2) Melinda
3) Kimberley
4) Carol
5) Jasmine
6) Nikki
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
SamHarrisFan |
Rank the 3rd place finishers |
Lead | |
|
1) Elliott
2) Melinda 3) Kimberley 4) Carol 5) Jasmine 6) Nikki |
|||
Frankie G Morris |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
Who is Carol?
I honestly don't remember her. |
|||
Raydawggie |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
That's the correct list, although I'd swap Nikki and Jasmine.
|
|||
NiceToAnimals |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
I think he meant Vonzell instead of Carol. I always mix those two names up.
|
|||
dcartist |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
1) Mel
2) El 3) Kim 4) VS 5) Nik 6) Jas |
|||
Frankie G Morris |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
Oh Yeah, I forgot some people called Baby V - Carol. It wasn't really funny then, and I guess I vanished it from my memory.
|
|||
NiceToAnimals |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
I didn't post here that much that season. Where did calling her "Carol" come from?
|
|||
Frankie G Morris |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
If I remember correctly ... someone called her Carol Smith or something, because she acted too "white" for their liking.
I may be wrong. They thought they were clever and witty though. That I do remember. |
|||
Cousin Oliver |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
1) Melinda
2) Elliott small gap... 3) Kimberley 4) Vonzell much larger gap 5) Jasmine 6) Nikki |
|||
NiceToAnimals |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
Thanks, Frankie. I'm sure it was funny at the time. Or not. ;)
|
|||
HumanFund |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
1. Nikki
Small Gap 2. Vonzell Everyone else sucked. |
|||
Hotlantan |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
Quote:Some superior posters here felt (and still feel) there are very specific stereotypes that ALL Black people are supposed to talk and act like. This was thier Stormfront Aryan code way of criticizing her for not being "Black" enough. It wasn't at all humorous either then or now.
|
|||
Msbossy |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
1. Melinda
2. Elliott 3. Kimberly 4. Vonzell |
|||
Msbossy |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
1. Melinda
2. Elliott 3. Kimberly 4. Vonzell 5. Jasmalien 6. Nikki |
|||
seaguy |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
KLo, Melinda & Elliott are three of my all time favorites that have been on this show. So I can't rank them. The others are easy:
4. Nikki 5. Vonzell 6. Jasmine |
|||
Hotlantan |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
Msbossy, you were right the first time.
There was no real reason to rank either Jasmine "would you like to sample our Costco cheezy doodles?" Trias or Nikki "Five dollar for a table top, Mister?" McKibbon. |
|||
moovivor |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
1. CAROL
2. Kimberley 3. Melinda 4. Elliott 5. Jasmalien 6. Nikki |
|||
Gregoire |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
Elliott and Nikki are my two favorite American Idol contestants EVER. Kimberley was my favorite from season two. Everyone I love always places third. I even preferred Vonzell to FarmBot and Bo. Although, where is she now?
|
|||
VejasFroggerCousinOfJess |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
1. Jasmine- She was entertaining every week and eliminated the boring Latoya London she was one of the saving graces in a season that might have been bad as the current one if not for her presence.
2. Elliot-Great singer and he looks like my cousin and him cracking up at all the ford music videos like they were the funniest thing ever in turn always made me laugh 3.K Lo-Was unlucky to be on the same year as overpimped rueben and the guy with the craziest and largest fanbase in the shows history 4.Baby V- I can't remember anything she sang although she looked good almost always 5.Nikki-I initially liked her but because of her we have had to put up with a bunch of people with dyed red and purple spots 6.Melinda- Too old fashioned for the Lawrence Welk she singlehandily caused the show to jump |
|||
Raydawggie |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
If I recall, the Carol thing came as a spin-off of when everyone gave J.Hud a more "divalicious" name of Boomquisha Dijonnay Santiago. As Vonzell didn't act Divalicious enough for HER name, she was renamed Carol Smith. I love this board.
|
|||
Mai4 |
Re: Rank the 3rd place finishers | ||
|
1. Melinda
<gap> 2. Vonzell 3. Elliott 4. K Locke 5. Jasmine 6. Nasty Nikki |
|||