Quote:
AMERICAN BEAUTY IS NOT ON THE FUCKING BULLSHIT LIST?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!!!!
I KNOW!
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Cuauhtemoc Cosby |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
Quote: I KNOW! |
|||
ProbstFan123 |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
No L.A. Confidential?
Sad. Grim. Pathetic. |
|||
Ginawantsme |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
How is "Casablanca" not #1? That is rediculous!! - Also "It's a Wonderful Life" should be higher.
"Titanic" on the list is just pure crap. It was one of the worst movies I ever watched. Thank god "Dances w/ Wolves" is gone. |
|||
Survivor Boy |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
Quote: Seriously. The competely snubbed all Kevin Spacey movies. .. and why was E.T. so high on the list? If Snow White is going to be that high up too, Toy Story should be in the Top 40 as well. |
|||
Gregoire |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
Overall a MUCH MUCH better list than the one ten years ago. Some real critic's darlings placed high (Sullivans Travels, The General!!) I was actually interested and pleased watching this. Movies like Intolerance and Virginia Woolf should have been on the FIRST list
The big winners -- The Searchers, City Lights, Vertigo, Raging Bull Clearly a bigger appreciation for silent films, and a decent showing of recent films. I really object to Raging Bull being in the top 10 (if they were going to move up City Lights, they should have put that there instead) last ranking - and how they rank now 1 Citizen Kane (1941) still the ONE 2 Casablanca (1942) down 1 to 3 3 The Godfather (1972) up 1 to 2 4 Gone with the Wind (1939) down 2 to 6 5 Lawrence of Arabia (1962) down 2 to 7 6 The Wizard of Oz (1939) down 4 to 10 7 The Graduate (1967) down 10 to 17 8 On the Waterfront (1954) down 11 to 19 9 Schindler's List (1993) up 1 to 8 10 Singin' in the Rain (1952) up 5 to 5 11 It's a Wonderful Life (1946) down 9 to 20 12 Sunset Boulevard (1950) down 4 to 16 13 The Bridge on the River Kwai (1957) down 23 to 36 14 Some Like It Hot (1959) down 8 to 22 15 Star Wars (1977) up 2 to 13 16 All About Eve (1950) down 12 to 28 17 The African Queen (1951) down 48 to 65 18 Psycho (1960) up 4 to 14 19 Chinatown (1974) down 2 to 21 20 One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest (1975) down 13 to 33 21 The Grapes of Wrath (1940) down 2 to 23 22 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968) up 7 to 15 23 The Maltese Falcon (1941) down 8 to 31 24 Raging Bull (1980) up 20 to 4, wtf?! 25 E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (1982) up 1 to 24 26 Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb (1964) down 13 to 39 27 Bonnie and Clyde (1967) down 15 to 42 28 Apocalypse Now (1979) down 2 to 30 29 Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1939) up 3 to 26 30 The Treasure of the Sierra Madre (1948) down 8 to 38 31 Annie Hall (1977) down 4 to 35 32 The Godfather Part II (1974) same as before! 33 High Noon (1952) up 6 to 27 34To Kill a Mockingbird (1962) up 9 to 25 35 It Happened One Night (1934) down 11 to 46 36 Midnight Cowboy (1969) down 7 to 43 37 The Best Years of Our Lives (1946) same as before! 38 Double Indemnity (1944) up 9 to 29 39 Doctor Zhivago (1965) OUT 40 North by Northwest (1959) down 15 to 55 41 West Side Story (1961) down 10 to 51 42 Rear Window (1954) down 6 to 48 43 King Kong (1933) up 2 to 41 44 The Birth of a Nation (1915) OUT 45 A Streetcar Named Desire (1951) down 2 to 47 46 A Clockwork Orange (1971) down 34 to 70 47 Taxi Driver (1976) down 5 to 52 48 Jaws (1975) down 8 to 56 49 Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1937) up 15 to 34 50 Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969) down 23 to 73 51 The Philadelphia Story (1940) up 7 to 44 52 From Here to Eternity (1953) OUT 53 Amadeus (1984) OUT 54 All Quiet on the Western Front (1930)OUT 55 The Sound of Music (1965) up 15 to 40 56 M*A*S*H (1970) up 2 to 54 57 The Third Man (1949) OUT 58 Fantasia (1940) OUT 59 Rebel Without a Cause (1955) OUT 60 Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981) down 6 to 66 61 Vertigo (1958) up 52 to 9 62 Tootsie (1982) down 7 to 69 63 Stagecoach (1939) OUT 64 Close Encounters of the Third Kind (1977) OUT 65 The Silence of the Lambs (1991) down 9 to 74 66 Network (1976) up to 64 67 The Manchurian Candidate (1962) OUT 68 An American in Paris (1951) OUT 69 Shane (1953) up 24 to 45 70 The French Connection (1971) down 23 to 93 71 Forrest Gump (1994) down 5 to 76 72 Ben-Hur (1959) down 28 to 100 73 Wuthering Heights (1939) OUT 74 The Gold Rush (1925) up 16 to 58 75 Dances with Wolves (1990) OUT 76 City Lights (1931) up 65 to 11! 77 American Graffiti (1973) up 15 to 62 78 Rocky (1976) up 21 to 57 79 The Deer Hunter (1978) up 26 to 53 80 The Wild Bunch (1969) up 1 to 79 81 Modern Times (1936) up 3 to 78 82 Giant (1956) OUT 83 Platoon (1986) down 3 to 86 84 Fargo (1996) OUT 85 Duck Soup (1933) up 25 to 60 86 Mutiny on the Bounty (1935) OUT 87 Frankenstein (1931) OUT 88 Easy Rider (1969) up 4 to 84 89 Patton (1970) OUT 90 The Jazz Singer (1927) OUT 91 My Fair Lady (1964) OUT 92 A Place in the Sun (1951) OUT 93 The Apartment (1960) up 13 to 80 94 Goodfellas (1990) up 2 to 92 95 Pulp Fiction (1994) up 1 to 94 96 The Searchers (1956) up 85 to 12! 97 Bringing Up Baby (1938) up 9 to 86 98 Unforgiven (1992) up 30 to 68 99 Guess Who's Coming to Dinner (1967) OUT 100 Yankee Doodle Dandy (1942) up 2 to 98 NEW 18 THE GENERAL (!) - the lists biggest snub from ten years ago, finally redeemed 49 Intolerance (and Birth of a Nation gone!) 50 Lord of the Rings (all of them? Godfather and Godfather 2 are on the list) 59 Nashville 61 Sullivans Travels 63 Cabaret 67 Whos Afraid of Virginia Woolf? 71 Saving Private Ryan 72 The Shawshank Redemption 75 In The Heat of the Night 77 All The Presidents Men 81 Spartacus 82 Sunrise (Im impressed, who thought THIS would sneak on?) 83 Titanic 85 A Night At The Opera 87 12 Angry Men 89 The Sixth Sense (the most senseless addition) 90 Swing Time 91 Sophie's Choice 95 Last Picture Show 96 Do The Right Thing 97 Blade Runner 99 Toy Story |
|||
aspects13 |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
Of the new movies, ones I have not yet seen: Intolerance, Nashville, Sophie's Choice, The Last Picture Show, and Do the Right Thing.
I think Sunrise is the best movie of the new movies. (I actually just purchased the Best Picture Movie Collection on Friday to get this movie.) Personal favorites that fell off the list: Amadeus, Fantasia, The Machurian Candidate, and Patton. Still sad that Rebecca could not make either list. |
|||
PunkinHeadToo |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
Any list that moves up To Kill a Mockingbird is the right list!
Seriously, it is a better list. Still some bumps, but better. |
|||
Piranhahaha |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
Gregoire, that was some aweome work there.
Well done! |
|||
BillNyeSurvivorGuy |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
Yeah thanks a bunch Gregoire I don't really want to be an AFI member just to see these lists. Also thanks for the time put in.
Couldn't they just have had Godfather at #1 just for the hell of it? I mean is it really noticeably worse than Citizen Kane? Most people who worked on Citizen Kane are dead anyway so nobody's gonna be offended if you fudge a bit :P Besides, are we just going to slave the classics forever and ever? We'll get old and decrepit and our sons and then grandsons will have to hear some old a-hole from my generation (maybe me :P) INSIST Kane is the greatest ever... in 2041, even if it is 100 years old, blah blah blah. I want to feel like we are growing, I think modern America wants a movie to feel like it's own, Godfather IS America's modern movie masterpiece, we don't need to shove old movies down all our throats when there is some real good cinema out there that came out within 30 years. Sorry had to get that rant out of my system there, I apologize. Also a bit miffed about LOTR having to be a spot lower then that weird old silent epic. If a movie does it better, it should be higher, not the originator. So switch the order. I don't think the model T is better than my car today, but I do appreciate the man who built it though. I ain't sayin don't have the film on at all though. It's probably amazing. I'll need to check it out someday. But all this talk like "OMG they built all these sets!!!" Well, what about Hobbiton? A lot of stuff was set work and yes a lot of miniatures and CGI but the sets in LOTR movies are all really well done too! Anyway... I bet in 10 years a Pixar movie breaks into the top 75, maybe Toy Story again but they are really special films they make. I guess I am just a fan boy but I love Pixar. Gee I'm not sure if Raging Bull was all that, brilliant film by a huge degree of course, but I really liked Goodfellas and would have ranked it higher myself... Also they majorly blew their wad with Shawshank and SVP back to back. Then it felt like forever until a movie made in the last 20 years appeared. Well good times were had by all :D Sorry for my long lengthy blog styled post, I just get passionate. |
|||
Aye Too Tacky |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
You ingrates!
|
|||
BillNyeSurvivorGuy |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
Wow i'm a windy bastard today but I got to say I never thought i'd see The Third Man get snubbed, that is kinda wrong.
I thought Fargo was untouchable but I guess we have seen better these days... shrug... all I know is Ebert may die tonight. No manchurian candidate or from here to eternity? Not completely objecting but...wow... never thought i'd see that either. This list was almost more interesting for what they left out! |
|||
PunkinHeadToo |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
I agree with updating our standards (no one wants a Model T!) but what place should a piece have that set the standard? There would be no cars at all without the Model T...so does it deserve some mention as a forerunner and move on?? I think that's the dilemma with some of these films. Look at some of the crap that's rated above Dr. Strangelove. Do we know what the criteria is/are? If that's universally known, excuse my ignorance. I'm really only looking at the list as a film buff, not a pro.
|
|||
Charlie the Big Dog |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
Posts: 4939 (06/21/07 1:33 AM) Registered user |
No Back to the Future?
Well, I guess a movie is not funny if it doesn't star Charlie Chaplin, Buster Keaton, The Marx Brothers, or a guy dressed like a woman. |
||
zeneth18 |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
Thank God Crash is not in the top 100. Overall, a good list.
|
|||
A Bartholomew |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
Wow, The Last Picture Show made the list? I loved that movie.
|
|||
bluesboi |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
Quote: Well deserved. Quote: BULLSHIT!!!! |
|||
dayzdnconfuzd |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
Quote: I agree... I'd rather see them pick a certain number of important movies per decade so that each generation has an equal showing. And then rank them accordingly. I think the older movies get more credibility just because they are older. That's agism |
|||
nuclear snake |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
Good to see Nashville, Cabaret and The Last Picture Show on the list. Nashville should have been much, much higher on the list, though.
|
|||
Gregoire |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
If you stepped foot in one film class in the past ten years, you could have probably predicted some of these trends:
- a surge in the importance of films from the 70s - increased importance of old comedians over new - the continued disinterest in the musical - renewed interest in older films from big artists (Katharine Hepburn's Philadelphia Story and Bringing Up Baby rise, African Queen falls) - recent box office as a sign of quality (Sixth Sense, Titanic) - rescuing two artists from near obscurity (Buster Keaton, Preston Sturges) - horror shunned - an appreciation on early films that tackled social issues that are relavant today (The Searchers, In the Heat of the Night) - renewed interest in silent films (while noticably shunning what was once considered the 'best', The Birth of a Nation) - the imdb.com predicator (Shawshank Redemption, 12 Angry Men) And Vertigo being restamped as the 'ultimate' Hitchcock film is a recent phenomenon. In general, movies that have iconic stars playing psychologically flawed characters like John Wayne in the Searchers and Stewart in Vertigo have gotten a lot of renewed attention. I still cant account for the sudden huge popularity of Raging Bull. I really really wish this wasnt a list produced by the American Film Institute because it would be amazing to see a list of the greatest films of all time worldwide. Lists like this seem very strange without movies like Metropolis, Das Boot and la Dolce Vita, all were big movies in America but just werent made here. (And werent Clockwork Orange and Lawrence of Arabia British productions anyway?) |
|||
Glebe220 |
Re: AFI's Top 100 Movies - 10th Anniversary Edition | ||
|
Bridge on the River Kwai dropping 23 spots and North by Northwest dropping 15 were my biggest disappointments
|
|||