Survivor All Stars Winners Edition in Lions, Tigers, Survivors

0 Points

Survivor All Stars Winners Edition

Started By	Comment
xena321	Survivor All Stars Winners Edition	Lead	[-]
Posts: 48 (12/09/09 07:31 AM) Registered User More Recent Posts	I can resist everything except temptation. Remove this ad If there was an all stars edition that only had winners and runner-ups(including final 3 aswell) from the 19 seasons. Which 16 survivors would you pick for the two tribes? You know whenever they decide to end Survivor, I think doing something like this would be the best way to end it, but I think they'll have to pick from the top 4 from each season, as even though there will be enough people from winners/runners-up to choose, alot may back out, so they'll have to go to 4. Last Edited By: xena321 12/09/09 09:07 AM. Edited 1 time.
SkyDreamer		#1	[-]
Posts: 529 (12/09/09 07:49 AM) More Recent Posts	Winners - Sandra Parvati Danni Jenna Richard Todd Ethan Yul Runner ups - Kelly Courtney Amanda Stephenie Colby Stephen I can't think of another 2 guys.
KMKinCB		#2	[-]
Posts: 28 (12/09/09 09:06 AM) More Recent Posts	Winners- Sandra Parvati Jenna Tina Todd Richard Tom J.T. Runner-Ups (I'm including anyone in a final 3 Final Tribal Council): Courtney Sugar Katie Twila Colby Boston Rob Dreamz Clay
Michaelf7777777	Tribes for all Winners/ Runnersup Edition	#3	[-]
Posts: 9 (12/09/09 09:36 AM) More Recent Posts	I think 1st up It would be good to check all the possible candidates to see where they stand Richard (S1) - The original creator of the alliance and the man who made survivor what it is. Was targeted immediately in All Stars and even though this may well happen again, if he is out of prison then he is a definite yes. Kelly (S1) - The original female challenge dominator who had second thoughts about alliances. Possibility Tina (S2) - One of the original great social and strategic female players. Definite Yes Colby (S2) - Very strong in challenges and decent strategically (despite one huge blunder). Still a big fan favourite so definately yes Ethan (S3) - Great social player who benefited from Samburu errors but considering his relationship with Jenna M who would be more valuable for this type of project, I would have to say No Kim J (S3) - A goat outside of their main alliance who only got to the finals by the unlikely winning of two immunities so definately not Vecepia (S4) - Very good if somewhat dull strategic player who came up with flipflopping two seasons before Rob C. Possibility Neleh (S4) - Only cast if eyecandy is needed. Didn't play for the 1st 24 days by her own admission. Definately No. Brian (S5) - Absolutely dominant in his season. Despite his problems with the law. Definite Yes Clay (S5) - Very nearly got the wolf in goat's clothing strategy to work with only some unproven allegations and one explosion coming back to haunt him. Stronger physically than he looked and provided some good one liners. Probable Jenna (S6) - Good social player who also won four immunity challenges during her season. Has also retained prominance through such ventures as Survivor Live and is also good eye candy for attracting viewers. Definate Yes Matthew (S6) - Great physical player who strategically progressed from being the clueness aliance partner of the strategic mastermind (who mocked hin behind his back) to outsmarting the mastermind by throwing the F3 immunity challenge. Probable Sandra (S7) - Weak physically but unusual anyone but me stratergy and explosive temper makes her a Definate Yes Lilian (S7) - Would usually be nothing more than a 3rd boot. Definately No Amber (S8) - Very good player but not as good as Rob M so Definately Not Rob M (S8) - Player of one of the greatest games not to win. Definite Yes Chris (S9) - Came back from 6-1 down. Yes Twila (S9) - Abrasive personality who hand fed the game changing move to the winner. Possibility Tom W (S10) - Extremely popular and good physical competitor. Also a lifesaver during 9-11 so Definate Yes Katie (S10) - Goat. No Danni (S11) - Social Strategic brillance. Yes Steph (S11) - Fan Favourite who murdered all her goats and became a goat herself. Probable Aras (S12) - No Danielle (S12) - No Yul (S1 3) - Dull strategic mastermind. Possibility Ozzy (S1 3) - Great challenge dominator and fan favourite. Yes Earl (S14) - To Dull. No Todd (S15) - A canniving winner who could form an interesting showmance with Hatch. However the large possibilities of China means he is just a Possible. Courtney (S15) - Eyecandy spot to attract viewers. Yes Parvati (S16) - All girl alliance expert whom would of been in a good position if not for twists in original season. Definate Yes Amanda (S16) - Late game physical threat. Good enough social and strategic threat to reach the Final Tribal Council twice. Definite Yes Bob (S17) - Nice old man who won 5 challenges in a row. Probable Susie (S17) - Old lady who didn't appear to do much. No JT (S18) - Physical dominater. Good enough to win 7-0 against a good player. Yes Stephen (S18) - Good strategist, however couldn't muster a single vote so probably not Male Shortlist Rich Colby Brian Clay Matthew Rob M Chris Tom W Yul Ozzy Todd Bob JT Female Shortlist Kelly W Tina Vecepia Jenna M Sandra Twila Danni Stephenie Courtney Parvati Amanda Tribe 1 Rich Mathew Rob M Yul Amanda Stephenie Tina Sandra Tribe 2 Brian Colby Tom W Chris Jenna M Kelly W Parvati Danni
Michaelf7777777	Another possibility	#4	[-]
Posts: 10 (12/09/09 09:41 AM) More Recent Posts	Or if we're doing a tribe of winners vs a tribe of runners up Winners Richard Brian Chris JT Jenna M Sandra Parvati Danni Runners Up Colby Stephen Rob M Clay Amanda Twila Kelly W Stephenie
georgiaknight33		#5	[-]
Posts: 244 (12/09/09 10:58 AM) Registered user More Recent Posts	WINNERS Richard Brian Chris Earl JT Jenna Sandra Amber Parvati Natalie FINALISTS Colby Matthew Clay Dreamz Stephen Kelly Neleh Katie Courtney Susie Amazing cast <3
Maximus20		#6	[-]
Posts: 368 (12/09/09 11:08 AM) More Recent Posts	Winners Tribe Richard Todd Brian Tom W Yul Tina Sandra Danni Jenna Parvarti Runner-Up's tribe Ozzy Colby Steven Rob M Dreamz Twilia Amanda Stephenie Courtney Kelly
Sole Survivor Genius		#7	[-]
Posts: 1571 (12/09/09 11:10 AM) Registered User More Recent Posts	Michaelf7777777 wrote: I think 1st up It would be good to check all the possible candidates to see where they stand Kim J (S3) - A goat outside of their main alliance who only got to the finals by the unlikely winning of two immunities so definately not JT (S18) - Physical dominater. Good enough to win 7-0 against a good player. Yes Stephen (S18) - Good strategist, however couldn't muster a single vote so probably not Disagree! Kim J should have won Africa.. She made her alliance with the right people, she won when she needed to and DAMN she out-beat guys almost half her age! Stephen didn't get a vote because the Jury was too bitter and everyone effin loved JT, who by the way did NOTHING to win. He got by on the effin southern charm bullshit. BARF. Did he strategize once that entire season? Oh wait he did, to get the gay guy out. -_-'
Huntorr		#8	[-]
Posts: 26 (12/09/09 11:14 AM) More Recent Posts	Michaelf7777777 wrote: Earl (S14) - To Dull. No I think you gotta put Earl on there. Great strategist, was in control of his entire season. I'd also consider Dreamz, because of his unpredictability and the fact that he was so memorable.
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#9	[-]
Posts: 9846 (12/09/09 01:12 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts	I can resist everything except temptation. Remove this ad Winners are at the top of the list. No runners up.
SleepTight		#10	[-]
Posts: 320 (12/09/09 03:03 PM) More Recent Posts	Yul & Danni F2 plz
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok		#11	[-]
Posts: 1677 (12/09/09 05:47 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts	Michaelf7777777 wrote: I think 1st up It would be good to check all the possible candidates to see where they stand Vecepia (S4) - Very good if somewhat dull strategic player who came up with flipflopping two seasons before Rob C. Possibility Neleh (S4) - Only cast if eyecandy is needed. Didn't play for the 1st 24 days by her own admission. Definately No. Psh ha wtf ever!!! Neleh may have not played til late in the game but Vecepia never did. Vecepia=worst winner ever and will never be a possibility to be on any other survivor season ever! She wasnt asked back for All-Stars, Neleh was. Also Spoiler [+] 4 of the 7 female winners were asked back for All-Stars 2 and she was definitely not one of them. And yet again Neleh was asked back Neleh > Vecepia
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok		#12	[-]
Posts: 1678 (12/09/09 05:50 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts	Winners vs. Runner-ups sounds better to me Winners Brian Earl Todd Yul Aras Samoa winner Danni Sandra Jenna Tina Runner-ups Steven Dreamz RobM Matthew Colby Neleh KellyW Twila Katie Courtney
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#13	[-]
Posts: 9860 (12/09/09 06:19 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts	ElisabethNelehHeidiRok wrote: Psh ha wtf ever!!! Neleh may have not played til late in the game but Vecepia never did. Vecepia=worst winner ever and will never be a possibility to be on any other survivor season ever! She wasnt asked back for All-Stars, Neleh was. Also Spoiler [+] 4 of the 7 female winners were asked back for All-Stars 2 and she was definitely not one of them. And yet again Neleh was asked back Neleh > Vecepia You're delusional. Vecepia played the game brilliantly, it was just hidden from view most of the time. And Neleh being invited to ASS is no indiction of her game prowess. If anything, it's the exact opposite.
KMKinCB		#14	[-]
Posts: 36 (12/09/09 11:37 PM) More Recent Posts	ElisabethNelehHeidiRok wrote: Winners vs. Runner-ups sounds better to me Winners Brian Earl Todd Yul Aras Samoa winner Danni Sandra Jenna Tina Runner-ups Steven Dreamz RobM Matthew Colby Neleh KellyW Twila Katie Courtney What happens if a guy wins????
ilovekelly752		#15	[-]
Posts: 587 (12/09/09 11:43 PM) More Recent Posts	Winners: Todd Parvati Richard Sandra JT Danni Brian Tina Runners Up: Colby Courtney Rob Twila Ozzy Kelly Stephen Stephenie
Ahora		#16	[-]
Posts: 724 (12/10/09 12:18 AM) More Recent Posts	winners Sandra JennaM Tina Parvati Richard Todd Aras Tom RunnerUps CourtneyY Twila KellyW Steph Colby Stephen Ozzy RobM
Antithesys		#17	[-]
Posts: 25789 (12/10/09 01:15 AM) Gadabout More Recent Posts	I can resist everything except temptation. Remove this ad We're putting this kind of thing in the stickied thread for now.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Survivor All Stars Winners Edition

Survivor All Stars Winners Edition