
You might not know this, but Top Chef is seriously Project Runway's bastard sibling. They're made by the same production company, Magical Elves, but are similar in some ways. Project Runway has batshit crazy people in a sewing room with sharp needles while Top Chef has batshit crazy people in a kitchen with sharp knives. Project Runway has spectacular trainwrecks when they made shitty clothing while Top Chef has spectacular trainwrecks when they made shitty food. Both of the these programs are so similar, and I just love them both.
Inspired by UKK's ProjRun rankathon thread, here's my Top Chef rankathon thread, ranking all 92 cheftestants from the six seasons that have aired so far. This list is based on the following criterion: cooking ability, entertainment value, and personality. But really, it's all about the last two, because let's face it; while we all think we can decide who's the better cook, we can only look at the food, not taste it.
I've been rewatching the earlier seasons (I've just started rewatching Season 5) to get a better grasp of who's actually a good character and who's not, so I'd like to think is accurate. But then again, who gives a fuck? It's a matter of interpretation, and if you agree, good for you. If not, oh well, I don't give a shit.
Each chef will receive a consolation prize; an ingridient that is indicative of who they are, or just something they fucked them up in a QuickFire or Elimination challenge. Because I'm nice like that. :)
First write-up coming soon! Gonna finalize the list and watch some more Top Chef.
Update on 12/01/2010
02nd: Tiffani Faison
03rd: Stephen Asprinio
04th: Lisa Fernandes
05th: Spike Mendelsohn
06th: Marcel Vigneron
07th: Andrew D'Ambrosi
08th: Dave Martin
09th: Robin Leventhal
10th: Cynthia Sestito
11th: Jennifer Carroll
12th: Fabio Viviani
13th: Dale Talde
14th: Kevin Gillespie
15th: Stefan Richter
16th: Lee Anne Wong
17th: Elia Aboumrad
18th: Mia Gaines-Alt
19th: Ariane Duarte
20th: Dale Levitski
21st: Bryan Voltaggio
22nd: Andrea Beaman
23rd: Ken Lee
24th: Ashley Merriman
25th: Mark Simmons
26th: Sara Nguyen
27th: Michael Midgley
28th: Jamie Lauren
29th: Brian Malarkey
30th: Micah Edelstein
31st: Hung Huynh
32nd: Radhika Desai
33rd: Jeff McInnis
34th: Harold Dieterle
35th: Candice Kumai
36th: Sam Talbot
37th: Ron Duprat
38th: Josie Smith-Malave
39th: Nikki Cascone
40th: Ash Fulk
41st: Stephanie Izard
42nd: Lisa Parks
43rd: Jennifer Biesty
44th: Richard Sweeney
45th: Carlos Fernandez
46th: Clay Bowen
47th: Lia Bardeen
48th: Ryan Scott
49th: Jill Snyder
50th: Mattin Noblia
51st: Suyai Steinhauer
52nd: Casey Thompson
53rd: Jesse Sandlin
54th: Hector Santiago
55th: Tre Wilcox
56th: Camille Becerra
57th: Sara Mair
58th: Valerie Bolon
59th: Otto Borsich
60th: Emily Sprissler
61st: Manuel Trevino
62nd: Patrick Dunlea
63rd: Jen Zavala
64th: Marisa Churchill
65th: Alex Eusebio
66th: Zoi Antonitsas
67th: Nimma Osman
68th: Laurine Wickett Hope
69th: Brian Hill
70th: Miguel Morales
71th: CJ Jacobsen
72nd: Antonia Lofaso
73rd: Melissa Harrison
74th: Michael Voltaggio
75th: Richard Blais
76th: Eve Aronoff
77th: Betty Fraser
78th: Preeti Mistry
79th: Eugene Villiatora
80th: Sandee Birdsong
81st: Hosea Rosenberg
82nd: Lauren Hope
83rd: Cliff Crooks
84th: Eli Kirshtein
85th: Howie Kleinberg
86th: Danny Gagnon
87th: Ilan Hall
88th: Erik Hopfinger
89th: Mike Isabella
90th: Leah Cohen
91st: Frank Terzoli
92nd: Joey Paulino














