| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
JLK Name |
|
Lead | |
|
I was looking at my Survivor rankings and I looked at Guatemala/Marquesas they weren't in the worst seasons or the best seasons but I couldn't figure
out which is the better season? The location in S4 looked very dirty and the producers kinda ignore S11 by not inviting an contestant for a 2nd time around
(Stephenie/BJ are not included).
Last Edited By: JLK Name 11/18/09 12:30 AM.
Edited 1 time.
|
|||
Maniacboy888 |
|
||
|
Loved both, Marquesas was simply more memorable for being an early season. You can't really compare the two with the change in editing over the years
|
|||
JLK Name |
|
||
Maniacboy888 wrote:I think when it comes to characters, marquesas is better they had kathy, the rotu4, sean, paschal the purple rock victim and rob. In guatemala they had Stephenie, Judd and Jamie. Danni and Rafe doesn't really stand out no matter how they played the game. |
|||
Maniacboy888 |
|
||
|
I'll agree to that, I find Guatemala to be more fun to watch, but Marquesas will always be a classic
|
|||
agent2424 |
|
||
|
Posts: 4703 (11/18/09 12:57 AM) Registered user |
Marquesas was an instant classic.. But they come very close.... I would actually say I prefer Guatemala... I'm watching the season right now and maybe
it's because I haven't watched it in a long time but I'm loving the season... Both season had amazing contestants both pre merge and post merge. I
think Guatemala has one of the best pre jury groups though:
|
||
dontkilloffcharlie |
|
||
|
marquesas hands down.
marquesas was the first survivor season ever to have a power shift in alliances. nothing can top that, especially anything from guatemala |
|||
koondog |
|
||
|
Both are very good but Marquesas is slightly better.
|
|||
ThrowMeGabon |
|
||
dontkilloffcharlie wrote: this |
|||
ilovekelly752 |
|
||
|
Guatemala, because it was a more strategic season, with Danni, Stephenie, and Rafe. It's the same reason I like Pearl Islands, China, Micronesia, and
Amazon.
|
|||
solesurvivor123 |
|
||
|
Those are very close for me but I like Guatemala just a little bit more.
|
|||
027huds |
|
||
|
Both are very good seasons, but Guatemala beats Marquesas by a tiny margin for me. I just loved the epicness of the Guatemalan location with all the temples
and the wildlife as well as the camp set ups. It also seems like one of the toughest seasons ever for the castaways in terms of survival aspects. Some of the
challenges were amazing, like the one with the huge boulder and I like how the season played out. Also, the tribal council set was amazing.
Marquesas was great because of the groundbreaking strategy involved. For the first time the alliance in control was overthrown and didn't have control for the whole of the merge. Loved that it was the awful Rotu 4 who lost out as well, because seeing John cry like a baby was fun. The ending was a bit rubbish though. If the jury hadn't been so bitter, maybe Neleh would've actually won, which would've been a more satisfying result. I suppose though I have more recent memories of Guatemala as I'm just rewatching it now. I haven't watched Marquesas in at least a year or two, so maybe they will switch round once I get around to watching it again. |
|||
Wezzie |
|
||
|
Marquesas! Hunter, Rob M, Sean, Vee, Kathy O'Brien, John Carroll , beautiful scenery
Guatemala had the invisible winner and a bunch of cranky people sitting on rocks. The TC was nice, though. |
|||
OrsNaz |
|
||
|
Marquesas. Guatemala was decent but it was lacking in quite a few areas. Steph being an asshole and losing the season because of it ruined it for me. She
should have won...
|
|||
JackSparrowBauer |
|
||
|
I loved both, but I prefer Marquesas just slightly. Marquesas is my 5th favorite and Guatemala is my 6th. Marquesas just had a better overall storyline, some
epic subplots, really entertaining characters, and just an overall great season.
|
|||
GrenadeJumper85 |
|
||
|
This isn't even a contest - Marquesas, hands down, no questions asked. Great characters, memorable moments, and awesome gameplay from episode one to
episode thirteen.
Marquesas is, and always will be my favorite season of Survivor ever. |
|||
Shred |
|
||
|
This is a lot closer then ya think
Marquesas wins slightly though. Love the season, it's classic. Great cast, power plays and great moments. Purple rock......GINA!!!!!!!! <3, Rosie O Donnel hosting reunion. Free car give aways. Guatemala is so underrated though. Great season. |
|||
SleepTight |
|
||
|
Guatemala x100000
Marquesas bores me to tears. |
|||
GrenadeJumper85 |
|
||
|
I can still tell you what happened in EVERY single episode of Marquesas just by memory. I can't even remember half of what happened during the pre-merge
stage of Guatemala, let alone the entire game.
Not saying Guate was a horrible season, but it doesn't stand up to the greatness that was Marquesas or pretty much anything Pre-All Stars.
Last Edited By: GrenadeJumper85
11/18/09 1:03 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Penthesilea |
|
||
|
Guatemala
|
|||
Shred |
|
||
|
LULZ this is where that one poster with multiple accounts is gonna keep coming on saying Guatemala. Guatemala is great no need to. Nobody is dissing it.
|
|||
Dingo |
|
||
|
Guatemala was a fine season but Marquesas is a top 5. I'd even say it was a top 3. No contest.
|
|||