| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Buccaneer |
|||
|
Outback
|
|||
Outback |
|||
|
WTF. Both are good seasons. The worst is Fiji. Have you all forget luxury twist plus the fact everybody with exception of 1 or 2 castaways were recruited for
Fiji. Horrid season.
|
|||
mecansodemactors |
|||
|
all of you retards need to shut the fuck up. the first 8 seasons will forever live on as the best in survivor history. Samoa, Tocanshit, Fiji and the Cooks are
the worst ever.
|
|||
Ngiratkel |
|||
|
Borneo <<<<<<<<<<<< Outback <<<<<< Thailand
|
|||
novaya |
|||
mecansodemactors wrote: Exactly. Both Thailand and Australia were good. Tocantins was the absolute worst. I put it below CI and Fiji. |
|||
Breadwinner |
|||
|
What?! This isn't even up for discussion. Thailand is the worst season ever.
|
|||
SkyDreamer |
|||
|
Australia > 10 other seasons > Thailand > Fiji
|
|||
Maniacboy888 |
|||
|
Australia was EPIC. The only reason you KIDS don't love it is because you only get to see the shit they now shove down our throats as legitimate seasons.
|
|||
Deadpool |
|||
|
You're right. Australia was epic. But that was back when there was nothing else to watch and no real standards
since the only thing to compare it to Survivor's worst season of all Season 1. Now you wonder how we could even watch that shit.
|
|||
ribald2008 |
|||
|
Thailand
|
|||
sddorme.idolnoise |
|||
|
Australia > Every other season
Australia was the SHIT! |
|||
solesurvivor123 |
|||
McPhever224 wrote:I hated Outback because it seemed to go on forever and ever and there was never any great moment that made me really excited about what was happening. It was just another inferior rehash of the first season. Oh look people suffering because of their stupidity. It was one of the least difficult seasons with no bugs. They didn't have to struggle with rain or swimming like most seasons, and they didn't even have to deal with intense heat like Africa. Instead we got to see Elisabeth's hair fall out due to malnutrition. How exciting. They didn't ration their rice properly and actually got production intervention to give them more food because they were such screw ups. Then they messed up once again by not listening to Rodger and building their camp down near the river. The game side was even more dull with a bunch of followers and goats rolling over and accepting losing placements. The final jury was 1 big snoozefest. Colby, who controlled the entire game and made the numbers possible for his tribe didn't even win. On top of all that everybody was just really plain and boring, and the editing ignored way too many people. As awful as Thailand and amateur as Borneo were, they were both better than S2. |
|||
seljukbuyyid |
|||
|
Australia for the worst.
|
|||
027huds |
|||
|
How come so many people are ranking Borneo / Australian Outback as the worst? Clearly they shouldn't have an opinion / are the same person.
Australian Outback was an amazing season and had so many memorable characters and good moments. The same goes for Borneo. I'm afraid that's fact, so anyone who ranks them worst is clearly lying or hasn't even watched them. Thailand was pretty crappy at the time, but looking back it's not the worst. It did have a few uncomfortable moments and a really predictable post-merge thanks to the twist, but it really wasn't all bad. My least favourite has to be Cook Islands. Shitastic twists, shitastic new rules, too many invisible castaways and it just seemed dragged out because of the late merge and the early recap. |
|||
LuteinSa |
|||
027huds wrote:Because they were the worst seasons duh. |
|||
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
Posts: 9455 (11/08/09 7:59 PM) Registered user |
Charite wrote: In the words of Dick Cheney, go fuck yourself. Sorry, instinctive reaction. |
||
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
Posts: 9456 (11/08/09 8:01 PM) Registered user |
Breadwinner wrote: No it isn't, not even close. It's not even the worst among the first eight seasons. |
||
Xyston |
|||
|
People take these things way too personally geez. I think even people who are being real about this can admit that Borneo was the worst season because it was
new and the producers didn't really know what they were doing. They had this really cheesy soundtrack playing in the background and at times it seemed
like somebody made a video for their high school class.
|
|||
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
Posts: 9457 (11/08/09 8:09 PM) Registered user |
Xyston wrote: Not really. I consider the current soundtrack to be hokey and uninspired, while Borneo's was epic and inspiring. |
||
WylDawg |
|||
027huds wrote: Totally agree with everything you just said. If you hated the first two seasons, you're probably a n00b to Survivor. Seasons like Samoa, CI, Fiji and Palau are the ones that should be hated because they go against everything Survivor was originally about. But the greater question is, why do we need a daily thread to discuss and compare seasons? This is getting way old. |
|||