should have won, thats bullshit!"
mtj1282		#212	[-]
Posts: 3217 (11/03/09 6:03 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	SurvivorGuy91 wrote: mtj1282 wrote: SurvivorGuy91 wrote: mtj1282 wrote: Lexxan wrote: Kim Johnson. Her game was equal to Ethan's, won two Immunities, and was as likeable as Ethan imo. She did very well for a 57-Year old Grandmother. (Take that, Gillian!!) There was one tribal council were frank had voted for her and the fans were like WTF? cause it was so random. She wasnt as nice or likeable as she came across in the editing. However, I think she would have made a very deserving winner. Over Ethan? Likeability gave him the win over her. If that didnt come into play and she had won i think she would have made a deserving winner. There is nothing that she did that Ethan didn't, except he played his likability card as a strategy, whereas she didn't, which helped him get the win. Also, what plans did she concoct? Ethan orchestrated Silas' elimination (if I remember correctly) which is really his only major move, but Kim really didn't do anything. Besides, she was saved by the switch, because if Boran lost another immunity, it would've been her gone. Nope. The alliance was already made at that point. It would have been clarence.
toomanynachos16		#213	[-]
Posts: 486 (11/03/09 6:52 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	mtj1282 wrote: toomanynachos16 wrote: mtj1282 wrote: SurvivorGuy91 wrote: mtj1282 wrote: Lexxan wrote: Kim Johnson. Her game was equal to Ethan's, won two Immunities, and was as likeable as Ethan imo. She did very well for a 57-Year old Grandmother. (Take that, Gillian!!) There was one tribal council were frank had voted for her and the fans were like WTF? cause it was so random. She wasnt as nice or likeable as she came across in the editing. However, I think she would have made a very deserving winner. Over Ethan? Likeability gave him the win over her. If that didnt come into play and she had won i think she would have made a deserving winner. That is literally one of the dumbest things I've ever read on this board....It's like saying, "Well, if you could just take the bitchiness out of Twila, then she would've been a deserving winner." Or maybe, "If you would've taken the craziness out of Matt, then he would've been a deserving winner." What I meant was that there wasnt much that ethan did that made him a better player than her, therefor is she beat him i think she would have deserved it rather than thinking "oh ethan should have won, thats bullshit!" Okay, thank you for clarifying...I remember you from the Idol boards, and you're certainly not a moron...so I'm glad I just read it wrong ;)

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Who is the most underrated player ever?

Quick Reply