Performance Comparison Thread (cause you know someone else did it better) in American Idol/X-Factor Forum

0 Points

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Performance Comparison Thread (cause you know someone else did it better)

Started By

Comment

Miraclemax

Performance Comparison Thread (cause you know someone else did it better)

Lead

[-]

Posts: 3945

03/24/10 02:17 PM

Registered User

All Idol / X-Factor /Rockstar shows welcome.

Advertisement
	Remove this ad Remove this ad

Miraclemax

[-]

Posts: 3945

03/24/10 02:48 PM

Registered User

I hate you Paige for making me appreciate Mark Day.�

Top 16 - Mark Day - Against All Odds
Uploaded by idol_fanatic. - Full seasons and entire episodes online.

Liquidsunshine

[-]

Posts: 5612

03/24/10 05:43 PM

Registered user

There is no comparison, really.
(ETA: I'd forgotten about that creeper dude in red next to Seacrest at the beginning.

)

�
��

Miraclemax

[-]

Posts: 3945

03/24/10 05:50 PM

Registered User

That wasn't even David's best performance and it's still better than all things AI9. Why have I never noticed that wierd dude in red before? lol

I knew there are a lot of "Against All Odds" performances but I didn't remember even half of them. Ramiele >>>>> Paige too.

dagny1331

[-]

Posts: 4298

03/24/10 05:54 PM

MESS member

SHC is sooo going to have a field day in this thread, lol.

suckshardcore

[-]

Posts: 38413

03/24/10 05:55 PM

Registered user

SHC is sooo going to have a field day in this thread, lol.

This is my thread.

Liquidsunshine

[-]

Posts: 5612

03/24/10 05:55 PM

Registered user

Truth, Max. It's a pretty sad state of affairs for AI 9 when someone's *pretty good* performance from AI7 beats most of AI9 to a pulp.

Oh god, Ramiele sang Against All Odds, too? Did I repress that??

suckshardcore

[-]

Posts: 38413

03/24/10 05:58 PM

Registered user

This is so fucking sad but...

Liquidsunshine

[-]

Posts: 5612

03/24/10 05:59 PM

Registered user

Well, SHC? We're waiting! Post stuff!

Miraclemax

[-]

Posts: 3945

03/24/10 06:00 PM

Registered User

All this season is doing is reminding me of mostly CI/AuI/Rockstar performances that I prefered.

suckshardcore

[-]

Posts: 38413

03/24/10 06:00 PM

Registered user

Its sad when I remember Mantasia doing songs better than you.

Last night's songs were mostly overdone AI shit though, OzI and CI contestants generally have better taste in songs so I can't remember many who've picked the shit from last night.

Gary Morissette <3 So robbed. Didn't care about Omar but he's better than any black guy AI has ever had on and you know how much I hate Drewche but he's better than all AI9's male contestants.

Advertisement
	Remove this ad

suckshardcore

[-]

Posts: 38413

03/24/10 06:11 PM

Registered user

Yes, Paige, one of Kat's lesser performances and Scott fucking Savol did better than you. (I actually loved Scott).

suckshardcore

[-]

Posts: 38413

03/24/10 06:15 PM

Registered user

Not from last night but I need to reinforce how much Paige sucks.

dagny1331

[-]

Posts: 4298

03/24/10 06:15 PM

MESS member

We need to bring JD's performance of YCAGWYW, Ryan Star's Paint It Black and Dilana's Ring of Fire from Rockstar to this thread for comparison. (I lack the skillz for vid posting.)

tia

suckshardcore

[-]

Posts: 38413

03/24/10 06:17 PM

Registered user

dags go to Youtube and copy the embed code for the video you want, then in the reply box click the little button that says HTML (hypertext markup language ftw!) and paste the code in after the tags that show up. It only lets you do 2 videos at a time for some reason and don't type anything under the videos or it won't show up.

suckshardcore

[-]

Posts: 38413

03/24/10 06:20 PM

Registered user

Casey was pretty good but I think I prefer James' version.

dashbrdparadise

[-]

Posts: 5307

03/24/10 06:24 PM

I don't get
most of the jokes

lol at Simon crushing on her

suckshardcore

[-]

Posts: 38413

03/24/10 06:27 PM

Registered user

This is better than Mike's "When A Man(atee) Loves A Woman" ...

suckshardcore

[-]

Posts: 38413

03/24/10 06:30 PM

Registered user

I was going to post Bucky's "Superstition" too.

Okay Amandine and her French accent are better than Manatee too.

Drew B

[-]

Posts: 8345

03/24/10 06:30 PM

Registered User

Liquidsunshine wrote:
Truth, Max.�It's a pretty sad state of affairs for AI 9 when someone's *pretty good* performance from AI7 beats most of AI9 to a pulp.

How about when a completely unpimped fodder's version from a previous season is way better than a TCO front-runner? Sorry, Shove-on!