| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
PumaPeggy |
|||
|
the horses seemed in the script...as a way for Ben to ride off. Makes no difference to me...I think I was one animal long anyway, in my answer.
Technically...I'd say the smoke monster made one appearance...despite the different views of it. wow...I think MS is clairvoyant...asking the going up any
stairs question<G>.
|
|||
agent2424 |
|||
|
Posts: 2712 (04/24/08 10:46 PM) Registered user |
This was simply a pathetic attempt, I think I remember once being in the Sucks 6, and was still close to it, well now that dream is over... A pathetic 300 points with a total of 6 questions right... I think i got that, someone can try re-calculating it, but wow that went terrible. |
||
FeliciaM7 |
|||
|
Those two horses were definitely part of the script. They didn't just wander by the cameraman like those damn birds that used to count.
Claire's face was bloody when Sawyer uncovered her. She looked better later, but she had blood on her face after the explosion. Ugh I actually put more than one regarding Smokey because I know how nitpicky we all can be with the questions (HOW MANY TIMES will the smoke monster be seen. technically it was seen twice), so I figured if he was seen in two separate scenes it would count as two. And I still think anyone who went out on a limb with 11+ for #7 should get it right! There was so much violence in this episode. Worth a try anyway. :) |
|||
catspasms |
|||
|
You know, I believe it is 9 injuries/deaths total...
*2 guys on horseback + guy Sayid kills + 3 Lockie red shirts + freighter dude in the smoke monster + Alex + Claire |
|||
Beautiful Patsy |
|||
I can't read Misterpuff's answers at all. Can anyone else see them?I can see them. Here are Misterpuff's answers: 1. No |
|||
aslanscubs |
|||
|
As far as injuries, here's what I counted:
-Ben -Two guys in the desert -Three redshirts killed in Otherville -Claire -Guy Sayid killed -Freightie killed by Smokey -Alex (RIP) -Dr. Ray (I think he'd count since he was definitely injured in this episode and wasn't the last time we saw him) As far as animals, I counted Vincent and two horses. Did anyone see any other animals? Dang, I didn't hear Sawyer call Locke that! Grrrr!!!! |
|||
FeliciaM7 |
|||
|
Then that is 11 deaths/injuries. We never saw Nadia's body, right?
What a rip-off. I wanted to see her with Sayid before she died. That and Alex getting killed really disappointed me. :-/ Unfortunately for my no answer, Sawyer did call Locke a "crazy son of a bitch". It was when they were in the jungle. I just saw the three animals, Aslans. I wanted to see two more! Thanks Beautiful Patsy!
Last Edited By: FeliciaM7
04/25/08 7:06 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
aslanscubs |
|||
|
I meant to add thanks so much, Felicia for posting my answers last night. My hubby bought a new monitor last night and is going to pick up the computer deck
this evening. Yeah, for a new computer!!!
I bombed this quiz didn't I? ETA: Ok, so Ben kissing Alex's head when he was saying goodbye to her wouldn't be sharing a kiss huh? Hey, I'm trying!! Injured Claire
Last Edited By: aslanscubs
04/25/08 9:12 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
MissScamper |
|||
|
Hi, everyone.
I just want to say that I'm sorry for ever complaining about how slow the episodes would go back in Seasons 2 & 3, cuz now things are moving so fast my head is spinning, and I have a hard time keeping up with all the action in each episode. I think only a few questions are under debate at this point, so I'll just address them. Definite Injuries = 3 Losties were shot (bang, bang, bang right in a row); Claire was injured when her house was blown up; Ben injured the 2 guys in the desert; Sayid killed the guy in Iraq; and Alex was killed. That's 8 for sure. Debatable Injuires = We saw Smokey drag the guy away, but I have to watch it again cuz I'm not sure we actually saw Smokey injure the guy. We didn't see Ben get injured when he landed in the desert (I expect a polar bear caused his injury). We didn't see Doctor Doom's throat get cut. Did Sawyer get injured in the compound? Discuss. Did we actually see anyone climb stairs? I have the impression Ben climbed stairs in London, but I have to watch it again to be sure. I saw 3 animals (Vincent & 2 horses). I think Smokey appeared only 1 time this episode. We got several different views of Smokey, but he showed up, moved around, did a lot of damage, and then left. Usually Smokey shows up, disappears, and then re-appears to do some damage. This time he was called so he just stayed around. So, the official answer is 1. I heard Sawyer say Son of a Bitch, but I thought he was referring to Ben, not Locke. |
|||
PumaPeggy |
|||
|
>>Did we actually see anyone climb stairs? I have the impression Ben climbed stairs in London, but I have to watch it again to be sure. <<
twice actually. Ben climbed stairs in Tikrit to take pictures at Nadia's funeral...and climbed stairs in London. BTW...I answered no to there being any stair climbing ocurring...so I'm not being biased<g>. I need to watch again...I missed Hurley saying Dude. |
|||
aslanscubs |
|||
|
I too answered no to the stairs questions and thought I might injure myself when I saw Ben going up those steps in Tikrit. Dang it. Hurley said dude near the
beginning of the episode when they were playing Risk.
|
|||
FeliciaM7 |
|||
|
I think we can safely assume that Smokey killed the guy we saw him grab. How many have seen his wrath, have seen him in destroy mode, were touched by him
(it) and lived??? Well Locke did that one time, but hell he wanted to ride the monster's back down a hole so he ain't right and doesn't count. Back to Ben, I thought we didn't have to see him get injured as long as it was a new injury. I mean, what if five guys stumbled from the jungle and collapsed dead as hell, but we never saw if it was Smokie or if an Other injured them or whatever. I would think those guys would be in the injured/dead even though we didn't see the cause. The doc was alive when we last saw him and dead this time, dunno who cut his throat but he's still dead.
I know the question was "how many injured in this episode" but that can be taken two ways even though some clarifications were made. It could be turned around to "while viewing this episode, how many people do we see that are injured or apparently dead"? Does that make sense? We see them dead, but not who or what did it. I knew this would be a violent episode so I went high. It's difficult with such a high body count to nitpick over this shouldn't count and that
shouldn't count. We know at least 11 and probably more than 11 were injured or dead/killed or just shown injured/dead. I know this is a lame plea
for 11+ but if it counts it will help at least 3 posters, if it's 8 or 9, then I don't think anyone got it right. Could be wrong.
Last Edited By: FeliciaM7
04/25/08 1:54 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
aslanscubs |
|||
|
FWIW, I agree about the injuries. With the ones I listed earlier today, the count would be 11 at least. The guy grabbed by Smokey was a definite injury in my
book. Didn't you hear him scream? Anyway, I'd be arguing this one even if my answer was different because I believe there were a lot of injuries this
episode.
|
|||
PumaPeggy |
|||
|
I just watched it again...heard the Dude this time...can't believe I missed it. I was going to mention Ben giving Alex a kiss also. Once again that
doesn't help me...but it definitely happened. I still could not give you an accurate injured count...because we don't know how many Smokie really got.
I also wanted to point out...the Doc that washed ashore...he had stitches on his face....besides the throat cut. He'd not had stiches before. Just
rather interesting<g>. I heard Sawyer saying you Son of a .... to Locke. Ben did NOT go up stairs in London as I thought...but he definitely did in
Tikrit.
|
|||
cindidindi76 |
|||
|
JMO, but if someone kissing Aaron wouldn't have counted, then Ben kissing Alex shouldn't. The question didn't specify "share a romantic
kiss" though, so I won't be bitching either way it gets decided.
I know this is a lame plea for 11+ but if it counts it will help at least 3 posters, if it's 8 or 9, then I don't think anyone got it right. Lol! It would probably help at least 3 posters if one of the other answers were changed too, but that shouldn't affect what the answer is! |
|||
FeliciaM7 |
|||
|
None of the others are really debatable ('cept maybe the kiss) so I'm not asking her to change her official answer. I'm asking for a
consideration. If she changed the answer to any other question, it'd be 100 % WRONG. So there. Eat me.
And give me a call sometime soon. It's been awhile! |
|||
Magnolia2day |
|||
|
I'm going on a trip tomorrow so can Fel, or Cindi or Aslan please post my answers for next week "? They will be a;; NO except yes for the first
& last answers & all multiple choice should be answered alphabetically ie a for the first multiple choice b for the second etc :)
Last Edited By: Magnolia2day
04/25/08 8:53 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
FeliciaM7 |
|||
|
So that's all no answers except yes to first and last question. And A, B, C, D, etc in that order to any multiple choice?
I should be able to do it for you, my Mags. |
|||
MissScamper |
|||
|
Just finished rewatching the episode. Yep, we did see Ben walk up stairs, so the answer to that questions is Yes..
And yes, we did see Ben kiss Alex on the forehead. HOWEVER, the quesiton was, Will anyone share a kiss? Sharing a kiss, IMO, means the participants are alive to share in the activity. When one participant is dead, well, that's not sharing. (Now you've made me remember a scene from Criminal Minds, where the killer only buried his victims from the shoulders down, so he could go back to "visit" them. He kissed the corpse on the lips. Hate to think about what else he did when he "visited" the corpse. EUWWWW) Sorry, I just can't make this a yes answer. (And my guess for this question was yes, so I'm not doing myself any favors here.) As for the injury question, I thought a lot about it, and it made my head hurt. Consequently, I'm going to just throw it out. In other words, everyone gets the same amount of credit for the question, no matter what answer they picked. So, gentle scorekeepers, would you please post the results to this week's quiz? Thank you so much. |
|||
FeliciaM7 |
Scamper's official answers | ||
|
1. Yes 2. Yes 3. No 4. No 5. No 6. No 7. N/A 8. No 9. No 10. Yes 11. Yes 12. D (3) 13. No 14. Yes 15. Yes 16. B (1) 17. No 18. Yes 19. A (0) 20. Yes |
|||