The best player won!!! in Lions, Tigers, Survivors

0 Points

The best player won!!!

Started By	Comment
BeerIsTasty	The best player won!!!	Lead	[-]
Posts: 17 (01/10/10 08:37 PM) More Recent Posts	I CAN REMOVE is 100 times more important than IQ. Remove this ad In thinking about who won each season, when did the best player that season actually take the title? Here are my thoughts, taking into account mainly who played the best game, with some additional social aspects included. I understand some may say the best player always wins or whatever based on the final votes. However to me "game" play (strategic 75% and challenge 25%) is more interesting as to how they got there, and won the title. Borneo: Richard Hatch Thailand: Brian Heidik Vanuatu: Chris Daugherty Palau: Tom Westman Cook Islands: Yul Kwon Fiji: Earl Cole China: Todd Herzog Micronesia: Parvati Shallow Tocantins: JT Thomas So 9 times out of 19 the best "game" player won, most will disagree with this list as a whole, however everyone will agree with several I am sure. Last Edited By: BeerIsTasty 01/10/10 08:53 PM. Edited 2 times.
troynuncdicit		#1	[-]
Posts: 848 (01/10/10 08:43 PM) More Recent Posts	BeerIsTasty wrote: In thinking about who won each season, when did the best player that season actually take the title? Here are my thoughts, taking into account mainly who played the best game, with some additional social aspects included. I understand some may say the best player always wins or whatever based on the final votes. However to me "game" play is more interesting as to how they got there, and won the title. Borneo: Richard Hatch Thailand: Brian Heidik Vanuatu: Chris Daugherty Palau: Tom Westman Cook Islands: Yul Kwon Fiji: Earl Cole China: Todd Herzog Micronesia: Parvati Shallow Tocantins: JT Thomas So 9 times out of 19 the best "game" player won, most will disagree with this list as a whole, however everyone will agree with several I am sure. Just out of curiosity (and lulz depending on the following), who did you think was the best player in Samoa? (oh wait, he put best "game" player so it's probably Russell )
roxbury123		#2	[-]
Posts: 717 (01/10/10 08:50 PM) More Recent Posts	Are you talking about the best of the people in the finals or the best over all the season. Because i dont think there would be any argument but CIRIE >>>>>>>>>>>>>> PARV on FVF. If you account for the entire season. But if not duh PARV >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Amanda. But i think Tina played the best in Season 2 and deserved her win.
roxbury123		#3	[-]
Posts: 718 (01/10/10 08:53 PM) More Recent Posts	I think truly the best "player" of each season is as follows: RICH --- TINA -- LEX -- ? -- BRIAN --- ROB C --- JFP --- BOSTON ROB --- CHRIS --- TOM --- RAFE --- ? --- YUL --- EARL --- TODD -- CIRIE -- SUGAR --- JT --- RUSSELL. SEASON 4: Neleh/Sean/Pappy/Kathy/Vecepia all Dominated that game together so its hard to pic just one of them SEASON 12: Cirie or Aras i really couldn't choose they played that game together and made all the moves together so it was hard to pick just one of them.
SurvivorNinja		#4	[-]
Posts: 3504 (01/10/10 08:58 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts	The person who won was the best player of the season. If you need me to post why every single Survivor lost and the winners won I will but the "master manipulator" players who lost obviously lacked something the "master manipulators" who won had, amiright?
Despotism		#5	[-]
Posts: 176 (01/10/10 08:58 PM) More Recent Posts	The OP is a sexist piece of shit. Rot in hell!
BeerIsTasty		#6	[-]
Posts: 18 (01/10/10 08:59 PM) More Recent Posts	I am saying the best for the entire season cast. I agree Cirie was right there with Parvati, however a small step behind, and Ozzy close to, however short of Yul. In my opinion there are a couple of other close calls such as Tina, Ethan, Jenna, Sandra, and Danni, but another player was slightly ahead of them.
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok		#7	[-]
Posts: 1905 (01/10/10 09:01 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts	OVERALL best "player" of Samoa was not Russell, he was runner-up. The End.
roxbury123		#8	[-]
Posts: 720 (01/10/10 09:03 PM) More Recent Posts	I CAN REMOVE is 100 times more important than IQ. Remove this ad ElisabethNelehHeidiRok wrote: OVERALL best "player" of Samoa was not Russell, he was runner-up. The End. Why do you just say that for Russell and not Boston Rob???? JKJK I GET IT!
ilovekelly752		#9	[-]
Posts: 1025 (01/10/10 09:07 PM) More Recent Posts	Borneo- best player won Australia- best player won Africa- best player won Marquesas- best player won Thailand- best player won Amazon- Rob C. was the best, but the 2nd best player won Pearl Islands- best player won All Stars- best player won Vanuatu- best player won Palau- best player won Guatemala- best player won Panama- Cirie was the best, but the 2nd best player won Cook Islands- best player won Fiji- best player won China- best player won Micronesia- best player won Gabon- hard to judge since the one who accomplished the most gameplay wise wasn't playing to win, so it's hard to call her the best player Tocantins- best player won Samoa- best player won I think the best player is almost always the person who does what they need to do to win better than any other player. That's the goal, so it's hard to say that someone who couldn't accomplish that is better than someone who did.
Axie.rsfd		#10	[-]
Posts: 860 (01/10/10 09:11 PM) More Recent Posts	Best player is the one that wins. Period. We've had a thread about this already! Part of the game is getting to the F2/F3. All of them did that, some of the "best players" by most people didn't (Rob C., Ami, Cirie, Fairplay, Yau Man). then, the other part is getting the most votes from the jury, be the jury bitter or not, whatever their criteria is; you need to work around that. And some of the "best players" failed at that (Rob M., Sugar, S'ME, Stephen, and ew, Queefstain). You can bitch and defend your favorite players all you want, but long story short, all nineteen winners on the new delicious LTS banner deserved the title. Even Ambuh and Bob.
AveryC		#11	[-]
Posts: 250 (01/10/10 09:20 PM) More Recent Posts	By defination the winner is the best player, and this has held true amongst many seasons. The only counters to this are production errors and maybe medivacs. I'd also say if the winner isn't aware of what is going on and why things happened then a case could also be made against them. The following are not debatable to me: Richard Tina Ethan (Production Error here, but he was guranteed the Final 2 anyway). Vecepia (Kathy comes close) Brian Sandra Chris Tom Danni Yul Earl J.T. Natalie Jenna suffers from having Rob C there, as well as her attitude and her decisions based on that. Amber/Rob is very close, but I think Amber has the edge over him. Aras is also tough because of Cirie. Maybe he passes? To me Amanda played the best game and Courtney gave the best jury speech. I guess Todd works for not sucking visibly at either one. Parvati's hurt by the Fairplay/Jonathan/Kathy/James situation and what that resulted in. Not sure about her. Bob is the obvious anomaly. But he was in a season where nobody was all that great. Susie stands out as the only person who didn't really make any errors.
ilovekelly752		#12	[-]
Posts: 1027 (01/10/10 09:45 PM) More Recent Posts	AveryC wrote: Susie stands out as the only person who didn't really make any errors. She could've not fought with Randy over a cookie. If she did that, she would've won, and have easily been the best player that season.
ilovekelly752		#13	[-]
Posts: 1028 (01/10/10 09:47 PM) More Recent Posts	Axie wrote: Best player is the one that wins. Period. We've had a thread about this already! Part of the game is getting to the F2/F3. All of them did that, some of the "best players" by most people didn't (Rob C., Ami, Cirie, Fairplay, Yau Man). then, the other part is getting the most votes from the jury, be the jury bitter or not, whatever their criteria is; you need to work around that. And some of the "best players" failed at that (Rob M., Sugar, S'ME, Stephen, and ew, Queefstain). You can bitch and defend your favorite players all you want, but long story short, all nineteen winners on the new delicious LTS banner deserved the title. Even Ambuh and Bob. X on the main idea of the post, but who is the person in the bold?
Axie.rsfd		#14	[-]
Posts: 865 (01/10/10 09:48 PM) More Recent Posts	Russhole, but of course.
ilovekelly752		#15	[-]
Posts: 1029 (01/10/10 09:50 PM) More Recent Posts	I CAN REMOVE is 100 times more important than IQ. Remove this ad Axie wrote: Russhole, but of course. lol, I get it

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

The best player won!!!

The best player won!!!